Based on 509 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
113 3rd St, Baraboo, WI 53913
Phone: (608) 355-0373
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Robert Martin
We were camping at Devil’s Lake and wanted a pizza on a Friday eve. A quick google search and we picked out Mama Mia’s basically out of ‘thin air’. When I walked in the door, I saw Ben behind the counter and went up and asked him “Are your pizza’s any good?”, to which he responded very confidently “They are the best in town Man!”. And, I have to say my wife and I as well as my brother and his wife would agree with that statement! Now we’ve not had any other pizza in town, but, I’ve had a lot of pizza in my 63 years and I can tell you with no hesitation their pizza was one of the best I’ve ever had, hands down! If you are looking for a great pizza you will NOT be disappointed! Enjoy!
… more
Robert Brock
The food here is fantastic and the service is great. The portion sizes are big and prices are very reasonable. If you’re looking for Italian food in the area, this place won’t disappoint. We will be back every time we find ourselves in Baraboo!
… more
Therese Weiss
We were very excited to try this pizza because of the great reviews. We ordered a 16” takeout pizza. I took a nibble of the crust at first in the car and thought it was excellent. Once I got home and took a bite I asked my daughter what she thought of it and she said exactly what I was thinking – our pizza tasted like someone had poured an entire can of salt on it. So disappointing to pay $25 for a pizza and have it taste so salty, maybe this was a one off, but I’m not willing to give it another try.
… more
Ned Donaldson
Found this gem of a place last year and couldn’t wait to get back this year! Food is amazing and the owner and her daughter are absolutely great. They run a great place, fabulous food and very friendly and great service. Will be back the next time we are here for sure, highly recommend if you like great Italian!
… more
Sarah Felix
We ordered stromboli for takeout due to having a newborn at home. The stromboli was huge for the price and delicious! I don’t know why we haven’t gone there sooner but we’ll be going back for sure! ☺️
… more
Elizabeth Muller
We were greeted by the owner/chef immediately. She was friendly and set the tone for the whole meal. Throughout the meal she greeted every customer that came in, some by name. I chose the Italian sausage and peppers sandwich and my husband got the manicotti. We also ordered cheesy bread. His came with a salad. The salad and two round, warm hunks of bread with garlic and cheese came out. I assumed this was the cheese bread and took my roll. When I opened it, the smell took me right back to my Grandma’s kitchen on bread baking day. I would have been satisfied with that, but that was “just” the garlic knots they make with their leftover homemade pizza dough! I don’t My know how, but it only got better. My sandwich was so delicious and plenty of food! The real cheese bread served with their marina was an ooey gooey mess of delicious! We will be back in the fall and cannot wait to try their pizza.
… more
Kyle L
We came here while we visited Devils lake. The staff were super friendly. Love the awesome Italian food here. Local customers came in and knew the family that owned the place. Love that they supported this family and their business. Will be coming here in the future.
… more
I Hall
Had a BFF girls weekend away from our families in Baraboo and stopped in for dinner at Mama Mia on Saturday afternoon. WOW! We had THE BEST breaded mushrooms & pizza there that we have had in a LONG time! The breaded mushrooms were perfect-breading was not greasy, it was crunchy, seasoned just right and the mushrooms were large, succulent and delicious! The pizza was excellent-crust thin and crispy, NOT greasy or soggy and not too thin either, just right. The toppings were fresh and plentiful: sausage, mushrooms and onions. The cheese, oh the mozzarella cheese, there was plenty of it and it was to die for! The entire meal was to die for! Our eyes bigger than our stomachs we had to take half the pizza back to the hotel fridge, but it was just as delicious later as a late night feast while watching movies-SO GOOD! We will definitely be back for more next time we are in town!!!
… more
Ron Berg
Mama Mia is an outstanding restaurant serving Italian cooked by a genuine Italian family. I have had Italian in New York, and this is the best I have ever had in Wisconsin. Small restaurant but amazing dishes rival of Sinatra’s in New York. Enjoy this .
… more
Capri Danzeisen
Not sure what all the good reviews were. We got there 5 of us. Sat at a shotty small booth with a chair at the end. I plan my vacations around 4.5star or better for restaurant reviews. A couple I’m guessing we’re regulars there sat about 4mns after us. They got their drink order taken and food taken before we even got our drink order. Cheese bread was good. Mozzarella sticks were ok. The rest of the food was not good. I didn’t even finish my meal. Highly disappointed. Meatball sandwich was dry. My chicken was like a frozen chicken breast. Food was not seasoned well. During dinner the guy behind us kept pushing on the booth, we were already irritated with the food being super mediocre. We were ready to GO!! While waiting on the son to retrieve our bill, he sat at a back table we couldn’t figure out what was taking so long, mind you there were only 4 tables in there at the time. So when the bill finally came, it was hand-written with each item, yet only a total!! Didn’t get a receipt they didn’t have any!! I would never recommend this restaurant.
… more
… View more