Based on 95 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
202 Grand Ave, Paonia, CO 81428
Phone: (970) 527-3265
Website: http://paoniapizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 5–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 5–8 PM |
| Thursday | 5–8 PM |
| Friday | 5–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
mallory piekarski
I’m pretty sure I was served a 14″ even though I was charged for a 16″. Also, I asked when I ordered if I could split my one topping into half/half. I was told that I could and was anyway then charged for two toppings. This is clearly a scammy way to get more money. In total the pizza has only one topping on it. Why charge for two? Why not then double the amount of topping on each side to be fair? Rude service as well. Very disappointed.
… more
Henry Kloepper
Not a bad local pizza place. Food was OK, but not special. Good selection of toppings. Salad wasn’t inspired, but the ingredients were fresh enough that it was still enjoyable.
… more
Richard Whittaker
I never expected a pizza place to serve breakfast, but they opened right at 7 AM when I was trying to decide what to eat. I had a breakfast sandwich with waffles as the bread, and it was delicious. Good coffee and friendly service, too.
… more
Brian Hoyt
Pizza was good. Live music was incredible.
… more
Truth time With Tamzen
Fabulous tasty pizza. Unique.
… more
Travis Miller
Great service, friendly atmosphere, and tasty pizza… Plus, great beer. Hoped they were open at 8pm on a Tuesday and they welcomed us in! We’re glad we decided to swing by Louie’s and will definitely stop by next time we’re in town.
… more
Samuel Norris
Fantastic pizza, people, and atmosphere — a perfect local restaurant that also sometimes hosts live music. The waffle people on the weekend mornings are great, too!
… more
DBarnes
Good pizza! Great sandwiches! Great music! What’s not to love?
… more
Brandon Kennedy
Pizza was good enough, though I will try a different pizza next time if I come back. The girl taking my order did a great job at writing it down, but that’s about it. She tried to short me $5 (I was supposed to get $15 back) and when I asked about it she said she “though it was a tip” and instead tried to give me $25 back, so I had to give her the $10 back. And yes, she was using a calculator. Also, she tried to pour a beer from the tap but tried giving me a cup of foam. Hopefully they go through some proper training with some staff. This girl is lucky there were more competent people there to help her out.
… more
Joshua Matthew
Standard good tasting pizza The biggest flaw in the Pizza at this place is the crust . If you don’t order it well done it will be undercooked.
… more
… View more