Mario’s Menu – Setauket- East Setauket, NY

Type : Italian restaurant

Location : Setauket- East Setauket, NY

Upmarket, bustling restaurant with a menu of classic Italian entrees & a warm setting. Based on 474 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Mario's 11733

Address:
Old School House Square, 212 Main St, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733

Phone: (631) 751-8840

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 3–10 PM
Wednesday 3–10 PM
Thursday 3–10 PM
Friday 3–11 PM
Saturday 3–11 PM
Sunday 3–10 PM
Monday 3–10 PM

Menu

Appetizers
Fried Calamari
Local calamari tossed in signature breading, fried golden brown with marinara sauce
$18.25
Shrimp Oreganata
Lemon, garlic, white wine, rustic breadcrumbs.
$17.10
Mario’s Meatballs
Housemade meatballs, tomato sauce, ricotta, parmesan.
$13.70
Mozzarella Sticks
12 breaded mozzarella sticks with marinara sauce
$13.70
Buffalo Calamari
Housemade buffalo sauce, celery, carrots, bleu cheese crumbles.
$19.40
Baked Clams
Seven whole, roasted clams baked oreganata style.
$14.85
Eggplant Tower
Fried eggplant layered between beefsteak tomatoes and fresh mozzarella with a balsamic drizzle.
$18.25
Mini Rice Balls
10 pieces, stuffed with rice, mozzarella, parmesan, tomato sauce and peas.
$13.70
Garlic Bread $6.85
Sliders
Choice of eggplant, chicken, or meatball parmigiana
$11.40
Fried Zucchini
Fried golden brown with horseradish sauce.
$14.85
Fried Ravioli
12 breaded ravioli served with marinara sauce.
$13.70
Wings
10 jumbo, bone-in wings tossed in choice of sauce.
$17.10
Soups & Salads
House Salad
Mixed greens, cucumber, tomato, onion with choice of dressing.
$11.40
Caesar Salad
Romaine, shaved parmesan, croutons, creamy Caesar dressing.
$13.70
Caprese Salad
Beefsteak tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, roasted red peppers, balsamic glaze on a bed of mixed greens.
$16.00
Arugula Salad
Arugula, cherry tomato, red onion, shaved parmesan, house vinaigrette
$16.00
Tuna Sashimi Salad
Sesame seed crusted seared (raw) tuna, mixed greens, avocado, mango, mango vinaigrette
$22.80
Greek Salad
MIxed greens, tomato, red onion, cucumber, olive medley, feta cheese, tri-color pepper blend, creamy Greek dressing
$18.25
Apple Salad
Mixed greens, diced apples, candied walnuts, craisins, crumbled blue cheese, crumbled bacon, raspberry vinaigrette.
$18.25
Soup Of The Day
Chef’s daily creation, available as a cup or a bowl
$6.85
Pasta
Penne Alla Vodka
Prosciutto, parmesan, pink cream sauce
$18.25
Fettuccine Alfredo
Creamy garlic parmesan sauce.
$18.25
Primavera
Fresh vegetables, choice of pasta, tossed in tomato sauce or garlic & oil.
$19.40
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Three homemade meatballs in tomato sauce with spaghetti.
$19.40
Rigatoni Bolognese
Beef, veal, & pork stewed in pomodoro sauce with a splash of cream.
$19.40
Five-Cheese Ravioli
Cheese stuffed pasta, marinara sauce, baked with mozzarella
$18.25
Nonna’s Lasagna
Fresh layered pasta, bolognese meat sauce, mozzarella, parmesan, ricotta cheese.
$20.55
Broccoli In Garlic And Oil
Sauteed broccoli, garlic, choice of pasta
$18.25
Stuffed Shells
Cheese stuffed, tomato sauce, mozzarella
$18.25
Baked Ziti
Penne, ricotta, mozzarella, tomato sauce.
$16.00
Bellisimo
Pesto cream sauce, asparagus, sun-dried tomatoes, shaved parmesan.
$20.55
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Sautéed shrimp and baby spinach in a spicy marinara sauce with choice of pasta.
$28.50
Greek Pasta
Spinach, tomatoes, red onions, feta cheese and chicken in a Greek lemon butter sauce.
$27.40
Stuffed Shells Alla Vodka
Cheese stuffed shells with vodka sauce and mozzarella.
$19.40
Baked Ziti Bolognese
Penne, ricotta, tomato, mozzarella, bolognese meat sauce.
$19.40
Burger Bar
Cheeseburger
8oz burger, choice of cheese, with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle.
$17.10
Bacon Cheeseburger
8oz burger, choice of cheese, crispy bacon strips, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle.
$18.25
The Godfather
Topped with prosciutto, bruschetta, fresh mozzarella, arugula, pesto mayo.
$21.70
Hangover Burger
Topped with American cheese, sunny side up egg, bacon, crispy onions, hollandaise aioli.
$22.80
Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana
Choice of Pasta
$22.80
Eggplant Parmigiana
Choice of pasta
$20.55
Meatball Parmigiana
Choice of pasta
$22.80
Shrimp Parmigiana
Choice of pasta
$28.50
Entrees
Marsala
Mushrooms, marsala demi sauce.
$25.10
Francese
Lightly floured and egg dipped, sautéed with lemon butter and white wine sauce.
$25.10
Piccata
Artichokes, capers, lemon, butter wine sauce.
$25.10
Shrimp
Choice of preparation: Francese, oreganata or scampi. Served with choice of side.
$28.50
Bruschetta
Two Panko-crusted chicken or veal cutlets, bruschetta, fresh mozzarella, balsamic drizzle.
$22.80
Milanese
Chicken or veal fried cutlet topped with arugula, cherry tomatoes, red onions, shaved parmesan on a bed of roasted potatoes.
$28.50
Grilled Chicken
Served with rice pilaf and seasonal vegetables.
$26.25
Heroes
Chicken Parmigiana Hero $18.25
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero $17.10
Meatball Parmigiana Hero $18.25
Shrimp Parmigiana Hero $20.55
Chicken Club Hero
Fried chicken, lettuce, tomato, American cheese, bacon, mayo.
$18.25
Buffalo Shrimp Hero
Fried buffalo shrimp, lettuce, tomato, blue cheese dressing.
$22.80
Eggplant Caprese Hero
Fried eggplant, beefsteak tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, arugula, pesto mayo.
$17.10
Platters
Fried Shrimp Platter
Served with tartar or cocktail sauce and French Fries.
$25.10
Chicken Finger Platter
Choice of sauce, served with French Fries.
$16.00
Fried Calamari Platter
Served with marinara sauce and French Fries.
$27.40
Wing Platter
Choice of sauce, served with French Fries.
$20.55
Children’s Menu
K/ Mozzarella Sticks
With French Fries
$10.30
K/ Chicken Fingers
With French Fries
$10.30
K/ Penne Pasta With Tomato Sauce Or Butter $6.85
K/ Personal Cheese Pizza $10.30
K/ Spaghetti And Meatballs $10.30
K/ Ravioli
Four raviolis, butter or tomato sauce
$9.15
K/ Chicken Parmigiana And Fries
Children’s portion of chicken parmigiana, with French Fries
$12.55
Sides
Side Of Pasta $6.85
Meatballs (2) $9.15
Garlic Knots $3.45
Sauteed Spinach $6.85
Mashed Potatoes $6.85
Seasonal Vegetables $6.85
Side House Or Caesar Salad $6.85
Sauteed Broccoli Rabe $9.15
Grilled Asparagus $9.15
Desserts
NY Style Cheesecake
Creamy cheesecake, graham cracker crust with strawberry sauce.
$9.15
Ultimate Chocolate Cake
Velvet chocolate mousse, cookie crust, chocolate ganache, chocolate chips.
$9.15
Gelato $6.85
Peanut Butter Explosion
Layered chocolate ganache, rich peanut butter mousse, topped with brownie bits, peanut butter chips.
$10.30
Chocolate Lava Cake
Flourless chocolate cake with a warm chocolate center and a scoop of vanilla gelato.
$11.40

… View more

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: opentable.com

Reviews

Shaquawnna Burks
It’s was great! Atmosphere was vibrant. Live music on Thursdays! Wow! Exceeded our expectations! Servers were very attentive. My water glass was never empty.

… more

Yash Kapoor
The fires were burnt tasted and felt like cardboard. The food was generally bland and unseasoned. I bought the Pene Alla Vodka which was supposed to come with prosciutto but it didn’t come with any. When I asked the waitress about it she said they took it off the menu I was never informed. The vibe of the place was nice but the food was not appetizing at all.

… more

Jon
Greeters and wait staff are all very friendly and helpful. The bar and kitchen needs a little help. We received summer sangrias that were nothing more than watered down fruit punch and the chicken Marsala was made with what looked and tasted like canned beef gravy.

… more

Framing Fan
Have loved it here for many years. Sadly not at the moment. Staff needs training. Servers repeatedly forgot requested items then one simply dropped them on the table with a “sorry” afte 2 requests and 20 mimute wait. Then when we were nearly done they brought it. Servers not familar with menu items. Soda gun needs cleaning (moldy taste on seltzer). This is not the pre fire Setauket Mario’s we knew and loved. Music was so depressing cut after cut of 70s drab hits weird. Bar and seats were empty on a holiday Friday at 830? That might tell you all you need to know. Please train staff. Fish was good but chicken was tough and over salted. Pound it flat. Twice had to get server when restaurant mostly vacant. Sad to see an old favorite struggle.

… more

pd speh
Met a few old friends form the area here at the bar. the bartender was great! Made me a special SMOKED OLD FASHION! What a great drink. Highly recommend going in and trying this. The smoke flavor in the drink was great and she told us about using the smoker to smoke cheese or meat. really cool friendly knowledgeable bartender.

… more

Sandra smith
Don’t go here. Don’t listen to the locals who think it’s okay. It’s not I’ve been coming here for ages. After the fire it went down hill bad. They left me sitting for 45 minutes waiting for my food that I ordered over the phone. Told me 20 minutes, came in nothing was ready. People come here to get drunk at the bar and order mediocre Italian food. I was just going here for grilled chicken to put with a salad. Oh and not to mention for grilled chicken and broccoli it’s 52 dollars. The girls at the front constantly gossip, and are rude and act like it’s you’re the one being rude when asking when your food will be ready.

… more

Rick Caravaggio
We came here with our family After a wake and we had a private room with 13 people, the people treated us with such respect and dignity during a difficult time. Food was excellent and so was the service I recommend this place highly.

… more

Diane Melidosian
Went to Marios 4/18/23. Was very pleasantly surprised by everything. I heard there is a new chef. If so, keep him/her.

… more

Rob Grimm
We went to Mario’s for pasta night. Great food, wonderful choices and fantastic service at unbelievable prices. However, it was a bad night for rice pudding. It was horrible. The women at the next table also sent ot back.

… more

James Carr
We had a horrible experience – all of our orders were wrong or incomplete and we had to wait an extra long time for our meals. We had to put in multiple requests for bread, water refills, and to-go boxes. I’m not sure if I caught them on a really bad day, but I’m hesitant to go back.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions