Converted home offering a welcoming environment for a range of traditional American dishes. Based on 777 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
5023 New St, Geneva, OH 44041
Phone: (440) 466-8606
Website: https://maryskitchengotl.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 7 AM–3 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–3 PM |
| Sunday | 7 AM–3 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Marcus Barkley
Really quaint and plesant diner right on the Lake Erie Shoreline in Geneva. My family went for breakfast on a rainy Monday morning, and were grateful for the wonderful service from our waitress, especially as we had four children (ages 1 to 7) in tow.
… more
Radar Varner
I had a dessert that was so delicious. I ate it first. I ordered an omelet it was so great and it was a very large I loved it. And I had a pancake that was so delicious that I wanted the recipe it literally melted in my mouth. I wish I were even hungrier I would have had more everything there was great if you have not been at Mary’s kitchen get there and you too will write a great review. Did I say it was great? It was. 10/10.
… more
AJ
A must-visit when you’re in the area! Our waitress, Cindy, was so very welcoming and friendly (everyone was). Despite being a busy weekend, the food came out promptly. I highly recommend the avocado toast. Pancakes are also incredible. Love the atmosphere as well. Thanks for a great experience!
… more
Gary Connor
Stopped for a late Monday lunch. Crowded but immediately seated. Jessica was our server and she was a jewel. Friendly and quirky she made the lunch so much more than a quick meal. Her suggestions were right on the money. Food arrived promptly. Bacon chicken wrap with onion rings and a meatloaf melt with fresh sliced tomato. All the food just perfect. Large portions were filling but Jessica suggested we split a cinnamon bun. OMG! Warm, gooey icing and sweet tangy taste was just great. Really didn’t want the meal to end. Prices were touristy but I will go out off my way to find a way to go back.
… more
Leah Hartman
They have great classics and fun new menu items. I loved the avocado toast (special seasoning makes it unique), paired with redskin potatoes and a side of fresh fruit. The soft texture of a perfectly seasoned house made veggie burger was a welcome treat, perfect with just a touch of mayo – most places just heat up a frozen one. A side salad and their fresh cut fries made a great meal. The staff is friendly & attentive and they have great coffee here. One of my favorite things about this place, though – the sunny yellow & white awning makes me smile every time I see it. Looking forward to enjoying more great meals here.
… more
Carol Sheasley
Great place for a family reunion with a cousin I hadn’t seen in more than 20 years. We’d originally considered Eddy’s, but decided Mary’s would be less crazy and more conducive to having a conversation. It definitely was — plus the food and everything else was top notch.
… more
nicholas fusco
Definitely hands down. I had one of the best experiences at this restaurant. I had a meatloaf Burger on country toast and it was absolutely delicious. Crispy on the country toast and very tender on the meatloaf. My son Nick had a burger which I think it might have been frozen but it was actually very tasty. He had pickles, mushrooms, lettuce and provolone cheese and it was really really good. The best part of the meal were the two ladies. One was the hostess named Brooke who entertained us while we were waiting for a waitress and she had a party of 14 before us but she was there at a timely manner. Her name was Jess. These ladies made us definitely feel like we were at home. Full of laughs and just great people and they made me feel like they’re still hope for our country. They said they will follow the owner of the restaurant anywhere. They’ve never been happier somewhere else. It’s all about how you treat your employees. You get the best attitudes out of your employees. Please don’t change a thing. I absolutely love it and God bless. If you’ve never been here on this little Alley in GOTL….. You must try it. You won’t be disappointed. Customer service was above and beyond. God bless
… more
Chasity Strawder
My husband & I had breakfast here for the first time. We wanted to be amazed at the food, but we were not. I ordered the avocado toast with eggs & home fries. The presentation was terrible. The avocado was hard at first. I had to send it back to exchange for softer avocado. The bread wasn’t well toasted, and the tomatoes slices were small. The home fries were average. My husband ordered a steak omelet. He told me he had a better omelet at other restaurants. Our waitress was friendly. The coffee was hot, but we won’t be back.
… more
Sally Rosellini
Had breakfast here every day on vacation! Delicious omelets! A DEFINITE add to your Geneva vacation! Accommodating service!
… more
Terri Lim
We have been coming here for years from Cleveland and today was the first time we were very disappointed. We brag about your cinnamon rolls to all our friends. We got 6 Togo and when we got home found that they were all burnt on the bottom. The service wasn’t up to it’s usual greatness and I was never asked if I wanted a refill on my coffee.
… more
… View more