Local fast-food chain turning out New York-style pies & slices plus other casual Italian eats. Based on 118 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2415 Sagamore Pkwy S, Lafayette, IN 47905
Phone: (765) 448-1254
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 12–5:30 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–6:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–6:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–6:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–6:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–7:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Andrew Quintero
I’ve been visiting this pizza place for close to 22 years now. It’s had its ups and downs over time as expected, but I always have forgiven the lapses in quality based on decent service. Tonight changed that sentiment. I ordered online through the official website. I ordered two pizzas: one large extra cheese and one stuffed meat pizza with extra toppings. The price was a bit higher than I wanted but that was okay since we were going to get a stuffed pizza. I even added in a $10 tip for a carry out order. My wife picked them up and drove them home. We were all set for dinner and opened the boxes to find a non-stuffed pizza with the toppings we had requested. I called and asked if they knew that this had happened. They said they don’t make stuffed pizzas there and didn’t seem to care. Okay. Call me a liar after my kindness after 22 years of pizza purchases and we are done. If I could upload a screenshot of the order that proves this order was real, I would do so. The employee was wrong and out of place.
… more
John Ruiz
Great pizza and pepperoni breadsticks. Kinda getting pricey. $24 for 2 adults and a toddler. That’s 3 slices of pizza, 4 breadsticks, and 2 drinks…
… more
Louis Maiden
The food is ok but they go way overboard with the amount of sausage relative to the other ingredients.
… more
A R
Food was good, has the be one of the worst placed menu items I’ve seen. I was pointed to 3 different menus on EACH wall. WHY HAVE employee special in the menu??? Why can’t you just tell the employees what the special is in person? Why a big sign?? Makes no sense. Who’s idea was it to put it there like it’s a option for regular customers?
… more
KC Hollingsworth
My mom and I were out on a Sunday and decided to give Luca’s at the mall a try. My first complaint is in regards to their deceptive pricing. The most obvious sign on their outdated pricing board (which was very hard to read) advertises a one-topping pizza for 7.99. We ordered said pizza and two soft drinks, for a total of over 22 dollars. We didn’t catch it until we had sat down; the huge ad for the 7.99 pizza is for mall employees only. The pizza we ordered was actually something like 15.99. We both enjoyed the pizza, although my mom thought it tasted doughy and under-cooked but the cheese was melted perfect. I agree the pizza was a bit doughy but that’s how I like my pizza. My second complaint is that they charge .54 cents for a refill of fountain soda! I’m sorry, but that is rediculous. We all know that a cup of fountain soda costs pennies, this is why most everywhere includes free refills. I nearly succumbed to an apoplectic fit when I tried unsuccessfully to refill my beverage at the pleasure of the establishment. Customer service was just fine, no complaint there. They brought the pizza out to our table, which was nice. I wondered (in my heart) whether or not they were going to charge for that too. We will go to Luca’s again, just with more money to spend. I would advise the owner to update the menu board, and for goodness sakes offer free refills and join us in the 21st century. Also, I’d like to point out that the atmosphere of the place was very nice.
… more
Tammy Payne
They usually have great pizza there. My pizza was soggy and doughy. Had to bake it more at home. Still wasnt.very good. Very disappointed.
… more
Lorraine
If you’re looking for a greasy piece of pizza with very crunch crust then they’re where to go. But the staff is rude and laughed at me for saying hi when I came in. Not the first bad experience I’ve had there. They also have a tip jar that’s always empty. I Wonder why.
… more
Eric Ruemler
A bit pricey but the slices are huge! The combo meal deals are the way to go. The majority of the food is already cooked, then reheated in the pizza ovens. Everything I’ve tried so far I give two thumbs up!
… more
Twitch Minor
Great pizza place and even better pricing . The worker was alittle rude and acted like she didn’t know what pizza was but all round good!!
… more
Holden McGroin
I used to enjoy it but when it went main stream and let cooperate influenza them it added something but took away the originality but they’re real original now ( or are they ) great staff though we’ll the kid out front obidiya or something like that was very polite but , ( what looked like his grandma ) worked fevershly almost the entire time until her husband or boyfriend ( who looked to be half her age) came in. She was very happy to see him and that’s the last we seen or her?
… more
… View more