Based on 274 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
4535 Buffalo Rd, Erie, PA 16510
Phone: (814) 899-7811
Website: http://mydadspizzaanddeli.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 3–10 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Logan R.
6/15/23 We are visiting the lake from north eastern PA. Ordered a large extra cheese. It was really good and fresh. A thicker crust with more thick sauce. Lots of cheese. The large is a 14″ pizza, so it’s not huge. It ran us only $13 and change with tax. Highly recommend.
… more
Adan Pena
The Pizza ball and Combo ball were delicious. Crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Definitely recommend these menu items. Mozzarella sticks were good, pretty standard flavor. Boneless wings and pizza were a bit lackluster. I got the Buffalo boneless wings and just didn’t taste like any Buffalo sauce i’ve had. Wings were particularly oily which was weird and so the flavor was a mix of that and a hot sauce. I got the bbq chicken pizza, the bacon was nicely crispy which was probably the highlight. I liked the idea of all the different toppings, but there wasn’t enough sauce to even it out. So the thick layer of cheese and the chicken just overpowered every bite.
… more
Kate Schaaf
My only complaint is that sometimes I swear they take the phone off the hook because half the time we call, it just rings busy for extended periods of time. My guess is they are just too busy. We love My Dad’s pizza. It is a favorite. Best place in harborcreek to get wings and we love the pizza.
… more
Jeffrey balogh
the person that took the order was very friendly. The pizza was loaded with toppings and the sauce was great! and the driver had impeccable service! If I could rate a 6 I would
… more
Peter Snedeker
It’s easy to complain, especially when it’s a misunderstanding. I had ordered a pizza, and didn’t know that I had to ask for fresh dough to get a fresh dough pizza. They willingly made a new pizza with fresh dough. Thank you to the staff.
… more
David Zielinski
Great food! Just one thing. Your dressing containers open up and spill all over inside the sub bag. Happened twice. Please get better containers unless employees aren’t closing them all the way. please address. Thank you!
… more
Ben D
Got Steak salad and 6 bonless wings. Wings were cold, soggy and floating in sauce. The steak salad was disgusting. Cold chopped up roast beef with cold canned mushrooms and cheddar cheese. It was awful. Actually picked around the toppings just to eat the iceberg.
… more
Edith Wakeley
Very generous with the toppings and delicious sauce. Usually, I don’t like thicker crust but I loved it!
… more
D L
This was my first time trying My Dads Pizza…I thought I would never find a pizza i enjoyed as much as my childhood favorite which closed down many years ago ( Pio’s Pizza on East Ave.) This pizza was the best i have had for many, many years and the menu and pizza shop atmosphere was like going back in time.
… more
Shane Ferrara
Wings are great, service is great. Pizza is decent quality but a little unremarkable. Needs to be a little more generous with the cheese and Pep but when compared to the big chains, My Dads pizza holds their own. Be patient, they are a small business who has dealt with staffing issues…but it is worth the wait. Support local, and make My Dads a consideration when ordering out.
… more
… View more