Maggie’s eatery Menu – Miller Place, NY

Type : American restaurant

Location : Miller Place, NY

Based on 33 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Maggie's eatery 11764

Address:
465 NY-25A, Miller Place, NY 11764

Phone: (631) 828-5554

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 11:30 AM–8 PM
Thursday 11:30 AM–8 PM
Friday 11:30 AM–9 PM
Saturday 11:30 AM–9 PM
Sunday 11:30 AM–7 PM
Monday 11:30 AM–8 PM

Menu

Appetizers
Ahi Tuna Toast
Ahi Tuna tossed with Meyer lemon, minced peppers, chive & radish. Served on grilled sourdough toast with avocado and fresh herbs.		 $19.49
Burrata
Sweet corn, grape tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, sea salt.		 $17.19
Sweet Corn Hush Puppies
Sweet corn fritter, served with chipotle mayo and sea salt. 		$14.89
Nachos
Three cheese blend, jalapenos and black beans. Topped with Pico de Gallo, sour cream and guacamole.		 $17.19
Wings
Your choice of Buffalo, BBQ, Sweet Thai Chili or “Smack Ya Mama” dry rub. Served with bleu cheese dressing and celery sticks. (8 per order).		 $17.19
Salads
Avocado Toast
Sliced avocado on toasted ciabatta topped with arugula, radish and everything bagel seasoning. (add queso fresco +1, add a fried egg +2)		 $14.89
Greek Salad
Chopped iceberg lettuce, mixed Mediterranean olives, cucumbers, grape tomatoes, red onion and feta cheese served with Greek dressing and toasted pita bread.		 $14.89
Chopped Sesame Salad
Chopped romaine, butterleaf lettuce, fried wontons,
cucumbers and bean sprouts, dressed in a sesame soy dressing. 		$14.89
Wedge
Crisp iceberg lettuce, grape tomatoes, pickled red onion, crispy bacon, bleu cheese dressing.		 $14.89
Bowls
Korean Chicken Bowl
Pan fried chicken simmered in a Korean BBQ sauce with minced scallions, pickled vegetables, and avocado. 		$24.09
Salmon Bowl
Pan seared salmon cooked to your liking over sushi rice and seaweed salad with cucumbers, radishes, scallions, nori flakes and sliced jalapenos topped with a hoisin aioli.		 $26.39
Steak Bowl
Grilled skirt steak, sweet corn, cucumbers, roasted jalapeño salsa Verde, French fries and queso fresco.		 $24.09
Tuna Poke Bowl
Sesame soy marinated Ahi Tuna served over sushi rice and seaweed salad with edamame, cucumbers, radishes and guacamole topped with toasted sesame seeds.		 $26.39
Tacos
Fried Cod Tacos
Fried local Cod with a cucumber lime slaw, chipotle aioli, radishes, guacamole and Napa cabbage. 		$25.24
Shrimp Tacos
Spicy shrimp, avocado crema, corn salsa, queso fresco, guacamole, and Nappa cabbage.		 $22.94
Steak Tacos
Grilled steak, roasted jalapeño salsa verde, guacamole, Napa cabbage, fried onion strips and queso fresco.		 $22.94
Vegetable Taco
Baby bok choy, sweet corn, edamame, ponzu guacamole, Napa
cabbage and pico de gallo with a chipotle mayo.		 $20.64
Maggie’s Favorites
Fish N Chips
Long Ireland Brewery beer battered Flounder, served with Maggie’s tartar sauce and French fries.		 $25.24
Fried Shrimp Platter
Beer battered shrimp, served with Maggie’s Tartar sauce and French fries.		 $25.24
Handhelds
Burger
6-ounce patty cooked to your liking on a toasted brioche bun with lettuce, tomato and onion.

Add:
American, Cheddar, Swiss, or Mozzarella +1.5
Bacon +2
Egg* +2
Guacamole +3
Make it a double +3

 $18.34
Burrata And Arugula Sandwich
Fresh burrata, arugula, red onion and prosciutto on toasted ciabatta with pesto. 		$21.79
Chicken Bahn Mi
Organic fried chicken, pickled vegetables, hoisin mayo on toasted ciabatta.		 $22.94
Lobster Salad Roll
Our homemade lobster salad on a toasted potato roll, served with French fries.		 $34.44
Steak Sandwich
Marinated skirt steak cooked to your liking on toasted garlic ciabatta bread, with mozzarella cheese, fried onions, and arugula.		 $22.94
Kids
Chicken Fingers
Three fried chicken fingers served with French fries.		 $11.44
Grilled Cheese
Inside out burger bun with American cheese served with French fries.		 $11.44
Kids Fried Fluke
Served with tartar sauce and French fries.		 $13.74
Kids Fried Shrimp
Served with tartar sauce and French fries.		 $13.74
Sides
French Fries $7.99
Guacamole $6.84
Pico De Gallo $4.54
Dessert
Dessert Special
Call us to find out about our changing dessert specials.		 $7.99
Churros
Caramel Filled Churros		 $7.99
Drinks
Apple Juice $2.25
Blue Powerade $3.00
Choc Milk $2.25
Coca-Cola Move
16 oz		 $2.75
Coke
16 oz		 $2.75
Diet Coke
16 oz		 $2.75
Dr. Pepper
16 oz		 $2.75
Ginger Ale
16 oz		 $2.75
Gold Peak Green Tea $3.50
Lemon Gold Peak Iced Tea $3.50
Peach Gold Peak Iced Tea $3.50
Raspberry Gold Peak Iced Tea $3.50
Unsweetened Gold Peak Iced Tea $3.50
Orange Soda
16 oz		 $2.75
Orange Soda- No Sugar
16 oz		 $2.75
Pink Lemonade
16 oz		 $2.75
Red Powerade $3.00
Water Bottle $2.25
Sprite
16 oz		 $2.75
1.25 Liter Orange Soda $4.50
UNCATEGORIZED
Iced Tea $2.75
Coke $2.75
Portobello Sandwich
Marinated portobello, red peppers, whipped goat cheese, balsamic vinegar, on ciabatta bread.		 $17.19
Fried Chicken Po Boy
Fried chicken, mozzarella cheese, chipotle aioli, with lettuce, tomato and guacamole on a toasted roll.		 $19.45
Salmon Burger
Marinated salmon, fresh herbs with sesame seeds, served on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, and wasabi aioli.		 $23.09
Hot Lobster Roll
Butter poached lobster meat served in a hot dog bun served with French fries or a side salad.		 $31.44
Fried Cod Gyro
Served with cucumber, lettuce, tomato and onion with Maggie’s tartar sauce on toasted pita bread, with French fries or a side salad.		 $25.24
Chicken Milanese
Breaded fried chicken thighs served with an arugula salad with tomatoes, red onion, shaved parmesan Reggiano and lemon vinaigrette.		 $23.09
Lobster Tacos
Butter poached lobster, chipotle aioli, pico de gallo, crispy wontons, guacamole and Nappa cabbage.		 $31.44
Fried Fluke Tacos
Fried local Fluke with a cucumber lime slaw, chipotle aioli, radishes, guacamole and Nappa Cabbage.		 $25.24
Vegetable Bowl
Grilled portobello and zucchini served over sushi rice with chickpeas, cucumbers, corn salsa, minced scallions and guacamole.		 $20.64
Fried Chicken Bowl
Honey glazed fried chicken, roasted corn, sliced jalapenos, queso fresco and guacamole, served over French fries with chipotle aioli.		 $24.09
Salmon Salad
Pan Seared salmon over chopped butterleaf and iceberg lettuce, cucumbers and bean sprouts with a sesame soy dressing topped with crispy wontons.		 $22.94
Steak Salad
Butterleaf lettuce, arugula, cucumbers and grape tomatoes served with balsamic vinaigrette and topped with fried onions and queso fresco.		 $24.09
Potstickers
Fried chicken dumplings served with refreshing ponzu and sweet Thai chili sauce (6 per order).		 $14.89
Pan Seared Edamame
Pan seared edamame with sesame seeds.		 $11.44
Hummus And Pita
Jalapeno lime hummus topped with olive oil. Served with olive tapenade and toasted pita bread.		 $12.59
Chips And Guac
Guacamole and Pico de Gallo served with homemade corn tortilla chips.		 $11.44

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Emilia McGinniss
Absolutely fantastic food. We got a guac and chips, with what had to be the best pico I have ever had. It was SO fresh and crisp.

… more

Mary Cate
The food is fantastic here! An order of Shrimp Tacos brings you perfectly cooked shrimp surrounded by corn salsa, cabbage, and guacamole and topped with amazing flavors. Avocado toast is a wonderful starter. The Fish n Chips beats anything I’ve had in London!

… more

colleen klopfer
Delicious!!

… more

Peter L.
I’m at a loss for words, what can I say.. The food here is amazing. Just stumbled upon this unassuming place in a strip mall only to discover a farm fresh, colorful, flavorful, creatively presented, perfectly satisfying meal. I can’t recommend highly enough & can’t wait to come back with friends and family!

… more

Elisa Hendrey
Excellent food plated very attractively. Quite a bit of variety on the menu, including some dishes not so often seen such as salmon sushi rice bowl. The atmosphere is very casual. Bright and cheerful decor. Do not expect linen, etc., just really well-prepared dishes in a cafe style setting. The owner has experience as a chef in the Hamptons and it shows.

… more

Theresa Maritato
I absolutely love this place. We’ve been here about four or five times. The nachos are one of the best things I’ve ever had. So far I have tried the salmon bowl, the Portabella sandwich and a salad, and my husband has tried the steak sandwich, fish tacos, and more. It’s one of the best places in the area. The chef is amazing.

… more

Rose Scotto
What a great little place! Great atmosphere. My son and I had the steak sandwich. It came with fries. I’m not a fan normally but these were crisp and delicious. The steak was perfectly seasoned and cooked as ordered, on a toasted roll with lots of delicious melted mozzarella. We’re definitely going to be regulars

… more

Lindsay Cucchiaro
Absolutely delicious food! We have had several meals here and cant say enough. The food is excellent quality deliciously prepared! The flavors explode in your mouth and you will want to come back every night!!

… more

Andrew Swike
Extremely good food! And very fast, not even 15 minutes after I called it was ready.

… more

Bella Heather
Just picked up dinner from Maggie’s Eatery and OMG absolutely delicious! We ordered the Shrimp Tacos, Lobster Tacos and a Lobster Roll. Highly recommend and will definitely be going back for more!

… more

… View more

Related:

  1. Starbucks Menu – Miller Place, NY
  2. Needles Lodge Menu – Huntsville, UT
  3. Himm’s Grocery Menu – Byromville, GA
  4. Huddle House Menu – Harlan, KY

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch