Long-standing mountain lodge with picnic areas & trails, plus a restaurant, bar & live music. Based on 999 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
109 Main St, Greer, AZ 85927
Phone: (928) 735-7226
Website: https://mollybutlerlodge1910.com/
Hours
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
J. N.
This is a must-experience when you are in the White Mountains of AZ! It is located in beautiful Greer, so the scenery is fantastic. I highly recommend reservations or getting there a bit earlier than they open. We went for dinner, but they are open for lunch a few days a week also. The restaurant itself is upscale rustic, complementing the mountain scenery. The hostess Irene was friendly, helpful, and attentive. She answered all our questions and helped us choose menu items. Our waitress Mikayla did a great job getting our orders correct and keeping our drinks filled. Since we had 7 of us, we tried a good variety of menu items ranging from spaghetti with huge meatballs to filet mignon to mahi mahi. The mashed potatoes and gravy were amazing. All of the food was delicious! We were so full, but we wanted to try dessert. I ordered a slice of cherry pie, planning to take one bite and then take it home with me. It never made it to the take out box because it was probably the best piece of pie I’ve ever eaten. Seriously. And I’ve tried a lot of pie! I highly recommend this place.
… more
Pipes
Have been here twice and this is a mountain gem. Food is always spot on, service is great and atmosphere is welcoming and relaxing. Was there in June and had steak/butterfly shrimp and sides, delish! A few new places have popped up over the years but Molly Butler continues to be the anchor of Greer!
… more
Bruce Sherman
In the very small town of Greer, AZ there are few option for dining out and The Molly Butler Restaurant is the best of them – and busiest. Centered on the main street through town the historical lodge and restaurant is very charming and any seat in the place has a nice view. Great rustic atmosphere and well chosen decor perfectly matches the spirit and charm that is Greer. The menu is much like that of a typical steak house. We ordered two of their ribeye dishes. The quality of the cuts of meat we had were not up to par with many of the steak places we’ve been to in the same price range. On our visit we found the meals to be just okay and didn’t live up to the delightful upscale look and feel they have created. That said, if you’re in Greer, it’s a “must visit”. The staff was wonderful and the views make for a great backdrop for a nice dinning experience. Absolutely make reservations and call in advance to confirm hours of operation as they can fluctuate throughout the seasons.
… more
Kathleen Gherkins
Good food and friendly service. The atmosphere felt rustic and historic. Big windows to view the beautiful meadow and mountains. The server was kind, friendly, and thoughtful. Keep in mind that if you have a group larger than 8, there will be a 20% tip already added to your bill.
… more
Jim “TorpedoJones” Noble
Went WAY out of their way to accommodate our large group’s last minute and oddball requests. Treated us much better than it would have been reasonable to expect. Good people. I would not consider a trip through this area without a visit to Molly’s
… more
Shad Ahlstrom
Had a GREAT time here! Food was great, service was great, atmosphere was great. Couldn’t have asked for a better birthday dinner for my wife. We both had the baked Cod special with clam chowder. It was very good. We will definitely eat here again next time we’re in Greer.
… more
Haripriya Vallabhaneni
This is one of the oldest restaurants in Greer which serves amazing food. Their customer service is great as they are very friendly and welcoming. They serve freshly baked breads n pies which u cannot miss.
… more
ana guzman
One of 3 restaurants to grab a bite to eat in Greer. This was a nice place small menu but good options. My blt and ceaser salad was yummy.
… more
William Cloud (az96cat)
Beautiful mountain scenery. Classic hotel and restaurant that serves high quality and affordable food and drinks. I love that they have local beers too! Staff are all friendly and excited to help. Irene is the best!
… more
Angela
Love this place the food never disappoints. Steaks are super tender. We usually sit in the bar area. We had two drinks apiece plus two filets and apple pie all top notch! Highly recommend.
… more
… View more