Based on 480 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
301 N Beaver St, Lisbon, OH 44432
Phone: (330) 424-3559
Website: https://www.themaryspizzashop.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–10 PM |
| Thursday | 3–10 PM |
| Friday | 3–10 PM |
| Saturday | 3–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 3–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Amanda S
The best pizza we have ever had! We have lived in 3 different states and have yet to find anything remotely close. We are fortunate enough to have family who brings us a few frozen pizzas every time they come down as we are no longer local. We hands down recommend if you’ve never had it. If you have, go head and eat that extra piece you’ll never regret it!
Private Primate
There are very few pizzas in the world like a pie from Mary’s Pizza. A unique deep potent pizza with thick pan crust style with a unique sauce that has a complex spice blend, but most notably lands on the sweet-side, and a non-standard cheese blend that is aslo applied in a non-standard way, makes for a very powerful slice. Commonly known in the region, Mary’s is a pizza surely made to be one of your favorite pizzas. There just isn’t anything else quite like it. The place has been a stable, same-recipe, mutil-generational, staple of the area and doesnt just stand the tests of time, it stands out in the world of pizza and has won national awards at pizza competitions. People come from all over to try it and I’ve never had one that was inconsistent with their complex delicious presentation. Also the wings are good. The pizza rolls are good. The staff is extremely friendly. This town would not be the same without it.
… more
Erica Collins
We are from out of town and were looking for something to get for carry out. After seeing all the positive reviews about Mary’s Pizza, we wanted to give it a try. All I can say is: BEST. PIZZA. EVER! The sauce is amazing and you can tell everything is made from scratch. Will definitely be going back here if we are ever in town again!
Asia Brooks
I’ve never heard of Mary’s Pizza, and I was skeptical when I couldn’t order online. Let me tell you. I will dream of this pizza. Some of the best I’ve ever had. The staff also had such a positive energy!
Laura Sanders
A Lisbon tradition! I love the whole tomato pizza! The rest of my family loves the original Mary’s sauce!
Rebecca Schweizer
Tried Marys for the 1st time while visiting family. The food was absolutely amazing. Will definitely have it again when I’m in town.
Burt Michaels
Voted best Pizza in Columbiana County for the xx time in a row. So I had really high expectations that were not met. The sauce was sweet so that was different just like the cheese after it comes out the oven. I didn’t care for the rock hard crust. I feel like East of Chicago is better and they have a buffet.
Omgits Soup
Pizza would’ve been better with the toppings on top. They use a bit cheaper cheese on top of pizza. It comes off messy, which isn’t much of a problem, but destroys the entire experience. I am not a huge fan of having to clean up a mess just to put back together what was once my pizza. The cheese was also really gritty and had this stringyness to it i didn’t like. Otherwise pizza sauce and every other part of the pizza was great. If the owners ever see this I would really recommend losing the provolone.
Rachel Davis
Best pizza in the world! Yes I said it, the entire world! First and foremost it’s a family run business and has been around for a LONG time (got to love and support our local Mom and Pop businesses) secondly, from the dough to sauce it’s all great! It’s like a party in your mouth with every bite, fresh flavors all around! They also make pizzas with out the cheese so that you can freeze them, they send you with the cheese to put it on before you bake it so it’s all fresh and yummy at home just like you get them from their little store! I recommend Mary’s to everyone I meet!! 🙂
Amanda
This is THE best pizza I ever tasted, wish there was one out West lol. When I went back to Ohio a few month’s ago I had to ordered a pizza because no other pizza shops compares to Mary’s and I’ve been to many pizza shops throughout the states and nothing compares to there’s. If you love pizza this place you have to try… (employees are great, friendly)
… View more