Based on 119 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.5 stars. Price
Address:
1764 US-231, Crawfordsville, IN 47933
Phone: (765) 362-3676
Social Profile: 
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Teresa Duke
Had Mama Fazios a few times but not in a long while. Have to say I’m a bit disappointed this time. Ordered extra cheese. If this is extra cheese I’d hate to see what regular cheese is. And I will always give a poor review when the cheese doesn’t even go to the edges much less the toppings – especially when those toppings are only veggies – no meat. The crust is not as crispy as I remember – almost like it needed a few more minutes in the oven.
… more
scott dalton
Ordered delivery. Most of the order was prepared incorrectly. The selected chips were delivered wrong. They agreed to correct the order. Only one of the errors was corrected. The cheese pizza with light cheese wasn’t delivered. Bread sticks and Sun Chips was ordered and cheese bread and Doritos were delivered. When the delivery person was asked about this they said they were out and substituted. No warning or notice was received about substitution. The taste was bland and the sauce was thick and overpowering. I am so disappointed we gave this place a chance. Will not order again, buyer beware.
… more
Stewart Cronquist
Horrible pizza. Sausage was ground sausage spread all over it like it was sauce … never seen that before and I’ve been coast to coast eating pizza from almost every state.. this was awful! All I could eat was cheese and mushrooms.
… more
Ronnie Hornsby
Called and ordered a two topping medium pizza. She said it would be done in 30 min. I waited 40 min to make sure it was done. I walked in and she asked me what toppings I wanted and still haven’t even started the pizza. So I waited another 30 min for a pizza that was supposed to be done 30 min ago. And then when i finally get the pizza there was hardly no cheese on the pizza. U would think if u had someone wait a whole hour for a two topping medium pizza on a Wednesday u would make a better quality pizza. Our breadsticks wasn’t even warm they was in a door dash bag. So probably someone els cold bread sticks they gave us. And for the love of God please put some cheese on the pizza stop being stingy.
… more
Elizabeth Ferguson
I don’t know what all the 1 star reviews are about, but I had a great experience here!! Friendly staff and DELICIOUS pizza
… more
Marcie Sands
We have always loved this pizza! However, tonight they messed up our order. When I called to get it replaced, they said they could not replace the pizza unless we returned the original. I asked “you want a pizza back that we have touched during COVID?” We had already taken several slices out of the box and taken bites when we noticed it was made wrong.That is a ridiculous policy. The manager said that she knew she made it wrong. So why didn’t she call us and tell us that? Why didn’t she say it when
… more
Harold Lindsay
Forgot to send 2 weeks ago .we had a big dirtbike race to attend near this town .making sure we tried mom and pop every chance we can .orderd up from here .the family atmosphere was awesome. Prices were rt pizza was very good more .nit wits in this area should consider this place over the look at me .I’m in the drive threw over here plus this place was started in the 40s I believe
… more
Lili 9478
My husband and I ate pizza from here for the first time tonight. All I can say is YUMMY! It was the best pizza we have had in forever! It had so many toppings, the perfect amount of sauce and so much cheese. We will DEFINITELY be return customers. Thank you Mama Fazio’s for a GREAT dinner!!!!!
… more
Makayla and lucas Keller
Clean!! Made fresh in front of us chicken bacon ranch sandwich is fire! Staff is awesome and the sauce on pizza is great. Reminds me of real pizza places in chicago
… more
Kyle Campbell
Customer service? Lmfao I had better treatment at the bmv! Ordered a pizza over an hour ago and still have nothing! Called to get a discount or my money back and they said they will handle it later that they have other people waiting and hung up the phone! Welp you lost yet another customer in this area!! Garbage garbage garbage
… more
… View more