Based on 57 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
Address:
18 E Main St, Evansville, WI 53536
Phone: (608) 882-1315
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Amber Godfrey
Got a delicious stuffed pizza 12/10 Super delicious and filling. I highly recommend!
… more
Christina Whitelaw
The chicken and spinach Alfredo pizza is the best. We add shrimp, black olives, mushrooms and extra cheese. It’s our favorite pizza.
… more
Kimberly Pillar
Steak sandwich is a must have. I’d get it without lettuce and with extra sauce on the side. Soooooo good. And don’t pass up the pasta. Haven’t had the pizza yet but I’m sure it won’t disappoint considering how amazing the rest of the food is. Plus everyone there is super friendly. Gotta love good customer service.
… more
P G
We hadn’t been to Marsala’s since they moved to Evansville and we were weekly patrons when they were in Stoughton for so many years. I am happy to find the pizza is as good, maybe better than I remember.
… more
Amanda Rose
The food here was definitely not the highlight of our visit. Don’t get me wrong, it was delicious. Some of the best breadsticks I’ve ever had. What really made the night was the waitress, Tina. She was kind, attentive, and oh so very personable. There wasn’t a guest in there that she wasn’t sweet too. A woman at another table forgot her reading glasses, and Tina came to her rescue by letting her borrow hers. Food can be amazing but it’s the experience that staff bring that really makes or breaks a dining trip. Keep on being you Tina! ♡
… more
Adam Faherty
I ordered the hot wings as an appetizer. the wingettes were hot all the way through, but the drummies were ice cold on the bone. The server took them back and the kitchen remade them, but again they were still on the cold side. I dealt with it. The meat to fat ratio was extremely in favor of fat, and not very appetizing. Unless you order the BBQ or Garlic Parmesan ones, the hot wings are unseasoned, and have no sauce on them I guess. Caught me a little off guard.
… more
Robert Johnson
Bad experience. Ok pizza. Very slow. Told me when I ordered 25 minutes. Arrived and said it would be another 15 minutes. Ok. Ordered 2 small pizzas. One small cheese and 1 small sausage & mushroom. $26 dollars plus for 2 small pizzas. Looked at menu when I arrived home and was over charged. When I opened the sausage & mushroom pizza there were no mushrooms. Won’t be going back.
… more
Mary Kubly
For sure the best pizza in the area. Don’t like a lot of toppings “on my side” so they suggested the meat sauce. My husband added on toppings to his side! Delicious!! On your way home from a day of golf at the Evansville Golf Club stop by Marsala for dinner in or to go!!
… more
Tim Goke
Tried Marsala’s for the first time the other day for delivery, I was NOT disappointed! The pizza arrived as if it just came out of the oven, I even burned the roof of my mouth on a delivered pizza, that’s unheard of! Cheese was clearly high quality and plenty of toppings to satisfy.
… more
Lisa James
Delicious Italian dishes, spaghetti, lasagna, ravioli, and more.. big portions, great for leftovers, family recipe homemade sauce and meatballs. Love the pizza also , best around. Family have been serving communities in the area for years, recently opened in Evansville.
… more
… View more