We are the Home of the Square Pizza where We don’t cut corners, we fill the box! Offering a nice variety of pizzas, subs, sandwiches and salads! Pick-up or FREE Delivery available. (Dining Temporarily Closed).
Mill Street Pizza continues a hometown tradition that dates back over 30 years in the same location! We gladly combined some of those past traditions while starting some new ones! We have brought back the ULTIMATE PARTY PIZZA…THE 20 GUTBUSTER! Only now it’s SQUARE!
Our team takes pride in our pizzas! If we won’t eat it, we won’t send it. We strive to be consistent with not only taste, but presentation. We want our customers to know they are getting a high quality product every time they order. ~Chris Blackmore (Owner)
Based on 51 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
160 W Mill St, Bloomfield, IN 47424
Phone: (812) 384-4747
Website: https://pizzaonmillstreet.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday |
4–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday |
Closed |
| Wednesday |
4–8 PM |
| Thursday |
4–8 PM |
| Friday |
4–9 PM |
| Saturday |
4–9 PM |
Reviews
Ron Hamilton
Great food in a clean and friendly environment!
Brent R.
Only thin crust pizza here. But it was good. Breadsticks good also. No refills on drinks just a 20oz bottle. But that’s ok if you know before you go. I’d come back.
Phillip Adcock
I stopped into this place tonight as my wife & I were looking to try something new. Since we had not been here before, we decided to try the Special “The Sampler Box”” This was by far the best bang for our buck meal we’ve had in a while. The quality of the food was excellent and the sampler had a couple extra things I wouldn’t have expected from a pizza place. I’m so glad we stopped into this place and I will definately be back.
Alb
The delivery service was amazing!!! Haydi brought pizza all the way out to the back of the property and walked it all the way up, she was SO NICE!!! YOU’RE THE BEST HAYDI, YOU’RE DOING AN AMAZING JOB!!!
Cami Mattingly
Both my and hubby and I enjoyed the pizzas we ordered. Nice to see the dining room still closed. I felt safe picking up my pizza. Just wish the staff had been wearing masks.
Camillya Duncan
I will never give this place my business again!!! I ordered from there for the first time because I’m new to the area and needed delivery that day and they are the only place around that delivers. They got my order all wrong and they were rude and didn’t care to make my order right. I mean who orders nachos with meat and cheese only and gets nothing but a container full of nothing but meat and melted cheese. The meat was flavorless and they didn’t send several other items that I ordered. They called me after telling me they would make it right and told me that I didn’t order the stuff that I had ordered and that they weren’t going to do anything about it. I mentioned the place to a relative that is from the area and she said she learned her lesson about ordering from there and won’t be back as well.
… more
D B
Cheeseburgers and the BBQ Stromboli is very Good (as an older person the BBQ Stromboli reminded me of the TEXAS BBQ I used to get at a Local Pizza shop at home)Thank You and keep the good food coming. Have a great Day!
Blue Barn Hill Farm
Best Pizza Place currently in our town … wish they had a few more unique options … but they do make a perfect cheese and basic pizza
Tom Macwatters
Absolutely delicious I have had many pizzas this pizza is great. I’m a truck driver and it’s hard to get local pizza from the small mom and pop type places I’m glad they deliver. In case you would like to know what pizza I ordered you might as well call it the kitchen sink, I told him everything jalapenos chicken all that and it is awesome,thank you very much. The only thing I don’t like about it is— there’s not enough!!!! LOL
Ryan Bass
Great service and great food! I’ve only had the pizza so far, but will be trying a Stromboli soon.
… View more
