Opening in September 2022, Made in New York Pizza’s new Upper West Side location is just a few blocks south from our first location. Our NYC pizzeria serves slices and pies that open up a new world of flavor from the pizza you’ve come to know. With a range of classic toppings and unique combinations, we provide a good variety that New Yorkers will enjoy. We’re located between 72nd and 73rd Streets, just a short walk from the 72nd St subway stop.
Based on 87 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
271 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023
Phone: (646) 449-8556
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sawako Y
4.5 / 5.0 – If you’re looking for a solid NY pizza, look no further! Made In New York Pizza has another location in UWS, but this newer location is more accessible, right by the 72 St Station.
… more
Tina Nguyen
The square pizzas are sooooo good and crispy. The margarita pizza was ok. I wished I had tried the original slice and the mushroom. It looked really good. There was two other customers that were eating and went to order more. The a/c w felt really good. The place was really clean and felt good to eat in. I will definitely come back to eat more!
… more
Bella Fenn
Super tasty NY style pizza! We tried the vodka slice and the regular and both were good but the vodka was incredibly good and we’d definitely recommend. The regular slice is good but slightly acidic. The only reason I can’t give full stars is the pricing is a little bit higher than comparable pizza places in the city. But if you’re in the area, definitely swing by!
… more
Daniel Pincus
Report: they fixed the problem reported below and in an email. Pictured is a mushroom slice with pre-cooked shrooms, that’s crispy on the bottom. Thanks, management.
… more
Bailey Carter
I paid 5.50 a slice for this. Buffalo chicken was a ton of crust and you can see what happened to the pepperoni and sausage slice. Neither were crispy
… more
Gary S
Pizza is pretty good in the overall but until they do something about people and their dogs regularly coming in, I’m going to take a pause on visiting this location. NYC Health Code only allows service animals into food establishments but on this day (7/24/2023) literally there were 3 non-service dogs in the restaurant. Dogs are cool and all but besides the health code, not everyone is cool with a stranger’s dog sniffing and scratching while they eat.
… more
Silver Light Fox
Stopped here during lunch time around 12 or so, small place with a few tables and some outdoor dining, it was raining so I grabbed it to go, I got a regular and Buffalo Chicken slice, the regular slice was crispy and enjoyable the buffalo chicken slice was disappointing to be honest, hence the 3 stars, it was kind of dry, and slightly soggy, ok place to grab a quick bite to eat if your nearby. It came out to around 13$ for the 2 slices And a sprite bottle.
… more
Me Here
The food quality is decent but it’s very much a cash grab. Not only their prices are about 30 to 40% higher than most places in New York for a slice they charge a SERVICE FEE for using credit cards. Most merchants and companies eat the 3% processing fee as the cost of doing business. Merchants don’t have to manually sort and deal with cash. These greedy people in my opinion charge the customer that fee. Classless. If you’re going to engage in such a cash grabbing practice the least you should do is put signs all over the store saying watch out we are here for your money and we charge you the credit card processing fees on top of our high menu prices.
… more
Kevin Sorensen
Delicious by the slice pizza joint (can order full pies too). Second location on the UWS, 80th/Amsterdam location has been open for a long time and is many peoples favorite pizza on the UWS. Open till 11pm during the week at 1am on the weekend, a great spot for 4th meal.
… more
Abdullah Sarwari
Nice and crispy pizza by the slice. Tried several different counter serve pizza spots in the city and this was definitely one of the best. The service was good and the place was nice and clean. Would definitely recommend.
… more
… View more