Counter-serve chain offering pizza with lots of toppings in original or thinner-crust versions. Based on 130 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2523 Grand Ave, Laramie, WY 82070
Phone: (307) 742-5467
Website: https://mrjims.pizza/144.cfm
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Gr Basham
Mr. Jim’s pizza was a great pizza at great price. This is the second time we have ordered from this restaurant. This time we tried the meat eater pizza with the garlic parmesan crust. There are several different flavors of crust to try. Mr. Jim’s pizza came with a lot of toppings great tasting cheese and a tangy pizza sauce. Definitely recommend this restaurant. Staff was friendly pizza was cooked to perfection.
… more
Mark Moriarty
I went to Mr. Jim’s here in Laramie on Monday, July 10th. Their pizza blew me away !!!. It says when you walk in : ” It’s in the crust “. Well , if you LOVE thin crust that is VERY crunchy and NOT soggy , you’ll love Mr. Jim’s Pizza!!. From now on , there’s no more Papa John’s Pizza ; Pizza Hut; Domino’s ( which I used to go to 3-4 times a month since I moved here from Denver in 2019 ) for me !!. I not only live close ( walking distance) from Alibi’s Pizza. Well , that’s the correct name for that ” Char- broiled ” Pizza that’s 1/4 – 1/3 crust with very few toppings on my Pizza, as well. I also ordered ” Extra tomato sauce!. You can’t put enough tomato sauce on my Pizza!!”. Well , when the server brought my Pizza to me, I could tell by looking at it before taking the 1st bite , that the crust was dry as a bone !!. I told the ” server ” that this is NOT how I ordered this !!. Remember– ” I said VERY HEAVY tomato sauce “??. She didn’t say a word ; turned around & went back to the kitchen and brought out a VERY SMALL amount of very cold tomato sauce that was ridiculously cold & bland !!. I WOULDN’T GO BACK THERE IF THEY PAID ME to eat that ” Pizza ” !!. No way !!. Papa John’s is no better regarding sauce or amount of toppings & Pizza Hut is a joke !!. I doubt that they will be open by the end of this year – 2023 !!. EVERY time that I have walked in there place , I talk to a new face !!. They stopped their ” Lunch Buffet ” in May , I believe, because they were losing money by throwing out MORE ” product” than they sold –The Manager- told me ( who is now LONG GONE !! )!!. Dominos on Grand Avenue must rely on University students that are in a ” Coma ” from studying & NOT realizing what exactly they are eating ! ALOT of dough ; hardly any tomato sauce & their Sausage seems like it’s ” imitation ” , NOT only by the way it looks , but tastes as well !!. Well , all of these experiences are now in the past , so like it’s been said ” water under the bridge ” . Finally , Mr. Jim’s Pizza ‘s Manager near The Rib & Chop restaurant & just East of The Hilton Hotel here is a ” Fantastic ” guy named Matthew ( I think ) & he PERSONALLY asked me twice if ” everything was OK ” . Mr. Jim’s also has a basket FULL of packets of Parmesan cheese & crushed red pepper flakes for FREE !!. Another plus. Domino’s charges $1.00 for ANY SMALL Parmesan or crushed red pepper flakes or garlic sauce, etc. And I mean ” SMALL “. Well , that’s all I can say about Mr.Jim’s Pizza here . I was set in my ways of going to Domino’s on Grand Avenue, but NOT anymore !!. NO WAY !. Also , Mr. Jim’s Pizza is not only inexpensive, but they have coupons on-line & on their menus inside the store / restaurant . Last thing , Mr. Jim’s Pizza has a ” Happy Hour ” , I guess you’d call it , which I missed out on. Oh well , I’m going back again tomorrow & can’t wait. Their toppings are ” over the top ( pings ) ” in taste , but also the amount that they put on the Pizza ( at least the one I had ) . That’s it !!. I complimented Matthew on his GREAT Customer Service , plus their Pizza & he entered in my name and contact info to receive coupons in the mail , as well as email ” Specials and coupons/ discounts “. Tell Matthew that you heard about Mr. Jim’s Pizza from me — Mark Moriarty . Maybe I’ll get a ” Freebie ” pie if enough new customers go there !!. I’m just kidding. Go check them out & get ” converted ” to Mr. Jim’s Pizza like I have. I can’t wait till’ I get off work today , so that I can bolt over to Mr. Jim’s Pizza and get my pizza and eat inside their store . I don’t know their hours but I ” think ” until 10.00 P.M. ( ?? ). ENJOY!!!!. Bye , Mark Moriarty.
… more
maxine williams
Ohhh YEAHHH! I used to order from Dominoes. And I’ve tried Hambone…. But Mr Jim’s is the Winner! The Pizza was loaded with ingredients, and fresh & tasty. Delivered in 30 minutes.
… more
Clifton Dugan
order there a lot tonight I ordered a coke and a pizza. Rather than call to say they had to coke they sent diet driver gave me my stuff and ran manager absolutely refused to fix it. This place is total trash and they lost a really good customer I pretty much always tips $10 or better and they can’t bring me my coke. The whole purpose is k have company and didn’t want to leave the house. When some one makes a mistake they should fix it not just say I’m sorry.
… more
Parking Full Time
Nice crust with a crispy-on-the-outside but chewy-on-the-inside texture. Not a lot of flavor other than the slightly spicy sausage. Not great, but better than your average college town pizza.
… more
Melissa Pulley
Great pizza from Mr. Jim’s in Laramie, WY! We ordered the Meat Eaters Pizza (with 5 meats). Prefect amount of toppings and well-seasoned. We ordered online and picked up curbside on a stop of a cross-country drive. Would definitely eat again.
… more
Chris Thomas
Not very pleased with my order! One of my pizzas looked like they dropped it. Folded almost in half. Probably won’t order from them again!
… more
Aysegul D. (Aysha)
Horrible employee attitude! Online system gives 15-20 minutes wait time and when I told them about it he got upset. I under they are packed but he should learn how to talk to a customer.
… more
mark poage
Great calzone, stuffed with fillings, yummy crust. The brownie is huge but could taste a bit better. Staff were prompt and nice. Recommend if you’re in Laramie and want some good pizza
… more
NOT A Russian Spy
I want to start by saying I do not like to write bad reviews however sometimes do when it is due.
… more
… View more