For over 45 years Middle Island Pizza has been a pillar of the community. A testimate to family run businesses based on tradition and hard work. For almost 5 decades the D’Onofrio family has provided exceptional food and service to our community of friends.
Based on 336 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
Phone: (631) 924-0091
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
| Pizza | |
| Neapolitan Cheese Pizza Classic cheese or create your own pizza. |
$15.95 |
| Sicilian Pizza Pan cooked thick crust 10 slices. |
$19.95 |
| Grandma Pizza Pan cooked, chunky tomato sauce, oregano, fresh garlic, basil, pecorino & whole milk mozzarella cheese. |
$19.95 |
| Pan Pizza Round 8 slice pan cooked. |
$20.95 |
| Detroit Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza Thick crust, pan cooked, whole milk mozzarella, cup & char pepperoni, Mike’s Hot Honey drizzle. |
$19.95 |
| Ultra-Crispy Thin Crust Pizza | $9.95 |
| Cauliflower Crust Pizza | $13.95 |
| Gluten Free Crust Pizza | $12.95 |
| Gourmet Pizza | |
| Everything Pizza Meatball, pepperoni, sausage, onion, pepper, mushroom, pizza sauce, extra whole milk mozzarella. |
$28.95 |
| Buffalo Chicken Pizza Crispy chicken, buffalo sauce, whole milk mozzarella and cheddar cheese blend, ranch drizzle. |
$28.95 |
| BBQ Chicken Pizza Crispy chicken, BBQ sauce, bacon, red onion, whole milk mozzarella cheddar cheese blend. |
$28.95 |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Crispy chicken, bacon, tomato, ranch, whole milk mozzarella & cheddar cheese blend. |
$28.95 |
| Chicken Parm Pizza Crispy chicken, tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella. |
$28.95 |
| Chicken Vodka Pizza Crispy chicken, vodka sauce, whole milk mozzarella. |
$28.95 |
| Margherita Pizza Plum tomato sauce, sliced fresh mozzarella, torn fresh basil. |
$25.95 |
| White Pizza Ricotta, whole milk mozzarella, garlic infused EVOO. |
$25.95 |
| Meat Supreme Pizza Pepperoni, meatball, sausage, bacon, pizza sauce, whole milk mozzarella. |
$28.95 |
| Salad Pizza Iceberg romaine blend, tomato, cucumber, olive, roasted pepper, red onion, shredded whole milk mozzarella, served with our house made tomato vinaigrette. |
$29.95 |
| Crispino Pizza Thin pan cooked, sliced tomato, fresh mozzarella, roasted pepper, pesto, balsamic reduction. |
$26.95 |
| Chicken Cheesesteak Pizza Chopped chicken, caramelized onions, peppers, whole milk mozzarella & cheddar cheese blend. |
$28.95 |
| Thai Chili Chicken Pizza Crispy chicken, Thai chili sauce, whole milk mozzarella, scallions, sesame seeds. |
$28.95 |
| Tomato Basil Pizza Crushed whole plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, EVOO, whole milk mozzarella, basil. |
$25.95 |
| Mamma Mia Pizza Grilled chicken, tomato, roasted pepper, whole milk mozzarella, pesto, balsamic reduction. |
$28.95 |
| Pizzette | |
| Greens & Burrata Pizza Mixed greens, red onion, prosciutto, Romano cheese, burrata, balsamic glaze. |
$15.95 |
| Vodka-Rita Pizza House made vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, Romano cheese. |
$14.95 |
| Honey Spice Pepperoni Pizza Tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella, cup & char pepperoni, hot honey drizzle. |
$14.95 |
| Spinach Artichoke Pizza Creamy parmesan sauce, spinach, artichoke, whole milk mozzarella, sundried tomato. |
$15.95 |
| L.I. Clam Casino Pizza Fresh chopped clams, roasted garlic, chopped peppers, bacon, scampi sauce, whole milk mozzarella. |
$16.95 |
| Angry Vodka Pizza Chicken, pepperoni, spicy vodka, fresh mozzarella. |
$14.95 |
| Wild Mushroom Pizza Wild mushrooms, caramelized onion, marinara, whole milk mozzarella, truffle oil drizzle. |
$15.95 |
| Fra Diavolo Pizza Crumbled sausage, cherry peppers, spicy marinara, fresh mozzarella.. |
$14.95 |
| New Yorker Pizza Pizza sauce, whole milk mozzarella. |
$11.95 |
| Margarita Pizza Crushed plum tomato, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, EVOO. |
$13.95 |
| Arthur Avenue Pizza Broccoli rabe, Italian sausage, fresh mozzarella (served with or without sauce). |
$15.95 |
| Bianco Pizza Creamy ricotta, whole milk mozzarella, garlic infused oil. |
$15.95 |
| Mammas Pizza Grilled chicken, fresh tomato, fresh mozzarella, roasted pepper, basil, balsamic glaze. |
$15.95 |
| Cowboy Pizza BBQ chicken, red onion, bacon, whole milk mozzarella cheddar blend. |
$16.95 |
| OG Chicken Pizza Classic chicken parm. |
$15.95 |
| Veggetini Pizza Spinach, broccoli, onion, mushroom, roasted pepper, eggplant, marinara sauce, whole milk mozzarella. |
$15.95 |
| Sweet Thai Chili Pizza Chicken, Thai chili sauce, mozzarella cheddar blend, green onion, sesame seeds. |
$15.95 |
| Meatball & Burrata Pizza Chunks of homemade meatball, fresh burrata, marinara sauce, whole milk mozzarella, hot honey drizzle. |
$16.95 |
| Blue Cheese Buffalo Pizza Blue cheese coated crust, buffalo chicken, whole milk mozzarella cheddar blend. |
$15.95 |
| Italian Stallion Pizza Pizza sauce crust, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, shredded whole milk mozzarella house dressing. |
$16.95 |
| Appetizers | |
| Meatballs & Burrata (3) meatballs, (2) burrata, vodka sauce, toasted semolina bread garnish. |
$12.95 |
| Burrata & Tomato Arugula, vine ripe sliced tomato, roasted peppers, creamy burrata, balsamic fig glaze. |
$12.95 |
| Riceball Classic Homemade rice ball with ground beef & peas, topped with tomato sauce & melted whole milk mozzarella. |
$8.95 |
| Traditional Wings With choice of house buffalo, BBQ, teriyaki, Thai chili, mango habanero, garlic parm, Asian spicy BBQ, or plain, served with blue cheese, celery and carrot garnish. |
$8.95 |
| Boneless Wings With choice of house buffalo, BBQ, teriyaki, Thai chili, mango habanero, garlic parm, Asian spicy BBQ, or plain, served with blue cheese, celery and carrot garnish. |
$8.95 |
| Cauliflower Florets Wings With choice of house buffalo, BBQ, teriyaki, Thai chili, mango habanero, garlic parm, Asian spicy BBQ, or plain, served with blue cheese, celery and carrot garnish. |
$8.95 |
| Meatballs & Risotto Creamy parmesan risotto, meatballs, mushroom marsala demi sauce. |
$11.95 |
| Crispy Calamari Tender domestic calamari served with marinara, buffalo or garlic aioli dipping sauce. |
$14.95 |
| Zucchini Fries Breaded zucchini strips with a tomato dipping sauce. |
$9.95 |
| Breaded Ravioli Crispy breaded cheese ravioli with tomato dipping sauce. |
$9.95 |
| Stuffed Mushrooms Crumbled Italian sausage, mascarpone, ricotta, and pecorino Romano cheese in a madeira demi. |
$11.95 |
| Mozzarella Sticks Battered mozzarella sticks served with tomato dipping sauce. |
$8.95 |
| Baked Clams Whole top neck clams, seasoned bread crumb, lemon white wine sauce. |
$10.95 |
| Breaded Mozzarella Pearls Fresh mozzarella pearls coated in Italian Bread crumb and crispy fried, served with tomato dipping sauce. |
$10.95 |
| Caccio & Pepe Balls Fried Italian mac & cheese balls-angel hair pasta, ricotta, mozzarella & pecorino Romano cheese crispy fried served with alfredo & tomato dipping sauces. |
$10.95 |
| Italian Breaded Shrimp Cocktail Jumbo breaded shrimp, served with house cocktail sauce. |
$12.95 |
| Mussel Bowls PEI mussels served marinara, spicy fra diavolo, roasted garlic white wine, or carbonara style. |
$12.95 |
| Soups | |
| Chicken Noodle Soup Shredded chicken breast, celery, carrot, onion, chicken broth, noodles. |
$5.95 |
| Vegetable Minestrone Soup Red beans, ditalini pasta, tomato broth, assorted chopped vegetables. |
$5.95 |
| Pasta Fagioli Soup Crushed Italian tomato broth, garlic, cannellini beans, basil, ditalini pasta. |
$5.95 |
| Italian Wedding Soup Spinach, meatball, beef broth, egg drop, Romano cheese. |
$5.95 |
| Salads | |
| Italian Garden Salad Iceberg romaine blend, cherry tomato, cucumber, red onion, Kalamata olive, roasted red pepper, served with our house made tomato vinaigrette. |
$7.95 |
| Pizzeria Salad Iceberg romaine blend, cherry tomato, cucumber, shredded mozzarella cheese, served with our house made tomato vinaigrette. |
$8.95 |
| Chicken Salad Iceberg romaine blend, cherry tomato, cucumber, red onion, Kalamata olive, roasted red pepper, over choice of: grilled chicken, crispy chicken or buffalo chicken, served with our house made tomato vinaigrette. |
$9.95 |
| Burrata Salad Arugula, tomato, roasted pepper, dried cranberries, toasted almonds, balsamic reduction topped with burrata and balsamic drizzle. |
$11.95 |
| Greek Salad Iceberg romaine blend, cherry tomato, cucumber, red onion, Kalamata olive, roasted red pepper, stuffed grape leaves, feta cheese, served with our house made tomato vinaigrette. |
$9.95 |
| Caesar Salad Chopped romaine heart, homestyle crouton, shaved asiago cheese, creamy Tuscan Caesar dressing. |
$8.95 |
| Antipasto Salad Iceberg romaine blend, cherry tomato, cucumber, red onion, Kalamata olive, roasted red pepper, salami, ham, peperoni, fresh mozzarella, artichoke, served with our house made tomato vinaigrette. |
$10.95 |
| Spinach Gorgonzola Salad Baby spinach, cherry tomato, crumbled gorgonzola, candied pecan, sun dried cranberries, raspberry vinaigrette. |
$11.95 |
| Caprese Salad Sliced fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, garnished with roasted red peppers, Kalamata olive, pesto, balsamic reduction. |
$11.95 |
| Roma Steak Salad Romaine, grilled flank steak, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, roasted peppers, red onion, balsamic vinaigrette. |
$12.95 |
| Monterey Salad Baby spinach, candied pecan, mandarin oranges, fresh strawberries, shredded Monterey cheese, house balsamic vinaigrette. |
$10.95 |
| Strawberry Fields Salad Mixed greens, grilled chicken, strawberries, grape tomatoes, toasted almonds, crumbled feta cheese, raspberry vinaigrette. |
$11.95 |
| Sides | |
| Broccoli Rabe | $7.95 |
| Broccoli | $6.95 |
| Spinach | $6.95 |
| Asparagus | $6.95 |
| Meatballs | $8.95 |
| Sausage | $7.95 |
| Grilled Chicken | $8.95 |
| Fried Chicken | $8.95 |
| Pasta | $7.95 |
| Mac & Cheese Italiano | $10.95 |
| Pizza Rolls & Calzones | |
| Meatball Parm Roll Meatballs, tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella. |
$8.95 |
| Chicken & Pepperoni Vodka Roll Chicken, pepperoni, red pepper flakes, vodka sauce, whole milk mozzarella. |
$8.95 |
| Pizzone Roll Sausage, pepperoni, meatball, pizza sauce, whole milk mozzarella. |
$8.95 |
| Chicken Parm Roll Chicken, tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella. |
$8.95 |
| Eggplant Parm Roll Eggplant, tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella. |
$8.95 |
| Sausage Peppers Onions Roll Sausage, peppers, onions, tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella. |
$8.95 |
| Spinach & Broccoli Roll Spinach, broccoli, whole milk mozzarella. |
$8.95 |
| Sausage & Pepperoni Roll Sausage, pepperoni, whole milk mozzarella. |
$8.95 |
| Cheese Calzone Ricotta, whole milk mozzarella, Italian herbs. |
$8.95 |
| Buffalo Chicken Roll Chicken, buffalo sauce, cheddar & whole milk mozzarella blend, blue cheese dressing. |
$8.95 |
| Paninis | |
| Cittero Panini Ham, burrata cheese, sliced tomato, arugula. |
$12.95 |
| Chicken Florentina Panini | $12.95 |
| Mamma Mia Panini Crispy chicken, grilled chicken, or fire roasted turkey, fresh mozzarella, mixed greens, tomato, basil, balsamic reduction. |
$12.95 |
| Bella Donna Panini Breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella, broccoli rabe, tomato, roasted pepper, pesto, balsamic reduction, balsamic dressing. |
$12.95 |
| The Club Panini Crispy chicken, grilled chicken, or fire roasted turkey, American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo. |
$12.95 |
| Chicken Buffalo Panini Crispy or grilled chicken, buffalo sauce, melted mozzarella, tomato, blue cheese. |
$12.95 |
| Chicken Ranch Panini Crispy or grilled chicken, melted American, ranch, bacon, tomato. |
$12.95 |
| Chicken Guido Panini Crispy or grilled chicken, broccoli rabe, cherry peppers, melted provolone. |
$12.95 |
| Little Italy Panini Broccoli rabe, burrata, tomato, prosciutto, balsamic glaze. |
$12.95 |
| Portobello Capri Panini Grilled marinated Portobello caps, baby spinach, sliced tomato, fresh mozzarella, roasted pepper, pesto, balsamic reduction. |
$12.95 |
| Italiano Panini Salami, ham, prosciutto, pepperoni, provolone, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, roasted pepper, red onion, oil & vinegar. |
$12.95 |
| Barca Panini Crispy italian breaded flounder, melted mozzarella, arugula, tomato, Tuscan lemon garlic aioli. |
$12.95 |
| Flank Steak Panini Grilled marinated flank steak, caramelized onions, mushrooms, melted provolone. |
$12.95 |
| Chicken Caesar Panini Grilled or crispy chicken, chopped romaine, shaved asiago, Caesar dressing. |
$12.95 |
| Chicken Paisano Panini Grilled or crispy chicken, crispy prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, arugula, tomato, house vinaigrette. |
$12.95 |
| Heros | |
| Meatball Parmigiana Hero | $11.95 |
| Chicken Parmigiana Hero | $11.95 |
| Sausage Parmigiana Hero | $10.95 |
| Eggplant Parmigiana Hero | $10.95 |
| Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Hero | $13.95 |
| Shrimp Parmigiana Hero | $13.95 |
| Sausage & Meatball Parmigiana Hero | $10.95 |
| Sausage & Peppers Parmigiana Hero | $10.95 |
| Chicken Cheesesteak Hero | $13.95 |
| Frittata Hero Peppers, onion, potato, eggs. |
$10.95 |
| Pasta Dishes | |
| Penne Alla Vodka Shallot, garlic, plum tomato, cream, Romano cheese. |
$16.95 |
| Spaghetti & Tomato Sauce Slow cooked, imported mutti Italian tomatoes. |
$13.95 |
| Nonno’s Gnocchi Potato gnocchi pasta, ground beef and veal meat sauce, touch of cream. |
$18.95 |
| Baked Penne Penne pasta, ricotta, tomato sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella. |
$16.95 |
| Stuffed Shells Ricotta filled pasta shells, tomato sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella. |
$16.95 |
| Ravioli Ricotta filled ravioli, tomato sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella. |
$16.95 |
| Carbonara Penne pasta, pancetta, mushrooms, peas, onions, Romano cheese cream sauce. |
$17.95 |
| Braised Bolognese Fresh pappardelle pasta, red wine braised ground beef & veal in a slow cooked tomato sauce. |
$16.95 |
| Sunday Pasta Rigatoni pasta, oven roasted Italian sausage, meatball & braised pork in an old school Italian tomato sauce, topped with warm ricotta. |
$19.95 |
| Authentic Lasagna Layers of pasta, ricotta, ground beef, tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella. |
$16.95 |
| Alfredo Fettuccine pasta, parmesan cream sauce. |
$16.95 |
| Farm To Table Fresh orecchiette pasta, chicken, broccoli, oven roasted tomato, artichoke, Kalamata olive, roasted garlic white wine sauce. |
$18.95 |
| Harvest Tortellini Cheese tortellini pasta, crumbled sausage, baby spinach, roasted tomato, roasted garlic cream sauce. |
$18.95 |
| Stuffed Rigatoni Ricotta filled rigatoni, braised ground beef, tomato sauce, touch of cream, melted whole milk mozzarella. |
$18.95 |
| Seafood | |
| Old School Favorites Choice of shrimp, mussels, or calamari, prepared marinara, bianco, or fra diavolo served with choice of pasta. |
$19.95 |
| Shrimp Scampi Broiled jumbo shrimp, roasted garlic lemon white wine sauce, toasted bread crumb, served over choice of pasta. |
$20.95 |
| Shrimp Parmesan Breaded jumbo shrimp, tomato sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella, served with choice of pasta. |
$20.95 |
| Cadillac Shrimp Shrimp, shaved asparagus, artichoke, pink tomato cream sauce, shaved asiago cheese garnish served over penne pasta. |
$20.95 |
| Linguine Clam Sauce (Red or white) chopped fresh L.I. clams & whole baby clams, roasted garlic, chardonnay wine, fresh basil, served with linguine pasta. |
$18.95 |
| Seafood Chop-Chop Chopped shrimp, clams, & calamari, touch of tomato, basil, roasted garlic white wine sauce, linguine pasta. |
$21.95 |
| Broiled Shrimp & Flounder Oreganata Broiled shrimp & flounder, lemon white wine sauce, toasted bread crumbs, served with vegetable and choice of pasta or risotto. |
$23.95 |
| Salmon Crostino Panko parmesan crusted salmon, lite dill creamy sauce, served with vegetable and choice of pasta or risotto. |
$22.95 |
| Calabrian Salmon Calabrian chili glazed salmon, served with vegetable and choice of pasta or risotto. |
$22.95 |
| Flounder Milanese Pan fried breaded flounder topped with mixed greens, tomato, red onion, Kalamata olive, roasted red pepper, shredded whole milk mozzarella, balsamic reduction, served with roasted broccoli, asparagus and carrots. |
$23.95 |
| Seafood Fra Diavolo Shrimp, mussel, calamari, clams, spicy marinara, served over linguine pasta. |
$23.95 |
| Eggplant Dinners | |
| Eggplant Parm Skinless breaded eggplant, tomato sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella. |
$17.95 |
| Eggplant Rollatini Skinless breaded eggplant, ricotta, tomato sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella. |
$18.95 |
| Entrée Classics | |
| Chicken Parmesan Tomato sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella. |
$18.95 |
| Veal Parmesan Tomato sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella. |
$20.95 |
| Chicken Carbonara Pancetta, onion, peas, parmesan cream sauce. |
$19.95 |
| Veal Carbonara Pancetta, onion, peas, parmesan cream sauce. |
$21.95 |
| Chicken Francese Egg battered, lemon white wine sauce. |
$19.95 |
| Veal Francese Egg battered, lemon white wine sauce. |
$21.95 |
| Chicken Marsala Cremini & button mushrooms, marsala demi. |
$19.95 |
| Veal Marsala Cremini & button mushrooms, marsala demi. |
$21.95 |
| Chicken Milanese Panko crusted, topped with mixed greens, tomato, red onion, roasted pepper, shredded cold mozzarella. |
$20.95 |
| Veal Milanese Panko crusted, topped with mixed greens, tomato, red onion, roasted pepper, shredded cold mozzarella. |
$22.95 |
| Chicken Martini Panko parmesan crusted, hot cherry peppers, chopped broccoli rabe, lemon white wine sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella. |
$20.95 |
| Veal Martini Panko parmesan crusted, hot cherry peppers, chopped broccoli rabe, lemon white wine sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella. |
$22.95 |
| Kids Menu | |
| Kid’s Chicken Finger & Fries | $11.95 |
| Kid’s Cheese Ravioli | $8.95 |
| Kid’s Penne With Butter | $6.95 |
| Kid’s Penne With Tomato Sauce | $6.95 |
| Kid’s Mac & Cheese Italiano | $10.95 |
| Desserts | |
| NY Cheesecake Cream cheese cake, graham cracker crust. |
$6.95 |
| Red Velvet Red cake batter, cream cheese icing. |
$5.95 |
| Chocolate Lovin’ Cake Chocolate pudding layered between chocolate cake, chocolate icing. |
$6.95 |
| Rainbow Cheesecake Rainbow cookie layered cake with cheesecake center. |
$6.95 |
| Cannoli Crispy cannoli shell filled to order with creamy cannoli cream and chocolate chips. |
$3.95 |
| Tiramisu Espresso dipped lady finger cookies, mascarpone cream, coco powder. |
$5.95 |
| Tartuffo Chocolate dipped vanilla and chocolate ice-cream with black cherry crushed nuts center. |
$7.95 |
| Appetizers Lunch | |
| Toasted Penne Lunch Panko crusted penne pasta filled with ricotta, crispy fried, vodka dipping sauce. |
$9.95 |
| Fiamma Shrimp Lunch Crispy parmesan polenta crusted shrimp, garlic pepper dipping sauce. |
$10.95 |
| Grilled Portobello Lunch Served cold with grilled Portobello, fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted pepper, basil, balsamic glaze over bed of arugula. |
$10.95 |
| Arancini Lunch Mini riceballs stuffed with sausage & broccoli rabe, tomato dipping sauce. |
$10.95 |
| Baked Clams Lunch Whole long island top neck clams, seasoned bread crumb topping, lemon white wine herb sauce. |
$10.95 |
| Zucchini Sticks Lunch Crispy fried, served with tomato dipping sauce. |
$9.95 |
| Mussels Lunch PEI mussels served spicy marinara or chardonnay wine sauce. |
$12.95 |
| Fried Calamari Lunch Crispy fried, served with marinara & Tuscan lemon garlic aioli. |
$12.95 |
| Crispy Artichoke Lunch Golden fried, creamy horseradish dipping sauce. |
$9.95 |
| Wild Mushroom Crostini Lunch Homemade crostini topped with creamy burrata cheese, wild mushroom medley, truffle oil drizzle. |
$12.95 |
| Burrata & Meatballs Lunch 3 meatballs, burrata cheese, vodka sauce. |
$12.95 |
| Caccio & Pepe Balls Lunch Crispy fried angel hair pasta, ricotta, mascarpone & mozzarella cheese balls alfredo dipping sauce. |
$10.95 |
| Potato Croquettes Lunch Mashed potato, mozzarella, chopped imported ham, spicy ranch. |
$10.95 |
| Crispy Flounder Strips Lunch Crispy crusted flounder strips, jersey fries, jalapeno ranch dipping sauce. |
$10.95 |
| Garlic Mozzarella Pearls Lunch Crispy fried garlic bread crusted fresh mozzarella pearls, tomato dipping sauce. |
$9.95 |
| Soups Lunch | |
| Chicken Noodle Soup Lunch Chopped carrots, onions, celery, and noodles. |
$5.95 |
| Vegetable Minestrone Soup Lunch Assorted chopped, vegetables, red beans, tomato broth. |
$5.95 |
| Pasta Fagioli Soup Lunch Crushed tomato broth, garlic, basil, cannellini beans, and ditalini pasta. |
$5.95 |
| Italian Wedding Soup Lunch Spinach, meatballs, chicken broth, egg drop, romano cheese. |
$5.95 |
| Hand Crafted Pizza Rolls & Calzones Lunch | |
| Meatball Parm Roll Lunch Meatballs, tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese. |
$7.95 |
| Chicken & Pepperoni Vodka Roll Lunch Chicken, pepperoni, vodka sauce, mozzarella cheese. |
$7.95 |
| Chicken Cowboy Lunch Crispy chicken, BBQ sauce, cheddar & mozzarella, bacon, onions. |
$7.95 |
| Chicken Parm Roll Lunch Chicken, tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese. |
$7.95 |
| Eggplant Parm Roll Lunch Eggplant, tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese. |
$7.95 |
| Sausage Peppers Onions Roll Sausage, peppers, onions, tomato sauce, mozzarella. |
$7.95 |
| Spinach & Broccoli Roll Lunch Spinach, broccoli, mozzarella cheese. |
$7.95 |
| Sausage & Pepperoni Stromboli Lunch Sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese. |
$7.95 |
| Cheese Calzone Lunch Ricotta & mozzarella cheese, Italian herbs. |
$7.95 |
| Buffalo Chicken Roll Lunch Chicken, buffalo sauce, cheddar mozzarella cheese blend, blue cheese dressing. |
$7.95 |
| Pizzone Roll Lunch Sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella, pizza sauce. |
$7.95 |
| Panini Lunch | |
| Portobello Capri Panini Lunch Portobello, fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted peppers, pesto, baby spinach, balsamic reduction drizzle. |
$10.95 |
| Turkey Caprese Panini Lunch Fire-roasted turkey, fresh mozzarella, mixed greens, tomato, roasted garlic aioli. |
$10.95 |
| Mamma Mia Panini Lunch Grilled balsamic marinated chicken, sliced tomato, fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, roasted peppers, house-made balsamic vinaigrette. |
$10.95 |
| The Club Panini Lunch Choice of Fire-Roasted turkey, grilled or crispy chicken, American cheese, lettuce, bacon, tomato, and mayo. |
$10.95 |
| Chicken Buffalo Panini Lunch Grilled or crispy chicken, buffalo sauce, melted mozzarella, tomato, blue cheese. |
$10.95 |
| Chicken Ranch Panini Lunch Grilled or crispy chicken, melted America, ranch, bacon, tomato. |
$10.95 |
| Chicken Guido Panini Lunch Grilled or crispy chicken, broccoli rabe, cherry peppers, melted provolone, house-made balsamic vinaigrette. |
$10.95 |
| Chicken Pepe Panini Lunch Grilled or crispy chicken, chipotle sauce, sauteed onions, peppers & melted American. |
$10.95 |
| Chicken Americano Panini Lunch Grilled or crispy chicken, ham, American & honey mustard dressing. |
$10.95 |
| Chicken Paisano Panini Lunch Grilled or crispy chicken, crispy prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, arugula, tomato, house-made tomato vinaigrette. |
$10.95 |
| Italiano Panini Lunch Salami, ham, prosciutto, pepperoni, provolone, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, roasted pepper, red onion, oil & vinegar. |
$10.95 |
| Barca Panini Lunch Crispy flounder, melted mozzarella, arugula, tomato, Tuscan lemon garlic aioli. |
$10.95 |
| Chicken Picante Panini Lunch Grilled or crispy chicken, spicy hot honey, provolone, cherry peppers, lettuce, tomato. |
$10.95 |
| Chicken Caesar Panini Lunch Grilled or crispy chicken, chopped romaine, shaved asiago, caesar dressing. |
$10.95 |
| Flank Steak Panini Lunch Marinated sliced flank steak, melted provolone, onions, mushrooms. |
$10.95 |
| Chicken Florentina Panini Lunch Grilled or crispy chicken, burrata, baby spinach, tomato, balsamic glaze, roasted garlic aioli. |
$10.95 |
| Lunch Platters | |
| Chicken Parm Lunch Platter Served with pasta. |
$12.95 |
| Chicken Vodka Parm Lunch Platter Served with penne alla vodka |
$12.95 |
| Eggplant Parm Lunch Platter Served with pasta. |
$12.95 |
| Eggplant Rollatini Lunch Platter Served with pasta. |
$12.95 |
| Grilled Chicken Fresca Lunch Platter Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomato, mixed greens, roasted pepper, basil, balsamic reduction. |
$12.95 |
| Frutta Di Mare Lunch Platter Mussels & clams marinara over linguine. |
$12.95 |
| Flounder Milanese Lunch Platter Topped with arugula, tomato, red onion, balsamic reduction, and shaved asiago. |
$12.95 |
| Appetizers Catering | |
| Baked Clams Catering Top neck clams, seasoned bread crumbs. |
$50.00 |
| Clams Casino Catering Top neck clam, bacon, onion, peppers, bread crumb. |
$50.00 |
| Stuffed Mushrooms Catering Stuffed with crab meat, bread crumbs. |
$60.00 |
| Fried Jumbo Ravioli Catering Cheese ravioli, vodka sauce. |
$50.00 |
| Mozzarella Sticks Catering Battered mozzarella, Pomodoro dipping sauce. |
$45.00 |
| Zucchini Sticks Catering Breaded zucchini, Pomodoro dipping sauce. |
$45.00 |
| Pigs In A Blanket Catering | $55.00 |
| Chicken Fingers Catering | $50.00 |
| French Fries Catering | $35.00 |
| Italian Slider Catering Meatball, chicken, fresh mozzarella & tomato. |
$45.00 |
| Mini Rice Balls Catering | $55.00 |
| Crispy Artichokes Catering Horseradish aioli. |
$50.00 |
| Garlic Bread Parmigiana Catering | $40.00 |
| Sausage & Pepperoni Stromboli Platter Catering Pomodoro dipping sauce. |
$55.00 |
| Chicken Wings Catering BBQ, buffalo, teriyaki, blue cheese dressing. |
$45.00 |
| Salads Catering | |
| Italian House Salad Catering Romaine & iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumber, olives, roasted peppers & red onions. |
$35.00 |
| Gorgonzola Salad Catering Baby spinach, grape tomato, red onion, candied pecans, dried cranberries, gorgonzola cheese. |
$45.00 |
| Greek Salad Catering House salad, crumbled feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves. |
$45.00 |
| Caesar Salad Catering Romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan cheese, toasted croutons. |
$40.00 |
| Grilled Chicken Salad Catering House salad, marinated grilled chicken. |
$45.00 |
| Antipasto Salad Catering House salad, ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese. |
$45.00 |
| Sides & Extras Catering | |
| Roasted Potatoes Catering Red potato, Italian seasoning, Romano cheese. |
$40.00 |
| Baked Mac & Cheese Catering Mozzarella, cheddar, provolone, American, Romano cheese. |
$55.00 |
| Asparagus Catering Roasted garlic, olive oil, sundried tomato, Kalamata olive. |
$55.00 |
| Rice Catering | $40.00 |
| Garlic Knot Catering | $50.00 |
| Sautéed Broccoli Catering Roasted garlic, olive oil. |
$45.00 |
| Baby Spinach Catering Roasted garlic, olive oil. |
$45.00 |
| Mixed Vegetables Catering Zucchini, squash, carrots, broccoli, mushrooms, baby spinach, roasted garlic, olive oil. |
$55.00 |
| Roasted Garlic Mashed Potato Catering Roasted garlic, potato, mozzarella. |
$65.00 |
| Pasta Dishes Catering | |
| Pasta Pomodoro Catering Slow cooked homemade tomato sauce. |
$30.00 |
| Pasta Melanzane Catering Diced roasted eggplant, zesty marinara, fresh basil, topped fresh ricotta. |
$50.00 |
| Pasta Alla Mamma Catering Slow cooked tomato sauce, sweet Italian sausage, meatballs, warm ricotta cheese. |
$45.00 |
| Ravioli Spinachi Catering Cheese ravioli, baby spinach, grape tomatoes, cream pink sauce, diced fresh mozzarella. |
$45.00 |
| Pasta Bolognese Catering Hearty tomato meat sauce. |
$45.00 |
| Pasta Primavera Catering Fresh squash, zucchini, broccoli, spinach, peppers & mushrooms in a creamy alfredo sauce, marinara sauce or garlic & oil. |
$45.00 |
| Venetian Pasta Catering Grilled chicken, baby spinach, mushrooms, pink tomato cream sauce. |
$40.00 |
| Pasta Alla Tuscany Catering Grilled chicken, sun dried tomato & broccoli rabe, a garlic white wine sauce. |
$45.00 |
| Pasta Carbonara Catering Peas, onions, bacon, parmesan cream sauce. |
$45.00 |
| Tortellini Alfredo Catering Tri-color cheese tortellini, creamy cheese sauce. |
$45.00 |
| Pasta Casalinga Catering Chicken, broccoli rabe, sundried tomato, Kalamata olive, roasted garlic, olive oil. |
$45.00 |
| Pasta Alfano Catering Chicken, escarole, sun-dried tomato, cannellini beans, roasted garlic, olive oil. |
$45.00 |
| Pasta Alla Vodka Catering Cream, vodka, San Marzano tomatoes, parmesan cheese. |
$45.00 |
| Pasta Alla Vodka With Chicken Catering Cream, vodka, San Marzano tomatoes, parmesan cheese. |
$85.00 |
| Pasta Amatriciana Catering Onions, ham, mushrooms, marinara sauce. |
$40.00 |
| Gnocchi Catering Plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil. |
$45.00 |
| Pasta Antica Catering Mushrooms, peas, onions, light chardonnay cream sauce. |
$45.00 |
| Pasta Chicken Gorgonzola Catering Chicken, mushrooms, gorgonzola cream sauce. |
$45.00 |
| Pasta Palermo Catering Sausage, broccoli rabe, sundried tomato, Kalamata olive, roasted garlic, olive oil. |
$45.00 |
| Pasta Rustico Catering Sausage, escarole, cannellini beans, roasted garlic, olive oil. |
$45.00 |
| Lobster Ravioli Catering Lobster filled ravioli, light seafood pink sauce. |
$55.00 |
| Seafood Catering | |
| Fried Calamari Catering Fried calamari, choice of marinara/ fra diablo/ gorgonzola/ arrabiatta style. |
$70.00 |
| Calamari Marinara Catering Calamari, roasted garlic, white wine, basil, plum tomato sauce, pasta. |
$70.00 |
| Mussels Catering Mussels, roasted garlic, basil, white wine, red or white. |
$70.00 |
| Clam Sauce Catering Baby clams, roasted garlic, basil, white wine, red or white, pasta. |
$70.00 |
| Shrimp Parmigiana Catering Breaded shrimp, tomato sauce, mozzarella. |
$70.00 |
| Shrimp Scampi Catering Jumbo shrimp, julienned zucchini, roasted garlic white wine sauce, pasta. |
$70.00 |
| Shrimp Marinara Catering Jumbo shrimp, roasted garlic, basil, plum tomato sauce, pasta. |
$70.00 |
| Zuppa Di Pesce Catering Shrimps, scallops, mussels, clams, calamari, roasted garlic, white wine, plum tomato, pasta. |
$70.00 |
| Shrimp & Scallops Catering Jumbo shrimps, scallops, white wine, lemon, garlic, herbs, breadcrumbs, pasta. |
$70.00 |
| Salmon Crostino Catering Baked panko crusted salmon, baby spinach, creamy dill sauce. |
$70.00 |
| Salmon Saparito Catering Broiled salmon, asparagus, grape tomato, light seafood pink sauce. |
$70.00 |
| Chicken Catering | |
| Chicken Parmigiana Catering Pomodoro sauce, mozzarella cheese. |
$45.00 |
| Chicken Cacciatore Catering Mushrooms, onion, peppers, plum tomato sauce. |
$55.00 |
| Chicken Marsala Catering Mushrooms, marsala wine sauce. |
$55.00 |
| Chicken Francese Catering Lemon white wine sauce. |
$55.00 |
| Chicken Scarpiello Catering Sausage, peppers, onions, potato, demi glaze sauce. |
$55.00 |
| Chicken Piccata Catering Capers, artichoke heart, roasted pepper, white wine sauce. |
$55.00 |
| Chicken Roma Catering Grilled chicken, plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pesto. |
$55.00 |
| Chicken Teriyaki Catering Carrots, onion, pepper, broccoli, teriyaki glaze. |
$55.00 |
| Chicken Semi-Freddo Catering Mixed greens, grilled chicken, tomato salad. |
$55.00 |
| Carne Catering | |
| Sausage & Peppers Catering | $50.00 |
| Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Catering | $50.00 |
| Pepper Steak Catering Sliced flank steak, onion, pepper, teriyaki sauce. |
$80.00 |
| Meatballs Catering | $60.00 |
| Veal Parmigiana Catering Tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese. |
$80.00 |
| Veal Marsala Catering Mushrooms, marsala wine sauce. |
$80.00 |
| London Broil Catering | $80.00 |
| Eggplant Catering | |
| Eggplant Parmigiana Catering Breaded eggplant, tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese. |
$45.00 |
| Eggplant Rollatini Catering Eggplant, ricotta, tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese. |
$45.00 |
| Eggplant Napoletano Catering Breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella cheese, roasted peppers, tomato sauce. |
$45.00 |
| Platters Catering | |
| Italiano Antipasto Catering Dried Italian sausage, prosciutto, roasted peppers, olives, artichoke, provolone, fresh mozzarella & tomato. |
$70.00 |
| Caprese Catering Fresh mozzarella, tomato, red roasted peppers & olive garnish. |
$50.00 |
| Bread Basket Catering Garlic knots, focaccia, Italian bread. |
$20.00 |
| Focaccia’s Catering Choice of cheese, spinach, broccoli or tomato, on focaccia bread. |
$25.00 |
| Bruschetta Catering Italian crostini, tomato relish. |
$30.00 |
| Fruit Catering In-season fruits. |
$35.00 |
| Cheese Platter Catering Cubed cheese, crackers. |
$45.00 |
| Wrap & Panini Platter Catering | |
| Wraps Catering | $120.00 |
| Panini Catering | $120.00 |
| Dessert Platter Catering | |
| Mini Cannoli Tray Catering | $40.00 |
| Cookie Platter Catering 5lb. minimum order. |
$100.00 |
| Party Heroes Catering | |
| Traditional Italian Hero Catering Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, red onions, roasted peppers, tomato vinaigrette dressing. |
$51.00 |
| Classic American Hero Catering Ham, turkey, roast beef, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo, mustard dressings. |
$51.00 |
| Chicken Club Hero Catering Crispy chicken, American cheese, lettuce & tomato, mayo, bacon. |
$60.00 |
| Milano Hero Catering Crispy chicken, tomato, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, basil mayo. |
$60.00 |
| Tuscan Hero Catering Grilled zucchini, squash, eggplant, Portobello mushrooms, roasted peppers, balsamic glaze & dressing. |
$60.00 |
| Mamma Mia Hero Catering Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted pepper, basil drizzle, tomato vinaigrette dressing. |
$60.00 |
| Gallo Hero Catering Crispy chicken, mixed greens, tomato, red onion, ricotta, basil drizzle. |
$60.00 |
| Chicken Portobello Hero Catering Crispy chicken, Portobello mushroom, roasted peppers, mozzarella, balsamic vinaigrette dressing. |
$60.00 |
| Philly Cheese Steak Hero Catering Beef or chicken, onions, pepper, mozzarella cheese, garlic bread. |
$60.00 |
| Chicken Cali Hero Catering Crispy chicken, fresh mozzarella, fresh baby spinach, sliced tomato, balsamic glaze drizzle, house balsamic dressing. |
$60.00 |
| Chicken Buffalo Hero Catering Buffalo sauce covered crispy chicken, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, blue cheese dressing. |
$60.00 |
| Chicken Ranch Hero Catering Crispy chicken, American & mozzarella cheeses, bacon, sliced tomato, ranch dressing. |
$60.00 |
| Bella Donna Hero Catering Breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella, broccoli rabe, sliced tomato, balsamic glaze & dressing, pesto dressing. |
$60.00 |
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Chauncey Buddy
I had an experience with fraudulent activity on my credit card. I got the phone number from the order from the pizzeria. I Called the customer and when I called her out for using my card she apologized for stealing my cc info, called the pizzeria to pick up the tab but the person at middle island pizza said they could not refund me and charge the appropriate party. I am getting the police involved. Way to go with customer service middle island pizza. I’m happy that a one time fraudulent delivery order of $50 was more important to you than a daily local customer.
… more
Courtney Thompson
Every single person behind the counter is the nicest friendliest pizza shop worker. They have awesome heros and sausage and peppers! They also help the food pantry next door a lot which is awesome to see.
… more
Kathleen Fernie
I ordered eggplant Parm dinner & a slice if regular pizza. Usually the food is delicious, however this time the sauce was different and not in a good way. I am wondering if they changed their chief as the sauce was so much better in the past. I was very disappointed with the way the sauce tasted. The sauce is what makes the food taste good. However, I would order again to see if this was a fluke and just not a good night.
… more
Derek Samuel Reese
We just moved here last week to find great Italian food with the nicest people ever !! They welcomed my daughter and I with open arms, I haven’t heard welcome to the neighborhood in 40 years.
… more
Larry Biehl
Had a birthday party for my daughter on Sunday and I was in charge of the food. Of course I waited to the last minute. I called in a catering order on Friday and had specific details and a certain time food had to be delivered by. Anthony and his crew made it happen. My 40 guests and the staff at the venue all agreed how delicious everything was. I thank you again Middle Island Pizza! You will definitely be my place of choice for my next catering order. Regards, Larry
… more
Joan Jerome
Order a slice and the chicken wrap the pizza had a horrible taste and the wrap you couldn’t even eat there was something wrong with it the taste was so bad. Went there because they used to be very good I ended up throwing the food away
… more
Lisa Lichelle Hill
⚡Lisa – UPDATE✨ Excellent Service. In & out immediately, always. Nice Aye! He said, why all the pictures. I said, cause Your the Best! – Lisa Lichelle ✨
… more
Nicole Connelly
Apologizing in advance for Karening out but I was asked twice if I wanted chicken on my salad to which I answered, “no,” but got charged for anyway which made the salad warm and soggy. Additionally, if I’m ordering a slice this is not what I’m asking for. It’s pizza. If a slice has a giant dried out cheeseless bubble in it just throw it away. Unsure about how the rest of you feel but that does not exceed, let alone meet my standard. Usually the food is good. This was just straight up annoying.
… more
Family AndinoII
Just imagine, chopped up colorful peppers and pepperoni as a cecelian pie. It was so delicious i didnt have to put seasoning on it and i also forgot to take picture because it was stunning. Definitely a must try from here.
… more
Gaetano Tantillo
Middle Island Pizza does an amazing job of supporting Longwood schools and its activities and events… Best Local Puzza Place around!! 100 percent!
… more
… View more