Simple, family-run Italian joint serving New York-style pizzas, pastas & subs from a counter. Based on 534 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
145 Palm Bay Rd NE, West Melbourne, FL 32904
Phone: (321) 953-8488
Website: http://www.michellispizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tim Steidl
I tried Michelli’s Pizzeria for the first time, and I was very impressed. I come from south Florida (which is the makeshift capitol of New York) where there is a pizza joint on every corner, and in every shopping plaza. We know our pizza in So. Fla! So far the pizza in Central Florida has been unimpressive. I won’t say the pizza is bad, but I wouldn’t be opposed to Domino’s at this point. I have tried quite a few pizza places recently, looking for a tasty pizza, but have yet to find one. I found Michelli’s Pizzeria and liked what I saw, so I decided to try it out. I am very glad I did! This is the best pizza I have had in this area. Maybe even one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. When I ordered they were busy (which is a great sign) and yet they still had my order ready shortly after I arrived. Michelli’s is my new go-to pizza place! I highly recommend Michelli’s!
… more
Dominick D
I’ve been going here since they opened. I love the food and the service is amazing. They know me by name when I walk in or call. When I was a manager I would take my team here for lunch or order to be delivered. The delivery is exceptional. Everything I’ve ever ordered has been earlier than the time quoted. This pizza is far better than any other in the county. If you don’t agree than you don’t know what good pizza is..
… more
Kristen Marie
The pizza is so good! I love the pizza special, and the wings are great. The meatballs are good but I wish there were more in an order. I keep saying I’m going to try other things but keep coming back for that pizza! Great service and friendly staff
… more
Ashley Dodd
This was a first time trying Michelli’s. We got a flier in the mail. Former Bizarro’s customers, and current Papa John’s. Just bc PJ always comes hot and fresh and not overcooked. And I’m the first person to tell you, sometimes Italian, especially old Italian restaurants ive tried are either horrible or amazing. Without a life story, this was everything we needed. We haven’t had a day off in weeks, we finally finished up our last client for the weekend, and It wasn’t in me to cook. As a family who cooks at home and tries not to go out n spend, this was well worth it. The pizza was everything! We got a Popeye with eggplant and a classic pepperoni. Hot, fresh, and Finally I can order spinach and not get a burnt leaf, with fresh eggplant, plenty of toppings, I’m so impressed! I haven’t enjoyed spinach and eggplant on a pizza for 15 yrs. Never have I enjoyed it in FL. The kids loved it, we loved it. I forgot to mention, our delivery driver I think got stuck at our gate. They had the wrong number so she kept calling and calling, and the store called. I didn’t know till she got to the door, but I’m SO grateful she waited!! She was super sweet, and funny, and made sure we got our dinner, even though it was super sketchy out there! Thank y’all for feeding us tonight! Sorry for the novel. It was so delicious, filling, everything we needed after a long stressful work week!
… more
Brian Brownd
Pizza is awesome. Cheese bread fantastic. Meatball and mushroom pizza was a hit. Found my new favorite and I’m a pizza snob. Highly recommend!!
… more
Casandra Walko
Recently switched from our favorite local NY pizza shop, and it is crazy how good this place is in comparison.
… more
Nina P
I’m in the area for a potential relocation. Had to try out a local pizzeria. Ordered the spaghetti bolognese (meat sauce). Sauce is made to order. Absolutely delicious!!! Brought me back to the days when I lived in Italy. Thank you!! I’m definitely coming back!!
… more
Christine LaCavalla Norris
Michelli’s is a long-time favorite of mine!
… more
Keturah Colbert
Just picked up my order cheese pizza and teriyaki garlic chicken and this is the best tasting I have ever had! As ther say in Brooklyn, “Furgettaboutit!” Make Michelli your one stop New York style Pizza! All the others are Fake! Service is fast and the staff is welcoming! Thanks guys!
… more
Thea
Family-run, Michelli’s is our go-to for pasta, calzones and cannolis. Salad is fresh, pasta always cooked al dente and the different sauces are great. I think the meatballs could use more garlic, but honestly no complaint from me. The Cannolis. Oh my!! So GOOD – crispy shell and creamy filling – fresh..! Sometimes I order nothing but those. Delicious!
… more
… View more