Mama T’s Italian Eatery is a family run Italian restaurant that serves the best in fresh made pizza, pasta, sandwiches, appetizers, and salads. We also serve beer, wine, and sangria. Our style is very old school with big portions and that classic Italian immigrant taste that is so hard to find. Buon Appetito!
Based on 330 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
781 E Geneva St, Elkhorn, WI 53121
Phone: (262) 379-1148
Website: http://mamatsitalian.com/?utm_source=gmb&utm_medium=referral
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | Closed |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Maggie Howarth
It was our first time dropping in for dinner. It is a quaint little place. Everyone was super nice and attentive. The cannoli was quite literally the best I’ve ever had. And I’ve had A LOT of them. Lol.
… more
Génesis Laboy
SERVICE- the staff is very sweet, welcoming, and well-knowledged. My food came out in 20 minutes.
… more
Matt Oravec
We were in town for a race and needed pasta. Random search led us here and it did not disappoint. Very friendly staff and the food was phenomenal! Next time we are in town we will be coming back!
… more
Brian & Jenny Perket
We had their meat pizza and a pepperoni pizza, We also got their cheesy garlic bread and Sangria sampler. Food was very cheesy with great flavor. Sangria’s were just fruity drinks, not true Sangria. Seating was limited and booth seating was not comfortable but later found out our seat was pushed several inches to close to table. When busy there is no good place to wait. Recommend calling ahead.
… more
Keqi Gan
Came in on a Wednesday evening around 7 pm and it was packed. We all got pastas(seafood, chicken, and spicy sausage). All of them came with garlic bread and all of them very tasty. As far as pasta goes, it is as good as it can be except some dishes I had in Milan and Germany. Services was very friendly but a bit longer wait due to the crowd. Highly recommended and worth the wait.
… more
Rajesh Mehta
I generally don’t write reviews if food is good, but I would say this is just perfect and awesome not just food but the service, price and wait time. Jennifer was my server, was nice, very polite and helped me choose my food. I had chicken cacciatore with arbitrator sauce and a cheesy garlic bread. Being an Indian, no language or accent issues, that’s additional plus point!
… more
Lanigan Elvin
Fantastic food and service was awesome. Had two or three ladies checking on us, chatted with us and gave reccomendations. Got themeat Lasagna and meat tortellini, both came with fantastic garlic bread, and both were amazing but lasagna was hands down the favorite. Will be coming here again and can’t wait to try more off the menu!
… more
Fran Werfelmann
Today we went for lunch. It was wonderful!
… more
Bethany Elvin
Great waitresses & great food. Lots to choose from and fair prices. I’ve heard friends rave about the tiramisu, but sadly we were too full to try it. Definitely next time!
… more
Rosa Vasquez (iamamiwhoami)
I came across this spot while on our way back home, and I had to give them a try! We were greeted and sat down right away when we walked in. Our server was very knowledgeable and attentive, and she was very friendly! We ordered wings and white peach sangria per their recommendation. Also an Italian Beef and Mostoccoli. Everything came to our table in a timely manner, and we dug right in! She was not kidding when she said the wings were great! We loved them so much! They were larger, crispy on the outside and sauced just right! It was amazing! The white peach sangria was spot on! The Italian beef was very delicious, it was less salty then others I’ve had, which is a plus for me personally, because I am sodium sensitive! My partners Mostoccoli was super delicious, and yes, I tried some of that too, haha! Overall the atmosphere was very wonderful, the decor inside made me feel welcomed like home, and the server was wonderful at taking care of us and the food was superb. Thank you to the chefs who made our food, we were truly satisfied and amazed by what we ordered. We will be back soon. I would highly recommend this place!
… more
… View more