Named one of the best in the U.S., Mamacita’s Pizzeria is an award winning restaurant serving hand tossed New York style pizzas, huge Angus burgers, fresh salads, hot subs, and other goodies. We have vegetarian and vegan friendly offerings. We pride ourselves in providing you with fresh food, cooked to order, and friendly service. We are a carry-out restaurant, offering covered outdoor seating. We do not serve alcohol, but you are welcome to eat your food at the cantina next door. We look forward to seeing you!
Based on 211 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
20814 US-84, Abiquiu, NM 87510
Phone: (505) 685-4111
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 12–8 PM |
| Friday | 12–8 PM |
| Saturday | 12–8 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Joe Trujillo
I have been getting pizza here for the last 9 years and there is still no better pizza around. Fresh dough made daily! Every bite is full of flavor. The toppings are always fresh and tasty! She also does subs here I have yet to try them. I have had a burger years ago which I remember it being huge. You can call in ahead to order which times quoted are always accurate! Sure the outside area is posted in a way that keeps loiterers out. Sure the customer service could be a tad better. But this Northern New Mexico, I’ve ordered here enough that I can tell you the customer service is amazing. When I was a wild land firefighter she would give me free drinks. Wear a mask it’s courteous, and you might get a little extra love. Every time I’m in El Rito I order from here. Easily I’ve ordered over 20 times maybe up to 50. Cash or “plastic” credit card is accepted.
… more
AOP
The pizza – ESPECIALLY the crust – is delicious! It’s not inexpensive, expect $26+. Uncertain if the worker (possibly owner) is super good at making pizza but pretty darn off-putting with people or, doesn’t understand that tone of voice matters. Highly recommend ordering and picking up your pizza, because it’s SUPER good, especially for the area, just don’t ask for parmesan cheese
… more
Charles Canada
Excellent pizza. Always. After over a decade of getting take out here, I have never been disappointed.
… more
Christina Goebel
Fabulous New York/New Jersey-style crust where there are few restaurants and many of those are pricey. You can sit outside at a few tables or take to to go. The vegetarian pizza was surprisingly more tasty than the supreme! I love this place and it is one of the top user-rated pizzerias in New Mexico. Enjoy the views and wait for a worthy pizza. Their largest pizza supreme/vegetarian with bread sticks and two Pepsis cost around $40. But that is cheaper than most of the very few restaurants in the area.
… more
jhwygirl
Pizza was delicious. Service was actually very fast. The owner took my order, said it would be 12 minutes & she delivered.
… more
Julie Garcia
OMG best ever up north after Espanola and before ChamaNM…everything on point Abiquiu, New Mexico
… more
Dawn Curtis
Best pizza…Ever! And we’ve sampled our fair share. The crust is perfect and crisp on the bottom. The sauce is definitely home-made, the ingredients are fresh…and it was well worth the road trip. We even ordered a second pizza to take home. Highly recommended
… more
Harry Gantz
The Pizza was OK, but the woman running the place was extremely rude to us. Literally yelled at us for having a bottled water while waiting for our to go pizza. While the other party waiting at the tables both had drinks they brought from outside! Then she yelled at us about our dog, who was only in the parking lot, never came in the seated area. There are plenty of places to get good Pizza, it is not worth the abuse.
… more
Pearl Lucero
We’ve been there 6 times and it’s delicious everytime. The owner (Marta) is a fun, considerate and nice person to talk to. It’s a 45 minute drive for us and worth every minute of it. We always order 2 jumbo pizzas because it’s one of our favorite pizza places, actually our favorite and we have tried lots of different pizza joints. It’s definitely worth the drive!
… more
Taylor Kress
By far the best pizza in Northern New Mexico! The only NY style pizza we have found in the state. If you’re in the Abiquiu area you’d better stop by!
… more
… View more