Enjoy the best pizza in Bayville like the locals do.
Local residents have made Mama’s Pizzeria/Tony’s Pizza one of the most popular in the area. Sample what they have to offer and see if you agree.
Immerse yourself in the culinary scene of Bayville with some of the area’s top dishes. These classics are popular for a reason, so go ahead and see what all the fuss is about. See why the locals rave about Cheese Pizza at Mama’s Pizzeria/Tony’s Pizza. This local favorite is popular for a reason.
Complete your meal with french fries, it’s a great way to make dinner into a feast.
Based on 215 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
340 Atlantic City Blvd, Bayville, NJ 08721
Phone: (732) 269-5555
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lee Carter
Order a pie and wings. Order said out for delivery at 625 estimated delivery 626. At 725 had Order canceled as delivery driver never showed and they are .04 miles from me. Never ordering from again.
… more
jim griffin
I have lived in NJ for 37 years. I Have tried many many different pizza places and i can honestly say without over exaggerating this is by far the worst i have tasted. It was inedible had absolutely NO taste just grease from cheap cheese. Floppy, greasy disgusting pizza. One bite and the pizza went in the garbage. Not even garlic salt of red pepper flake could fix this disgusting abomination.
… more
Joanna Rebisz
I ordered garlic bread sliders with meatballs, fresh mozzarella/tomatoes, and pizza it was delicious. Food was fresh and warm when delivered. Strongly recommend, I was really satisfied with the order.
… more
Kenneth Dwyer
First time ordering from here. We ordered the chicken parmesan pizza, sausage Stromboli and wings. All were very good.
… more
Captain Drunk guy.
I thought the food was phenomenal. I believe the owner served me very busy by himself and was super polite! My own boss would have been quite the opposite.
… more
Angela DiGiorgio
Everytime I call they know who I am by my address always pleasant on the phone would highly recommend been going there since they were Tony’s and same great service
… more
Anthony Reese
Stopped in When i saw $1 slices(cant beat that DEAL), slices were DELICIOUS, HOT and original size. These guys do not joke around with their pizza, Crust was Crunchy and slices were sizzling. The guys in the shop were Super Nice as well. Will definitely be a Return Customer. GREAT FOOD AND BUSINESS!
… more
ken reich
Tried many in Lacey Twp. Mama’s is the best pizza and hot sandwiches around – Hands-down! If you like thin crust Brooklyn style you have to try mama’s.
… more
Christina Petrocelli
Love the California chicken cheesesteak wrap!!!! Customer service is always on point!
… more
L E
Our delivery driver disappeared into thin air. Waited an hour then called restaurant, was told the driver had left 15 minutes or so ago he will call him to see where he is. Nothing still. Not even a call back to let us know SOMETHING. Now its been almost 2 hours and decided to just go to restaurant for our food. Get there and the 2 behind the counter are just standing around one on the phone just chitchatting. I bothered him I guess. I explained my situation he knew exactly who I was and i explained im there, that I wanted fresh food. I paid for fresh food, not 2 hour old food. I was as nice as can be for being hangry. I mean kind of my right to have FRESH food that I already paid for, right? The young man behind counter straight up lied. Said the driver don’t have a phone. After he said on the phone when I called earlier that he was calling the driver. Then quickly said he is trying to get ahold of him. Then backtracked again and said he is on the phone with someone who knows how to get ahold of him. I mean which is it? All we wanted was our food. We didn’t want the old food. We were there to have our food made fresh AGAIN. He then says we are to wait for the driver to get back so he can reimburse us. He then said he will credit us. We were hungry. We just wanted the food remade. This wasn’t hard. FINALLY something clicked in his head and said “you want me to just remake it?” Umm yea that is what we originally wanted. We don’t want over 2 hour food we paid for FRESH HOT FOOD. Waited another 15 or 20 minutes as we are waiting still no driver comes back. Nothing. Apparently he is the owners son?! Not good. I enjoy coming to Mamas/Tony’s. Been coming for quite a while and never had an issue but after tonight I think I may take my business elsewhere. Although they FINALLY came through and made good with it and remade our food, it was an absolute ridiculous hustle just to get it.This is not good for business. At all. I am highly disappointed. Come to find out after all of that, 2 1/2 hours later our original food ended up at our apartment just before we got back home. I am not sure I’ll be ordering from there again. The fresh food was ehhh too.
… more
… View more