Counter-serve chain for brick-oven pizzas, plus salads, jumbo sandwiches & sides. Based on 242 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
159 E Center St, Ithaca, MI 48847
Phone: (989) 875-5061
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
stephen goodman
Done with main street pizza. Every single time I order one it is burnt. Tried St. Louis and tried Ithaca. Just done. Just not worth getting in the car and driving over. There are a dozen pizza places I can get pizza. I shouldn’t have to check my pizza everytime to see if it is burnt. Just done.
… more
Travis Strasel
They do not accept credit cards. Been years since I’ve been to a legitimate business that doesn’t accept cards. Go find an ATM and pay a $3 fee cause this business doesn’t accept them. No apology or warning before hand. Get home, pizza was tough, overdone, and had extreme grease seepage from the pizza. Save your money, save your wasted time, don’t bother ordering this pizza.
… more
Nick Massey
The pizza has always been awesome, but the last pizza we got was flat and didn’t look very inviting. And I’m pretty disappointed about it, because in Ithaca we don’t have many food choices, and don’t get any deliveries here either, so make us a yum yum pizza like you usually do. God Bless
… more
Regina Andersen
If a little cheese was put on the top to help hold toppings that would help. Pizza tasted fine, bread sticks were good, salad was delicious. Remember cash or local checks only. The actual store could use updates & repairs. I don’t know if it’s ever had a facelift.
… more
Ryan Craig
Food was not very good. Waited 30 mins for a 10in pizza sub and when i got it was still ice cold in middle. Just seems like the people working there coukd care less bout the quality n service they give.
… more
Craig Russell
The guy there just seems rude and hates his job. Maybe he was just having an off day though. The biggest thing is not taking cards. I mean c’mon the number one way to pay now and you don’t take cards. Huge bummer especially on large orders.
… more
Steven Clements
3 times in a row now pizza not done very little toppings and couldn’t even take the time to cut pizza properly.
… more
john “thunder frogs” mitchell
i walked in and whent to pay and he said sorry cash of checks only like really you could have said something when I ordered on the phone very inconvenient!! And the place is a mess looks like they never clean!!!!
… more
Eva Howell
Great pizza!!!! First time visiting Main Street in Ithaca. Good selection on their menu. Different choices than Carson City. Will definitely try them again. Tried calling Carson City to order and nobody would answer the phone. So it was Ithaca’s lucky day. Will definitely return to this location!
… more
Scott Jacob
I called to get a time for pickup, they said it would be about 20 minutes. I ordered 2 subs and a cheese bread. After I arrived to the restaurant the counter guy said they hadn’t even started my order and it would be another…he didn’t know! Anyhow, it took over 15 more minutes. That normally wouldn’t be an issue but I stopped here on my way back to the Detroit area, I could have hit a fast food restaurant instead. The subs were mediocre and the cheese bread was bread sticks with mozzarella heated over the top. It wasn’t horrible but nothing I would go out of my way for again.
… more
… View more