Based on 603 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
3102 Foltz St, Indianapolis, IN 46241
Phone: (317) 241-6019
Website: http://www.mickeyandbills.com/
Hours
| Sunday | 3–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 3–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 2–9 PM |
| Saturday | 2–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Chris Reilly
Food is served hot, pretty quickly and with a smile. Got an old school vibe, like something from the 80s. Pepperoni pizza was good, standard issue dough and sauce and pepperoni. Wasn’t blow away with it but at the same time couldn’t complain one bit. I’m guessing that this style and flavor suits the masses when looking for a good solid pie. I would definitely go back here to try them again.
… more
Christy Brooks
Pizza is delicious and the price is fair for what you get in return. The toppings are fresh and they pile it on. Customer service is excellent. Very nice and helpful over the phone and delivery drivers have always been polite. Highly recommended.
… more
Marc Pero
I was looking for a local pizza place that delivered and the hotel desk clerk recommended Mickey and Bill’s. I’m so glad I tried them because everything I got was outstanding! The Works pizza was superb, and the cheesey garlic bread and tossed salad were top notch! The delivery service was quick and hassle free. I wish I had a place like this back home. Next time I come back to town I’m going to make this a must get meal again! Keep up the great work.
… more
Glenn Brown (drwho6871)
Mickey & Bill’s Pizza has been around for nearly 60 years at the same location in MarsHill and has the best tasting pizza you ever put in your mouth! The only negative that is to be said about them is they do not stay open for very long like the use to before the Covid stuff all started. They are only open for like 5 hours a day which is just plain ridiculous and a complete waste of time on both their part and their long time customers as well as any new and future customers. They use to stay open at least a normal 8 business hours a day and longer on the weekends. Not anymore!! Very sad indeed and very disappointing also… ☹
… more
Melanie J Watkins
My husband and I tried Mickey & Bill’s for the first time. We ordered the Mars Hill Monster, and it was delicious!!!! Very hefty pizza with every topping. We highly recommend it.
… more
Stephen Smith
The Mars Hill monster absolutely slaps, and I tend to trash talk everything on them pizzas. I whole heartedly can’t do that here, as this was just so well made and the flavor combinations were amazing.
… more
Kerly
Haven’t had this pizza for a while. The pizza still tastes the same… YUMMY, but the price! Yikes
… more
Jennifer Shields
It is my husband’s 50th birthday. He wanted chicken wings. Found out that Mickey and Bill’s had them. The wings are large and have alot of meat on then. But they need to add some kind of season to there batter. Probably won’t be ordering wings there again.
… more
Delzie James
This was our first time having Mickey & Bills pizza, it was very good. Crust might be frozen but the stuff that on top was fresh and good. It took 20-25 that what they said, of course any place you go for pizza it take that long anyhow. Will come back again.
… more
john grant
Two items stand out to me since I haven’t ordered much from this place but The Mars Hill Monster is the bomb, And the Italian Salad is awesome, So order whatever I’m sure it’s all Good, The prices leave something to be desired but it is what it is and the food is great for what little I’ve tried and would definitely recommend.
… more
… View more