Classic pizzeria fare in a relaxed space with a bar & TVs airing fights & other sporting events. Based on 889 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
223 E Brown Rd, Mesa, AZ 85201
Phone: (480) 733-6292
Website: https://mesamayanewyorkpizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
5 AM–2 AM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 5 AM–2 AM |
| Wednesday | 5 AM–2 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–2 AM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: mesamayanewyorkpizza.com
Reviews
Oscar B. Chacon
Not bad. Nothing special either. The food was decent. Everything was edible, but nothing really stood out as being special. Everyone was friendly. They had karaoke while we were there. The dining area was a bit dilapidated. The hallway to the bathroom was poorly lit and my wife shared she felt uncomfortable going to the restroom. Overall, I don’t think we’ll be returning. I think the restaurant has a lot of potential if they invest some time, energy and money making the space more polished and clean. If you’re looking for a small, low profile bar with a friendly atmosphere that also serves food…, you might like this place.
… more
Andrew Lawver
This place is completely run down and terrible! We were skeptical from the driveway when we saw no cars, but thought we might give it a chance. We walk in and it’s a ghost town, the only people we see are playing pool at two sad pool tables off to the side. we realize after a couple of minutes standing around that they are actually the people working inside this building. They were more focused on their pool game, then a customer walking into the door! Bar looked very sad, but we sat there due to the fact, we weren’t offered a seat, and when the bartender came over, we were handed a menu of which nothing was actually available to order except a few items. Six out of the eight beers offered on their top were completely out. We ended up, leaving after drinking a few sips of the beer because we were convinced it was old at this point. This place is completely sad and by the way, the air conditioning was set at probably 82°. This place should close down and stay away. There was fish food displayed on their bar, this is disgusting.
… more
Nataya Crawford
This was a strange experience. This place has potential, but it’s just not there yet. May have been a great place back in the day. There was karaoke, and pool tables. There was lots of seating, but not many people there, although the few people who were there were extremely nice and seemed like they were having the time of their lives.
… more
Miguel Salazar
Horrible, from the customer service all the way to the food. After an hour wait with the establishment empty should not have been a problem but the quality of the food was unacceptable. Food tasted old and was uncooked, absolutely no meat on the nachos, and to top it off. They were unable to give me an itemized receipt due to their “system being down”. Will not return, zero stars if I could. Will definitely not recommend, go to native bar and grill across the street instead.
… more
T russell
I think the food is great. Have eaten there quite a bit and always really enjoyed the food. However, the service is mediocre most of the time, and bathrooms could be cleaned a bit better. I hope they can take constructive criticism and step it up in the near future because I really do love the food
… more
Mar Gar
This pizza was delicious. It seems like more of a bar but very tasty pizza. I ordered a Mediterranean it was missing the artichoke but i think my pizza was technically not on the menu so that was just me being complicated but WOW delicious!!!!
… more
Borus Amsted
Went in expecting a high end pizza restaurant, when I arrived the hostess was wearing sunglasses at 10pm and had a very bad attitude directing me to the end of the bar where I waited by a few women who very clearly looked like they were overdressed for a Wednesday night. The music was too loud and very trashy. In all honesty it gave off the vibe you would get at a strip club with random dudes sitting around. The customers and employees seemed shocked I was there for food, this place has got to be a front…
… more
Dolores Damian
We were super hungry so everything was good.
… more
Kristina
We got the Giant(largest they have) pizza…. Was excellent. Cooked and crispy crust all the way through and plenty of cheese, which makes me smile Amazing how it can be thoroughly cooked, as large as it is.
… more
Nicole Ecklund
Absolutely no respect for the neighbors. Music WAY TOO LOUD. I tried calling multiple times and the phone line seems to just not work. How convenient.
… more
… View more