Based on 122 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
41 New Main St, Haverstraw, NY 10927
Phone: (845) 429-5220
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Malatak
I always take stars away for certain things in this case it was 1 service and 1 for quality of food. Was passing by this little town while at work at saw a pizza spot so I gave them a try. I walk in there is 1 guy behind the counter and another walking around. I wasn’t greeted and I was the only person at the counter. The guy just looked at me and said “yea”… we’ll ok then. I asked if they had fresh blue cheese to put on my Buffalo slice if I ordered it and he said yes. I asked for it to be warmed up not to hot and to serve it on a plate since I had planned to eat it as I left. He served it to me sooo hot and cooked the credit had become over baked and to crunchy which I don’t like and it was the last Buffalo so I just took it. The blue cheese he gave me in a small cup and really wanted it on top but that’s not too major. While waiting I asked to use the restroom and the guy said let me get the key, he then spoke to the other guy about the key abs he came back to tell me someone must have locked the key inside so no bathroom. Overall I wasn’t please with the service and in a stickler for places that say “Restaurant” because to me that gives a higher level of expectation and this place failed to deliver. Unfortunately there isn’t another pizzeria close by to this one so if your ever in this town you’ll have to hold off at least 10-20 min to drive to another area with better service and food and lastly the slice was ehh I would give it a 5 out of 10 it’s not the quality of chicken I’m use to getting down in Long Island and it was burnt sooo. There it is hope this helps someone out as well as the restaurant themselves, they need to step up the level if service and learn how to greet customers and make them feel welcomed.
… more
Rickie-NYC
Stopped in for some pizza. It wasn’t great but would say no entirely bad. If they add a bit more sauce would greatly improve the experience.
… more
JoAnne Weiss
Update 2/3/21: Still my favorite, even more now since returning to eating in & my weekly stop.. The absolute best Margherita & also veggie pizza in the county, fresh veggies & thin, perfect crisp crust. Yesterday had lunch/dinner with chicken parm, first time, I’m fussy & this was perfection in every way! Lucky as a non-driver I have this gem in my neighborhood!!
… more
Megs Adams
Its a pizza shop. I rarely order pies from there because I am a picky pizza person (NYC native) but the other food menu is delicious! We are a family of 6 and split the 1of the meals between the little kids. We usually get the chicken franchese, chicken parm dinner or sandwhich, penne vodka with or with chicken n brocc.
… more
Rita Bosico
Best pizza. We get plain cheese, pepperoni, and even their vegetable topped pizza. It’s all so delicious. And their garlic knots are great too! Easy parking for carryout. Quick service.
… more
Saira Vargas
Mariella’s is a hidden jem in Haverstraw, NY. Their food is made with quality.
… more
Brad Gold (NCNYChief)
Great food at typical prices. Quaint little restaurant and takeout options. However- Judy the waitress will talk your ears off though to the point we won’t go to the restaurant anymore. She even interrupted a conversation we were having with another couple to offer her opinion. Sometimes she’s the delivery person too…
… more
Timothy Cahill
great pizza, strombolis, and wings! have yet to sit and be served in their dining area but have had the above mentioned foods either as take-out or in their pizzeria style seating. always friendly counter service, fair prices, prompt timing.
… more
Ed Molina
Excellent service, good food, but mostly takeout.
… more
Crystal Brown
I had a slice of pizza which smelled way better than it actually tastes. Needless to say it was very disappointing.
… more
… View more