Easygoing counter-service chain known for its sandwiches, stuffed baked potatoes & sweet tea. Based on 957 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2025 W Jonathan Moore Pike, Columbus, IN 47201
Phone: (812) 657-8501
Hours
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10:30 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Char Penson
The food is good and fresh. I ordered a Ruben with a side of sauce & a chef salad for the next day’s lunch, both were delicious. The staff is very nice and patient, being that it was my first time there.
Sandy Arnold
Usually love eating at McAlister’s when I travel… and we have an annual event in Columbus, IN where we order about 30-40 box lunches x3 days in a row, and the service & quality have been outstanding for several years, even with staff changes & covid.
Lucy Maximoff-Quinn
Haven’t liked eating there since I was a kid tried to work at the one just opened up in Seymour and already had drama pop up and I only got through one week. Managers are unfriendly and so is the staff. One of them gave me an allergic reaction at a different place we worked at together. The food is just like any other deli. Don’t come here if you want friendly and good food.
Mona Jalal
I like the Rachel turkey sandwich here. I order from the app and they bring it to the table, via the app I was able to add garden vegetables and spinach to my sandwich. The potato salad is good too. This place has a cozy vibe and offers comfortable sitting.
Chloe Simon
Laid back atmosphere similar to a panera bread. Lots of different options on the menu including soup, salad and sandwiches. There is a kids menu available. I got the choose 2; broccoli cheddar soup and the chicken avocado salad. The soup was good, the put shredded cheese on top, which I personally could have done without. The salad was pretty good! The dressing that came with it was really great!! My husband got the jalapeño crunch sandwich and said it was good. My little one got this kids grilled cheese with fruit and a cookie. The food tasted good and was served very quickly. You order at the counter and they bring it to your table. The only reason i rated three stars instead of four, is because you can see the cooks through the window – both had very long hair and no hair nets and neither were wearing gloves. Also, the prices are too high for the small portion sizes. Other than that the place was clean, the sevice was fine and the food was decent!
… more
Franklin Jones
Sweet Tea, it’s all you need. It’s not true southern sweet tea, but it tastes pretty good. Can’t use it as pancake syrup like other tea places but it’s real sugar and not that sugar substitute made from unholy things. Sandwiches are good but pricey to me to which I am a lunch special person cause I am cheap but I like to think of it as frugal so I sound fancy.
Abby Normal
My innate cheapness rebels at well over $20 for sandwich, sides, drink, and tip, but that’s more on me than them.
Kathleen Gomez
Food is good. Service a bit slow. good variety of sandwiches. Great tea! Good soup. Carrot cake is top notch!
Rachel S
Wow, we really liked the salads we got from this place! The southwest chicken salad was very fresh and a good size. The avocado was actually fresh, real avocado. We tried the chipotle ranch and honey mustard dressing and I liked both of them honestly – The honey mustard was nice and sweet and tangy and the chipotle ranch wasn’t spicy but kind of smoky. We heated up the chicken at home (just personal preference) and add a little bit of pepper.
Jay Palmer
Absolutely a great dining experience! Traveling through the area and stopped for lunch. We had potato soup, savannah chopped salad, and club sandwich. Everything was so flavorful and prepared well. Cashier and server were nice. Restaurant was bright and clean. Reasonably priced.
… View more