Based on 31 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
31 Water St, Eufaula, OK 74432
Phone: (918) 314-8011
Hours
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Reviews
Brandon Huxford
The pizza was great! My family, including in-laws, visited Carlton Landing and enjoyed an evening of pizza and conversation with an outdoor dining experience. Staff were genuinely friendly and cared. Definitely recommend.
… more
Shane & Hannah
It was good pizza, lots of toppings, but there’s no AC in the building and when we went it was very hot. Wasn’t a terrible wait about 25 minutes, but would go back!
… more
Andrew Brown
Mama Tig’s is great. Possibly some of THE best pizza in the state. My wife and I are biracial, and I’ll say the atmosphere while seemingly friendly in the Carlton Landing location, really didn’t vibe all that much with us. There is a heavy predominantly Caucasian population living in town. Nothing against Mama Tig’s, but something to keep in mind, as we experienced one person stating they were a local and attempting to cut us in line in order to get sauce, when we hadn’t even been served. This town needs to expand its cultural diversity as it just isn’t realistic otherwise, in my opinion. Food 5/5, service 5/5, atmosphere 4/5 due to the reasons mentioned above.
… more
Tonia Brannan
The food was delicious! I didn’t know before I went that there was no inside seating but they had plenty of fans and shade so in spite of the oppressive heat it wasn’t too bad.
… more
Phil D.
Incredible pizza and great atmosphere. Ignore the goofy people giving low reviews that just complain about misrepresented hours…the operators were unaware, acknowledged immediately, and worked to get everything updated. You won’t be disappointed with this place!
… more
Kent Hathaway
Good grief this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. The cauliflower pizza crust was incredible. It was so good that I ordered another one.
… more
Gerry Sifuentes
I wasn’t expecting this quality of pizza in Oklahoma. I really enjoyed the sauce to cheese ratio. The crust was excellent. Good sounding crunch without being totally dry. I’m glad I tried this place and I’ll be sure to stop by when I’m around.
… more
Thaddeus Yeargain
Great pizza spot! Dough was perfect, service was extremely fast and friendly. Wood fire flavor was excellent. The dough was crispy outside but chewy and soft. Will definitely be back when we are in the area.
… more
Ben Laurie
A surprising gem in a sleepy lakeside town. This is the kind of place you always hope to happen upon when exploring the quiet corners of rural America.
… more
Michael Fesler
Awesome pizza. We love it when visiting. Many weekends it is wise to place your order early in the day for evening pickup since it is so popular.
… more
… View more