Mr. Italiano’s is one of North Caldwell’s most popular. Give them a try, and you’ll soon understand why.
It’s not just pizza. You can also find pasta, sandwiches, and other side dishes at independent pizzerias in North Caldwell Try something new and expand your culinary horizons.
Try french fries with your pizza. If you have a family to fee or just a big appetite, you can make your meal into a feast!
Based on 21 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
Address:
711 Main St, North Caldwell, NJ 07006
Phone: (973) 339-9985
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Marc Mc
A wonderful addition to the neighborhood. Super friendly staff and the order and prep is quick. I was a bit skeptical at first, as I’ve tried every other Pizza place in the area and there is little deviation usually. I always start with a regular pie with pepperoni to get a feel for the slice. The sauce on the pizza is perfect, less sweet than local places and truly reminded me of a slice from Queens where I grew up. There was no flop, it was perfectly cooked, little to no oil leaking, and a really fluffy and delicious crust. The mozzarella was a traditional taste that I really enjoyed. We got a side of garlic bread and got to really taste their sauce with that, it was great. For under $25 for a large pie and a side I have zero complaints. I’ll definitely be back! I recommend parking on a side street closeby, as you can’t park out front. It’ll take less than a minute to walk.
… more
Robert Graber
Saw this new place that opened up. Said let’s give it a try. Tried the Parm Please Sandwich
… more
Adam C.
Ok this place has the goods…easily ordered, picked up with no problems, friendly staff…seems like a mom and pop spot which I always like. Food is slamming, take it to the face!
… more
Dee G
I ordered lunch for our staff and was very pleased. I was actually shocked at the large size of the burger. We ordered a variety of dishes and everyone loved the food. The prices are very reasonable and the service is great. We will be happy to order again.
… more
Gerry Paolino
We ordered from here when they opened and the food was good and so were the prices. A month later prices went up and food was not so good plus the delivery person left OUR ORDER ON THE GROUND AND NEVER RANG THE DOORBELL. We will not order from them in the future.
… more
Sani
Just writing this review I’m giving credibility to this place as establishment, which is not what I want to give!
… more
Ramsey Abdallah
Great pizza, their sauce is perfect and they don’t go cheap on cheese. Great addition to the neighborhood. The staff is awesome and welcoming and friendly. This will become our new spot for pizza!!!
… more
Carlos Carrasco
My wife and I have ordered twice and loved the food. First time we ordered a Sicilian pie and the other time a sausage sandwich and chicken vodka parm dinner. Great addition to the neighborhood!
… more
TJ Raff
Saw boxes of frozen dough. They do not make there own. You can taste the difference. Save your money for real authentic pizza. Sandwiches are light on meat. TJ Raff
… more
Love M Gaillard, MSW
I just dropped in randomly an notice the server did not wash his hands. I mentioned it. He apologized…but a big guy who say he cooks in the back. He yelled to me, do you think you’re special? They wiped their hands. I touch everything. I dont care..yada yada.
… more
… View more