Casual, family-owned bar/eatery since 1977 with upscale seafood & steak dishes, plus daily specials. Based on 254 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$$
Address:
W278 N2316, W278N2316 Prospect Ave, Pewaukee, WI 53072
Phone: (262) 691-1450
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Christopher Adams
The prime rib, the ribeye, or the duck… I always have a hard time picking, we love this place! We ended up getting engaged here and Sarah and the staff went out of their way for us!
… more
Mauricio Varguez
A beautiful restaurant in the lake. Delicious food and friendly hosts. The patio is very nice.
… more
Jreggud
Steak salad was amazing. Fantastic drinks, they carry a great selection of bourbon and my favorite #BreckenridgeBourbon
… more
Amaya Dielen
I’ll start by saying that our waitress was very nice. She provided us the best service she could. The food on the other hand, was awful. The only food item that tasted good was the French onion soup. My partner ordered the blonde cut rib to be cooked medium. It was overcooked and rubbery. I ordered the shrimp scampi. The noodles were doused in so much sauce, it was overwhelming and ruined the taste of everything. We both ordered a baked potato on the side, which were undercooked. They were difficult to cut into and weren’t worth eating.
… more
Janis Ferguson
Welcomed as soon as we walked in. There were 5 in our group. We sat at the bar and enjoyed Brandy Old Fashion’s (Korbel) while chatting with the Owners and Bartender. At dinner we all ordered steak 4 prime rib and 1 Filet. We all agreed it was the best steak and dinner we have ever had along with the service. We e definitely be back!
… more
Stacy K (Wanderingcontessa)
Great old time supper club. Saturday night special is prime rib, which my husband had. I had a filet. It’s pricey, but well worth it. The decor has changed since we last visited. Very sunny and bright. The menu changed as well. They don’t have the lazy Susan for salads anymore, but our waitress brought us homemade croutons, which were delicious. You get soup and salad with your meal, along with ham salad and cheese spread. Well worth the trip.
… more
Peter Crivello
My wife and I really enjoy coming to Michael’s. The food is always delicious, and the staff is always warm and inviting. The prime rib is my favorite anywhere, and the specials are always great. Also, the drinks are very reasonable, especially the wines. This is a beautiful supper club, I highly recommend.
… more
JP Bluma
My son recently moved to the area and told me how wonderful this establishment was. Classy yet casual. He brought me there for Father’s day and it was fantastic savory Lucius steaks made perfect. My mouth is watering just thinking of it! They all were very polite, great with the kids and so hospitable. I think everyone deserves to spoil themselves at least once at this magnificent place. We will be back again soon without a doubt! Thanks for a most pleasurable dinning experience!
… more
David Hoefgen
Second time at michaels house of prime in two weeks. Great food as good as the old place
… more
Justin Dahlberg
While I think the place is a little dated and certain aspects were strange (the crackers and cheese and other spread, for example), this is a place that aims to please. From the bartender to the server to the, presumably, manager/owner, everyone was nice, inviting and seemed genuinely interested in us having a good time. We ordered an appetizer, I think it was called Sour Cream and Onion, and it was so good. I ordered the Ribeye while my wife ordered the prime rib… both were great but, the name of the place says it all. Get the prime rib, you won’t be disappointed.
… more
… View more