Michelle’s Brown Bag Cafe Menu – Sarasota, FL

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : Sarasota, FL

Based on 92 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Michelle's Brown Bag Cafe 34236

Address:
1819 Main St, Sarasota, FL 34236

Phone: (941) 365-5858

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed
Monday

(Labor Day)
9 AM–2 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 9 AM–2 PM
Wednesday 9 AM–2 PM
Thursday 9 AM–2 PM
Friday 9 AM–2 PM

Menu

Specials
Special #1 $9.95
Special #2 $10.95
Special #3 $11.95
Special #4 $12.95
Special #5 $13.95
Breakfast
Fresh Berry Parfait
Topped with granola low fat vanilla yogurt and fresh berries.
$9.95
Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese $4.50
Bagel With Peanut Butter & Sliced Apple $5.95
Bagel With Hummus, Sprouts & Tomato $6.95
Egg Sandwiches
Egg, Tomato, Fresh Mozz & Fresh Basil
Served on a whole wheat wrap, bagel or toast.
$10.95
Egg, Ham, Swiss, Spinach & Mushroom
Served on a whole wheat wrap, bagel or toast.
$10.95
Egg, Bacon, Tomato & White Cheddar
Served on a whole wheat wrap, bagel or toast.
$10.95
Egg, Goat Cheese, Roasted Reds & Spinach
Served on a whole wheat wrap, bagel or toast.
$10.95
Egg, Chorizo Sausage, Provolone
Served on a whole wheat wrap, bagel or toast.
$10.95
Egg, Feta, Mushroom & Sun-Dried Tomato
Served on a whole wheat wrap, bagel or toast.
$10.95
Egg, Avocado, Bacon & Brie
Served on a whole wheat wrap, bagel or toast.
$10.95
Egg, Smoked Salmon, Capers & Dill Cream Cheese
Served on a whole wheat wrap, bagel or toast.
$13.95
Egg, Caramelized Onions, White Cheddar, Bacon & Green Apple
Served on a whole wheat wrap, bagel or toast.
$10.95
Soup Specials
Soup #2 $6.95
Soup #1 $6.95
Field of Greens
Farmer’s Market Salad
Fresh baby greens, tomato, mushrooms, cucumber, sweet pickled red onion, French bread croutons and pita.
$10.95
Selby Gardens Salad
Fresh spinach, smoked bacon, cucumber, sweet pickled red onion, mushrooms, and crumbled Gorgonzola cheese and pita.
$13.95
Chef Lido Salad
Honey ham, turkey, Provolone, baby greens, tomato, cucumber, mushrooms, sprouts, French bread croutons, and pita.
$13.95
The Ringling Salad
Fresh baby spinach, sliced green apple, Brie cheese, cucumber, mushrooms, French bread croutons, and pita.
$12.95
Red, White & Greens Salad
Sliced tomato, fresh Mozzarella, basil, baby greens with balsamic vinaigrette and pita.
$12.95
Create Your Own Sandwich
Create Your Own Sandwich | Half $8.95
Create Your Own Sandwich | Whole $11.95
Sandwiches
The Manatee Sandwich
Fresh baby greens, cucumber, tomato, sprouts, sweet pickled red onion, mushrooms, and homemade hummus.
$9.95
Bird Key Sandwich
Homemade chicken salad, sliced apple, baby greens, tomato, sprouts, and crumbled Gorgonzola.
$12.95
Anna Maria Sandwich
Locally smoked salmon, baby greens, sweet red onions, sprouts, cucumber and herbed Goat cheese…pesto aioli?
$15.95
De Soto Sandwich
Boar’s Head turkey breast, homemade herbed stuffing, baby greens and cranberry relish…pesto aioli?
$10.95
Longboat Brie Sandwich
Honey ham, Brie cheese, baby greens, cucumber, tomato and homemade mango chutney…pesto aioli?
$11.95
Islander Sandwich
Sliced roast beef, herbed Goat cheese, baby greens, tomato, cucumber and sweet red onions…pesto aioli?
$13.95
Port Rivo Sandwich
Marinated portobello mushroom, fresh Mozzarella, baby greens, tomato, sprouts, and pesto aioli.
$10.95
Bayfront Tuna Sandwich
Homemade Albacore tuna salad, fresh baby spinach, tomato, sprouts, cucumber, and Provolone cheese.
$13.95
Ca’D’Zan
Honey ham, roast beef, Swiss, smoked bacon, baby greens, tomato, sweet red onions, banana peppers, Dijon mustard and pesto mayo.
$13.95
Bradenturkey
Turkey breast, white aged cheddar, crispy bacon, tomato, cucumbers, greens, and our pesto aïoli.
$12.95
Paninis
Sliced Green Apple, Aged Cheddar & Spinach Panini
Grilled sandwich with our pesto aioli on fresh baked focaccia.
$9.95
Mushroom, Red Onion, Spinach, Sprouts & Swiss Panini
Grilled sandwich with our pesto aioli on fresh baked focaccia.
$9.95
Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella, Smoked Bacon & Basil Panini
Grilled sandwich with our pesto aioli on fresh baked focaccia.
$11.95
Albacore Tuna, Provolone & Baby Spinach Panini
Grilled sandwich with our pesto aioli on fresh baked focaccia.
$12.95
Locally Smoked Salmon, Goat Cheese & Red Onion Panini
Grilled sandwich with our pesto aioli on fresh baked focaccia.
$14.95
Boar’s Head Ham & 3-Cheese Panini
Grilled sandwich with our pesto aioli on fresh baked focaccia.
$11.95
Turkey, Brie & Mango Chutney
All grilled on our focaccia with pesto Mayo
$11.95
Half In The Bag
Half Sandwich & Soup Or Salad
Half sandwich comes with pesto mayo, lettuce and tomato. With a choice of a farmer’s market salad or one of our homemade soups. Served with pickle.
$14.95
Favorites & More
Turkey Groovin Reuben
Swiss cheese, homemade Thousand Island and sauerkraut on rye.
$11.95
Ahi Tuna Salad
Lightly pan-seared with sesame seeds, cucumbers, crispy wontons, asparagus and tomatoes over greens with ginger sesame vinaigrette.
$16.95
SRQPD Panini
Roast beef, Swiss, mushrooms, red onion, spinach and tomato with our pesto aioli grilled on focaccia.
$12.95
Siesta Fiesta
Seasoned chicken with shredded Cheddar, black olives, fresh avocado, salsa, and sour cream, over tortilla chips and greens.
$13.95
Desserts
Homemade Cookie $3.95
Brownie $3.25
Drinks
Bottled Water $1.95
Coke $3.95
Diet Coke $3.95
Orange Juice $3.99
Unsweet Tea $3.25
Sweet Tea $2.25
Vitamin Water $2.25
Sides
Homemade Potato Chips $3.25
Homemade Slaw $2.25

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Paul Harris
I love and hate this place. When I work downtown Sarasota, I got there smoke salmon sandwich. I love everything about that except the lettuce. It’s a healthy lettuce. But an iceberg lettuce would go better. So I order it with no lettuce. But now I work in Lakewood Ranch. Every time I’m downtown at seems to be after two and a very close.

… more

Timothy Kelly
The pastry is so good. They have good espresso too so espresso drinks are also delicious. Leave a tip!

… more

Christopher Judge
Drive past this place a million times and finally stopped in and I should have done it ages ago. I order the #4 panini, hummus, and a cookie. The sandwich was D-licious l! Fresh tomatoes, bacon crispy but not burnt, and that pesto aioli made it perfect. The only reason I’m not goving 5 stars is because they FORGOT MY COOKIE!!! So bummed but I will be back.

… more

T H
My husband and I frequent this place often. We think they have great food! We love the owner and the staff, especially Jim!

… more

Debbie Turner
Love everything I’ve ever ordered from here! Fresh ingredients, friendly staff and a cool atrium area to eat in during your lunch hour.

… more

Sandra Gary
Always pleasure to eat here. Great customer service and food.

… more

vladimir oleaga
The Braden-Turkey was amazing, the fries outstanding. The place has also a cool vibe to it, super friendly staff. Highly recommend!

… more

Nanna Mel
Loved the vibe, the staff (one guy) was very nice. Food was good but nothing crazy specialz

… more

Lisa B
It’s so good when they do it right, but they almost always get something wrong. I can’t seem to get the pickle with my sandwich despite asking for it on the last three orders and it being listed on the receipt. Okay, I can understand missing the pickle. Maybe they were out, but they should have mentioned it if that were the case. Unfortunately, my most recent order not only missed the pickle, but the sandwich I ordered was missing all the condiments and most of the meat as it was supposed to have multiple kinds, but no bacon and no roast beef, just had ham and not much of it. Way over priced for that. It wasn’t good like that at all. Again, if they were missing something because of shortage they should have mentioned it, but maybe they just messed up. If they were busy I would understand but they weren’t. They are friendly and I wish them well, but my orders were really simple and no special requests, so I don’t understand why they’re so messed up. I hate to say it, but I’m done with them. Too much competition downtown with great food. They mentioned losing business and I can see why. I hope they get their act together. I always root for small business.

… more

Edvin Mandzukic
Traveled for work and my co workers mentioned this place to me. I had a mushroom, onion and tomato panini and it was outstanding. For light and delicious. If you are in the downtown Sarasota area try this place out.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions