Mermaid Oyster Bar Menu – New York, NY

Type : Oyster bar restaurant

Location : New York, NY

Upscale-casual seafood spot with a coastal vibe known for its lobster rolls & oyster happy hours. Based on 886 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Mermaid Oyster Bar 10012

Address:
89 MacDougal St, New York, NY 10012

Phone: (212) 260-0100

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
4:30–10 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 4:30–10 PM
Wednesday 4:30–10 PM
Thursday 4:30–10 PM
Friday 4:30–10 PM
Saturday 4:30–10 PM
Sunday 4:30–9:30 PM

Menu

Dinner
½ DOZEN LITTLENECK CLAMS $12.00
TUNA CRUDO
jalapeño, avocado & lime
$18.00
YELLOWFIN TUNA TAQUITOS
miso, radish, cilantro & tofu crema
$18.00
JUMBO SHRIMP COCKTAIL
ea.
$5.50
BABY GRAND PLATTER
six clams, six oysters & salmon tartare
$42.00
GRAND PLATTER
twelve oysters, six clams, tuna crudo shrimp cocktail & salmon tartare
$79.00
SHISHITO PEPPERS
sea salt & candied lemon
$14.00
LOBSTER FRITTERS
truffle maple syrup & sea salt
$18.00
NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER
bacon & fingerling potatoes
$11.00
SEARED CALAMARI SALAD
cremini, shiitake, frisée & feta, olive oil, lemon
$17.00
LOBSTER KNUCKLES “ESCARGOT STYLE”
parsley garlic butter & grilled country bread
$18.00
STEAMED MAINE MUSSELS
celery, grilled sourdough & red coconut curry broth
$18.00
BUTTERED SHRIMP TOSTADA
avocado, serrano chili, cilantro crema, queso fresco & bean puree
$18.00
SHAVED KALE SALAD
house caesar, parmesan, garlic croutons & old bay chickpeas
$16.00
MERMAID WEDGE
cherry tomato, red onion, maytag blue cheese, apple~smoked bacon, buttermilk dressing & chives
$16.00
“NEW ORLEANS STYLE” BROILED OYSTERS
parmesan, garlic chips, toasted potato roll & smoked chorizo butter
$18.00
PAN ROASTED TRUE NORTH SALMON
baby bok choy, fresno chili, shiitake & dashi
$30.00
FIRE ROASTED NY STRIP STEAK
smashed fingerling potatoes, shishito & salsa verde
$42.00
STRIPED BASS A LA PLANCHA
roasted pumpkin puree, red swiss chard & almond brown butter
$30.00
MERMAID FISH TACOS
beer batter, red cabbage, pickled jalapeño & pico de gallo
$28.00
BLACKENED YELLOWFIN TUNA
escarole, grilled corn, portobello mushrooms & sweet corn puree
$34.00
“NEARLY FAMOUS” LOBSTER ROLL
griddled brioche bun & old bay fries
$35.00
LINGUINE & CLAMS
arugula, meyer lemon & aleppo pepper
$28.00
BRUSSELS SPROUTS
sherry & apple smoked bacon
$11.00
OLD BAY FRIES $10.00
BUTTERED HOT ROLLS
old bay & sea salt
$7.00
SAUTEED BROCCOLI RABE
chili flake & olive oil
$8.00
HOUSE SALAD
parmesan, red onion, carrot, radish & lemon citronette
$13.00
Drinks
BLOOD ORANGE HOSPITALITY
jalapeño-infused tequila, blood orange, agave, lime
$16.00
EMPRESS SOUR
empress 1908 gin, lemon, egg white
$16.00
BLACKBERRY BRAMBLE
vodka, pamplemousse, lime, blackberries
$16.00
LIFE IS A BEACH
gin, vodka, elderflower, pink grapefruit, lime & cucumber
$16.00
THE DREAM CATCHER
whiskey, yuzu, passion fruit & dry vermouth
$16.00
MARTINI LIMONCELLO
gin, limoncello, orange bitters
$16.00
MERMAID KISS
aged rum, passionfruit puree, amaretto, cherry liqueur
$16.00
SMOKEY SIENA
mezcal, pineapple, grand marnier & lime juice
$16.00
FALL FOR YOU
whiskey, pumpkin, lemon, orange bitters
$17.00
SPICED APPLE HOT TODDY
bourbon, apple cider, honey & cinnamon
$17.00
CLASSIC
gin, campari, vermouth di torino
$17.00
BIANCO
gin, lillet blanc, sweet vermouth
$17.00
SBAGLIATO
campari, sweet vermouth, prosecco
$17.00
SAUVIGNON BLANC
baker’s arona 2020 (marlborough, new zealand)
$16.00
CHARDONNAY
stel+mar 2020 (lodi, california)
$17.00
GAVI DI GAVI
il doge, broglia 2021 (piemonte, italy)
$16.00
MUSCADET
domaine henri poiron 2021 (loire, france)
$15.00
SANGIOVESE
bibi graetz 2019 (tuscany, italy)
$16.00
PINOT NOIR
karine lauverjat sancerre 2019 (loire, france)
$17.00
MERLOT
château auguste 2019 (bordeaux, france)
$16.00
CRÉMANT ROSÉ
de limoux 2019 (limoux,france)
$16.00
PROSECCO
ca’ furlan nv (veneto, italy)
$14.00
CHAMPAGNE
jean laurent blanc de noirs brut nv (champagne, france)
$21.00
RIESLING & PINOT GRIS
grape abduction 2021 (podravje, slovenia)
$15.00
TOSCANA ORANGE
buccia nera 2021 (tuscany, italy)
$17.00
RHÔNE BLEND
m. chapoutier 2020 (rhône valley, france)
$16.00
PROVENCE ROSÉ
le provencal 2020 (provence, france)
$15.00
MONTAUK PILSNER
(montauk, ny) 5.4%
$8.00
SIXPOINT BENGALI
ipa (brooklyn, ny) 6.6%
$8.00
FIVE BOROUGHS HOPPY LAGER
(brooklyn, ny) 6%
$8.00
CATSKILLS DEVILS PATH IPA
(catskills, ny) 7.5%
$8.00
ALLAGASH WHITE
(portland, me) 5.1%
$8.00
AUSTIN EASTCIDERS ORIGINAL DRY CIDER
(austin, tx) 5%
$8.00
ABITA AMBER
(covington, la) 4.5%
$8.00
SAUVIGNON BLANC
domain de beauséjour 2020 (loire, france)
$56.00
PINOT GRIGIO
pacher hof 2021 (alto adige,italy)
$68.00
SANCERRE
michel thomase 2021 (loire, france)
$65.00
RIESLING
(DRY) emile beyer tradition 2019 (alsace, france)
$72.00
VERMENTINO
terenzuola, vinge basse 2021 (liguaria, italy)
$50.00
CHABLIS
chardonnay, domaine alan geoffray 2021 (burgundy, france)
$72.00
CHENIN BLANC
husch vineyards 2020 (mendocino, california)
$58.00
GRÜNER VELTLINER
tatomer, meeresboden 2018 (santa barbara, california)
$56.00
CRÉMANT
bailly lapierre nv (burgundy, france)
$42.00
ROSÉ CHAMPAGNE
joseph perrier cuvée royale nv (champagne, france)
$92.00
BURGUNDY Pinot Noir, Antonin Rodet 2020 (Burgundy, France) $54.00
BURGUNDY Pinot Noir, Domaine Devaux 2019 (Burgundy, France) $65.00
MORGON
gamay, dominique piron, 2018 (beaujolois, france)
$52.00
BAROLO
nebbiolo, silvio grasso, barolo 2017 (piedmont, italy)
$88.00
MALBEC
malbec de cahors, gouleyant 2020 (cahors, france)
$54.00
TEMPRANILLO
sierra de toloño 2019 (rioja, spain)
$62.00
CÔTES DU RHÔNE
grenache & syrah ferraton pere et fils 2020 (rhône, france)
$68.00
BORDEAUX BLEND
blend chateau haut selve 2018 (bordeaux, france)
$78.00
PROVENCE ROSÉ
château peyrassol 2021 (provence, france)
$54.00
SANCERRE ROSÉ
domaine sautereau 2021 (loire, france)
$58.00
THE PINK FLAMINGO
gin, strawberry, basil & lemon
$9.00
MARGARITA
tequila, triple sec & lime
$9.00
HOT & DIRTY
vodka, olive juice, peppadew & hot sauce
$9.00
DARK AND STORMY
goslings rum, ginger syrup, lime juice
$9.00
APEROL SPRITZ
blanc de blancs & aperol aperitivo
$9.00
MERMAID MARY
vodka & house bloody mary mix
$9.00
WHITE $9.00
RED $9.00
SPARKLING $9.00
DRAFT BEER $6.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: opentable.com

Reviews

Ali Charkeih
The service was phenomenal, if I could give that category a 6/5 I would. They were very friendly and catered to our dietary restrictions.

… more

Jackson Guan
The outdoor seating was beautiful, the happy hour oysters were a great deal and delicious, but the server and host was not very welcoming. I felt that one they realized only 1 of us was going to order a drink the attentiveness just went out the window. I am not too beat up over it though, I got what I came for; a quick bite and 1 drink. The oyster were fresh and delicious, no arguments there. If you want to get in and get out quick for oysters, get over here!

… more

Martina Ruseva
Came here for dinner on a Friday night and the place was at full capacity. You definitely need a reservation. The food and service were great. We got oysters, the calamari salad and the sea bass. I recommend all three. Lastly, we got complementary chocolate pudding at the end and even though I wasn’t intending to eat anything sweet that night, I finished the whole thing overall, great experience here. I will be back!

… more

Emily N
Cute place for oysters and a nice happy hour. To note, all of the happy hour items are super small portions…. Delicious clam chowder in a tiny cup. It was very nice they brought out a tiny pudding cup at the end for a small dessert

… more

Sonia Siaw
Went here for Happy Hour! Really fun place to hangout with friends! $9 wines in the city, pretty good. Love the kale Caesar salad and their mini fish tacos, delish!

… more

Omar Lastname
This was a great spot for happy hour. They have a fantastic assortment of oysters. The shrimp silders were excellent and my favorite part of my meal. The spinach and artichoke dip was excellent. It’s not over creamy and bursting with flavor. The mini fish tacos were also excellent.

… more

Florence
Don’t hate. Shell-ebrate! Yummy oysters, roasted peppers, and cocktails! With a reservation on a Friday afternoon, my group of 3 shared and enjoyed several happy hour apps and drinks. I like my drinks a little spicy and my briny Hot & Dirty martini (mer-tini) perfectly fit the bill with vodka, olive juice, peppadew, and hot sauce. The Fried Calamari, Mini New England Clam Chowder, and Salmon Tartare were okay to pretty good but the Oysters and roasted Shishito Peppers dusted with sea salt and candied lemon were delish! After all this, we were full but our server kindly gave each of us a complementary chocolate mousse. Overall, a great spot to get your vitamin sea!

… more

Rona Walstra
Great atmosphere, excellent waitstaff, would have given 5 stars on food but the Oysters were very, very small, which was surprised since it’s advertised as an “Oyster Bar”. Overall we enjoyed our time and meal there.

… more

katlynn Blanton
This lobster roll was fantastic! I was traveling for work, so unfortunately my husband wasn’t with me, but I’ll say that we have been influenced by Old Bay on French fries after this restaurant. Can’t wait to go back and eat oysters when I’m not pregnant anymore because those looked great too!

… more

Thai Massage NYC
All is good,

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions