Cutting no corners and using only the finest, freshest ingredients available, Mighty Fine Pizza proudly become a Petoskey legend and has won more awards over the years.
At just 8’ wide and 60’ long, and once an alleyway, the Mighty Fine Pizza building is now known as, “The hardest working 480 square feet in Petoskey!”
The building originated in 1966 and was Petoskey’s first pizza place.
Mighty Fine Pizza is set apart from others in the industry because they make their own fresh homemade dough and pizza sauce. There is nothing “franchise” about Mighty Fine Pizza! You’ll find fresh and local products that are chopped and prepped by hand. Mighty Fine Pizza takes pride in having a friendly, welcoming, neighborhood environment for the staff.
Storied mom-&-pop nook making pizza with gourmet toppings, plus sandwiches & daily specials, to go. Based on 310 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
222 E Mitchell St, Petoskey, MI 49770
Phone: (231) 347-3255
Website: http://mightyfinepizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed
Holiday hours
|
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday |
3–10 PM |
| Sunday |
3–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Shelby Turner
This is a small pizza shop, but they have the BEST pizza!! We spent the day in Petoskey and stopped for lunch. They did not disappoint! We ordered the supreme, and typically pizza places do not put a lot of meat and veggies on it, but sure enough it was loaded! The service was excellent, and he was extremely helpful! Their tables outside were very clean and the view was beautiful. We will definitely be coming back!
… more
Anne Sanchez
Cannot say enough good things about this little family-owned pizza place. No dining in, only take-out, but it’s the best pizza my family has had in a long time. Very nice back story and great family articles on the wall. We will definitely be back next time we’re in the area. Thank you!
… more
Shanna
We ordered a large pizza, chicken Caesar grinder and an order of Mighty meatballs. Everything was superb! The meatballs were delicious; they were wrapped in their pizza dough and baked, sprinkled with parmesan and served with ranch for dipping. Prices were fair. Great small business! Would definitely recommend!!
… more
Jacob Jackson
Mighty Fine Pizza is the perfect description of this place. I’ve eaten at gourmet pizza restaurants, I’ve eaten at humble fast food pizza joints but this place has rocketed to my number one favorite pizza.
… more
Jennifer Holmes
We ordered delivery to the campground we are staying at and the delivery driver was super friendly and on time. The pizzas were delicious and hot. I will definitely order from here the next time I’m here.
… more
Brandi C
Been coming to Petoskey for almost 20 years for Men’s Fast Pitch Softball, wanted Mancino’s tonight and ordered at 740p only to be told that they are closed.
… more
K B
Just a little hole in the wall that exceeded our expectations!!! Check out their online specials. We did the four personal pizzas with a side of breadsticks. Everything tastes super fresh and homemade. No indoor dining so we took it down to the park on the water and had a sunset dinner. Highly recommend Mighty Fine Pizza!
… more
Mike Vandermus
It’s Mighty Fine… but not quite Mighty Good… the service is Mighty Great though I will tell you! Quick friendly and affordable. Their pizza was pretty good. I got their pizzarito and it was a lot of dough and not much sauce or toppings, on the contrary their pizza has a little too much sauce but still a fine pizza.
… more
SillyBilly
We had there pizza while staying in the Petoskey area. Pizza was great. Had a pizza with so much flavor after a very long time.
… more
Beth
Quick and delicious pie. Didn’t expect such greatness to come from a “hole in the wall” type of establishment. Walked in to a friendly greeting. I listened to young staff discuss and care about their deliveries while I waited for my pizza to come from the oven. Every interaction with the order from conception to completion depicted the name of the restaurant.
… more
… View more
