Based on 277 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
115 S Thomas Ave, Sayre, PA 18840
Phone: (570) 888-9944
Website: http://mangialardos.edan.io/
Hours
| Tuesday | 5–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 5–10 PM |
| Thursday | 5–10 PM |
| Friday | 5–11 PM |
| Saturday | 5–11 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 5–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
David Alliger
Great atmosphere, delicious food, and great service. If you love the old fashioned places this is the spot. Definitely try the garlic pizza. World class.
… more
Lacey Valoroso
Went to dinner tonight with my fiancé for Valentine’s Day. Made reservations a couple weeks ago but it didn’t even seem to matter since the guy that sat us didn’t really care. We got sat in the back by the kitchen and at a small table and it just felt crowded. There was no music playing, dim lighting, and just people talking that resulted in a weird atmosphere. Server asked us for drinks and was very quiet almost could not hear her. We ordered mozzarella sticks for an appetizer, how could we go wrong? They came out burnt and out waitress never asked if we liked them. I ordered gnocchi W/ meatballs & he ordered ravioli W/ Meatballs. In the mean time they brought us bread. The garlic bread was pretty good. Our meal was edible but not great. The gnocchi just didn’t look good or taste good. My fiancé said ravioli was basic. Sauce was good. Went to pay and there was no spot for a tip on the receipt, asked server, she said the owner just switched to card system and is old school. Had to use the ATM in the back, just to be able to tip our waitress. Will not return.
… more
Lawrence Dusek (Larry)
ambiance us a little too dark making it difficult for someone with vision issues to adjust or read menu. Food overall was good. But the Chicken Marsala was DROPPED in the FRYER? First time I’ve encountered that. Plus the Marsala flavor was not well represented on the palate. Overall, still a worthy place to enjoy Italian food.
… more
Tracy Wandell
If you are looking for some Italian food where you can enjoy an old school restaurant this is the place. The garlic pizza bread you get as an appetizer before the meal and bread is wonderful. Veal is good and also homemade spaghetti.
… more
Dorothy Buynak
It was an experience. Definitely felt like stepping into a time warp. It was pleasant, the owner was our server, she was sweet but sassy as you would expect from an older Italian lady. But the food lacked in the salt and pepper department, but that was easy to fix at the table.☺️
… more
mark burnett
Family restaurant celebrating 90 years. The classic styling of the interior is maintained as is for at least the last 50 years. A must visit when I get home. Famous for their garlic pizza, but the entire menu is very good.
… more
Matt Wills
Amazzzing! The garlic cheese pizza honestly is an incredible slice of heaven. Its the only thing I ever get there, but I hear they have other great dishes. But the garlic cheese pizza is what they’re known for. I usually get a couple half-baked pizzas to take home and freeze for later, since I live 2 hours away. It’s definitely worth the drive. This is a family-run restaurant, and when you’re there the long-time servers and staff treat you like family too. You can’t go wrong with this place!
… more
Daniel Carey
This place was OLD SCHOOL Italian. Playing the theme from The Godfather in the background.
… more
nina horton
My husband and I made reservations for our first (and last visit). We couldn’t find a hostess to be seated. After waiting ackwardly near the two entrances the owner approached us. We told him we had a reservation, he waved to an area with two empty tables and told us to sit over there. We sat at the table that was furthest away from the large party in the middle of the room. After we were sitted the owner came over and very loudly told us get up this table is already taken, sit over there. So we got up and moved to the table next to the huge party. We sat and waited at least 20 minutes before anyone came to ask us which drinks we would like. We had already looked at the menu and placed our order as well. We waited another 20 minutes for our sodas to arrive. Our salads and bread did not come with them. We waited a total of 40 min before those arrived. Then our dinners came out immediately. The whole time we were waiting other customers came in and received their food and drinks. The waitress was very apologetic, but the situation was extremely disappointing. While waiting we witnessed the owner treat his staff very poorly, constantly yelling and demeaning them. Our food was ok at best and there are many other (better) options for Italian in the valley. Even if the food had been excellent we would not return after witnessing the rude behavior of the owner.
… more
Dawn Bellows
We had dinner and drinks here and had some awesome garlic pizza! The bar was gorgeous and the service was top notch. My boyfriend has been going here since he was a kid and his stories were all so lovely about the people here. I’m glad that he made me part of his memories of this place. Can’t wait to go back!
… more
… View more