Long John Silver’s Menu – New Castle, IN

Type : Fast food restaurant

Location : New Castle, IN

Real seafood should be sourced from real sea-places, like, you know, oceans. So that’s exactly where we source ours from. We’re no one trick sea pony. Sure, we’ve got the classic fried fish and chips you love, but now we’ve got delicious new grilled seafood options to add to our menu of delica-seas.

Counter-serve chain offering fried fish & seafood combos, plus chicken & sides. Based on 371 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ Delivery

Long John Silver's 47362

Address:
520 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362

Phone: (765) 521-2684

Website:

Hours

Sunday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
10:30 AM–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Thursday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Friday 10:30 AM–10 PM
Saturday 10:30 AM–10 PM

Menu

Long John Silver’s – Shrimp Baskets
Popcorn Shrimp Basket
Popcorn Shrimp with one side and 2 hushpuppies
$7.19
6pc Grilled Shrimp Basket
6 grilled shrimp on savory rice with one side
$7.19
Battered Shrimp Basket
6 battered shrimp with one side and 2 hushpuppies
$7.19
Long John Silver’s – Family Meals
8 Piece Family Meal
8 pieces mix and match fish/chicken, two family size sides, and 8 hushpuppies. Feeds 3-4 adults.
$33.69
12 Piece Family Meal
12 pieces mix and match fish/chicken, three family size sides, and 12 hushpuppies. Feeds 5-6 adults.
$45.19
16 Piece Family Meal
16 pieces mix and match fish/chicken, four family size sides, and 16 hushpuppies. Feeds 7-8 adults.
$57.09
Long John Silver’s – Platters
Fish & Shrimp Platter
Two pieces classic battered Alaska pollock and six pieces classic battered shrimp, two sides, and two hushpuppies.
$14.39
Fish, Chicken & Shrimp Platter
Two pieces classic battered Alaska pollock, one piece classic battered all-white meat chicken, three pieces classic battered shrimp, two sides, and two hushpuppies.
$14.39
Fish & Chicken Platter
Two pieces classic battered Alaska pollock, three pieces classic battered all-white meat chicken, two sides, and two hushpuppies.
$14.39
Super Sampler Platter
One piece of classic battered Alaska pollock, one piece of classic battered all-white meat chicken, three pieces of classic battered shrimp, serving of popcorn shrimp, two sides, and two hushpuppies.
$14.89
Long John Silver’s – Meals
2 Fish Meal
Two pieces of classic battered Alaska pollock, two sides, and two hushpuppies.
$10.89
3 Chicken Meal
Three pieces classic battered all-white meat chicken, two sides and two hushpuppies.
$10.99
8 Shrimp Meal
Eight pieces classic battered shrimp, two sides, and two hushpuppies.
$11.99
Fish & Chicken Meal
One piece classic battered Alaska pollock and two pieces classic battered, all-white meat chicken, two sides, and two hushpuppies.
$11.49
Long John Silver’s – Combos
2 Fish Combo
Two pieces of classic battered Alaska pollock, one side, two hushpuppies, and a 20oz drink.
$10.89
2 Chicken Combo
Two pieces of classic battered all-white meat chicken, one side, two hushpuppies, and a 20oz drink.
$10.39
Fish Sandwich Combo
Classic battered Alaska pollock sandwich (includes pickles and tartar sauce), one side and a 20oz drink.
$8.89
2 Taco Combo
Classic Fish Tacos (2)
$11.09
Long John Silver’s – Grilled Choices
2 Tacos
Customize your tacos with your choice of grilled salmon or grilled shrimp and one of our signature toppings.
$8.59
Rice Bowls (Salmon Bowl)
Customize your rice bowl with your choice of grilled salmon or grilled shrimp and one of our signature toppings.
$9.19
Rice Bowls (Shrimp Bowl)
Customize your rice bowl with your choice of grilled salmon or grilled shrimp and one of our signature toppings.
$9.19
Grilled Salmon Meal
One piece grilled salmon served on a bed of rice with two sides.
$12.09
Grilled Shrimp Meal
Eight pieces grilled shrimp served on a bed of rice with two sides.
$12.09
Grilled Salmon & Shrimp Platter
One piece grilled salmon, four pieces of grilled shrimp served on a bed of rice with two sides.
$14.39
Long John Silver’s – Sea Shares
15pc Hand-Battered Shrimp Share $11.99
15pc Grilled Shrimp Sea Share $11.99
Popcorn Shrimp Sea Share $11.99
6pc Fish Sea Share $16.79
9pc Chicken Sea Share $16.79
Long John Silver’s – Add-A-Piece
1 Pc Fish
One piece classic battered Alaska pollock.
$2.89
1 Pc Chicken
One piece all-white meat chicken.
$2.69
3 Pc Shrimp
Three pieces classic battered shrimp.
$3.49
Popcorn Shrimp
Snack size crispy breaded popcorn shrimp.
$4.29
Clams
Snack size crispy breaded clams.
$3.49
3 Pc Grilled Shrimp
Three pieces grilled shrimp.
$3.49
1 Pc Grilled Salmon
One piece grilled Alaska salmon.
$5.99
Long John Silver’s – Sides
Fries (Individual)
A tresure chest of golden, crispy, potatoey perfection.
$2.89
Fries (Family)
A tresure chest of golden, crispy, potatoey perfection.
$5.79
Coleslaw (Individual)
Creamy slaw pairs well with FIsh… and Chicken… and Shrimp. Really just about anything!
$2.89
Coleslaw (Family)
Creamy slaw pairs well with FIsh… and Chicken… and Shrimp. Really just about anything!
$5.79
Green Beans (Individual)
What’s a pirate’s favorite bean? GREEN!
$2.89
Green Beans (Family)
What’s a pirate’s favorite bean? GREEN!
$7.09
Corn (Individual)
How much does a pirate pay for corn?? A buccaneer!
$2.89
Corn (Family)
How much does a pirate pay for corn?? A buccaneer!
$5.79
Hushpuppies (6 Hushpuppies)
Shhhhhhh… don’t wake the hushpuppies. They are having cornmeal battered, deep fried dreams.
$2.69
Hushpuppies (12 Hushpuppies)
Shhhhhhh… don’t wake the hushpuppies. They are having cornmeal battered, deep fried dreams.
$4.79
Rice (Individual)
Fluffy rice is the ideal compliment to that meal you’re having.
$2.89
Rice (Family)
Fluffy rice is the ideal compliment to that meal you’re having.
$7.09
Onion Rings
White onions breaded and fried to a crunchy golden-brown crisp.
$1.89
Onion Rings (Family)
White onions breaded and fried to a crunchy golden-brown crisp.
$3.99
Long John Silver’s – Desserts
Classic Cheesecake
Cheesecake Factory Bakery® classic cheesecake made with a creamy and smooth cheesecake filling on top of a graham cracker crust.
$4.79
Chocolate Cheesecake
Cheesecake Factory Bakery® Triple Chocolate Cheesecake
$4.79
Long John Silver’s – Drinks
Pepsi (Small) $2.89
Pepsi (Medium) $3.29
Pepsi (Large) $3.69
Dr. Pepper (Small) $2.89
Dr. Pepper (Medium) $3.29
Dr. Pepper (Large) $3.69
Diet Pepsi (Small) $2.89
Diet Pepsi (Medium) $3.29
Diet Pepsi (Large) $3.69
Mountain Dew (Small) $2.89
Mountain Dew (Medium) $3.29
Mountain Dew (Large) $3.69
Starry (Small)
Lemon Lime
$2.89
Starry (Medium)
Lemon Lime
$3.29
Starry (Large)
Lemon Lime
$3.69
Orange Soda (Small) $2.89
Orange Soda (Medium) $3.29
Orange Soda (Large) $3.69
Fruit Punch (Small) $2.89
Fruit Punch (Medium) $3.29
Fruit Punch (Large) $3.69
Lipton Unsweet Tea (Small) $2.89
Lipton Unsweet Tea (Medium) $3.29
Lipton Unsweet Tea (Large) $3.69
Lipton Sweet Tea (Small) $2.89
Lipton Sweet Tea (Medium) $3.29
Lipton Sweet Tea (Large) $3.69
Lemonade (Small) $2.89
Lemonade (Medium) $3.29
Lemonade (Large) $3.69
Cherry Pepsi (Small) $2.89
Cherry Pepsi (Medium) $3.29
Cherry Pepsi (Large) $3.69
Strawberry Lemonade (Small)
Dole strawberry lemonade
$2.89
Strawberry Lemonade (Medium)
Dole strawberry lemonade
$3.29
Strawberry Lemonade (Large)
Dole strawberry lemonade
$3.69

… View more

Reviews

Kenton Bubp
Yes mistyped the receipt so it said we had grilled shrimp basket instead of fried, so tried waiving and honking horn at window. Someone finally came to window and I asked if it was fried or not. Response was it’s fried, have a good day and she practically threw the bag into our vehicle. Only car in line and was trying to rush us off.

… more

Josh Thomas
Visited here today. Stated opening hours are 10:30 drive through and 11am inside seating. Doors still locked at 11:15 and drive through was unresponsive. Do not recommend.

… more

Rachel A
Got the family meal and added shrimp… Excellent choice left everyone satisfied and happy!!! Food was fresh and timely in the drive thru

… more

Ruth Williams
Don’t know what’s going on there one time you can only order inside the next time you cant go in. Crazy trying to figure out where to order

… more

Jamie Allred
Food was great. The young man at the window was super nice and was very professional!

… more

Dawn Evans
They could be better prepared and make sure they’re not out of food items that are on the menu

… more

Cathy Morgan
Went though drive young nan that took order and at window very polite great service

… more

Leslie Shaul
This was a bad day for them. We’d been many times. The doors were propped open and the place was very smokey. We arrived at 840 pm and she told us the dining room would close in 20 minutes. I told her she better cook quickly. 10 minutes later she put the closed sign across the open doors. I felt rushed and unwelcome. Sorry to have bothered you with my pesky business. I’ll eat next door next time. Chick must have had a big date planned.

… more

Linda Ballenger
The person taking the order at the drive-thru was nice , and helpful. She knew her products . At the window to pay, the lady was nice and helpful about sauces for the food . We left there and got home and they left out one whole piece of chicken. We probably should have checked the order before we left the window

… more

Diana Sullivan
Food was good not greasey. All 3 employees greated with a smile asked how our day was. Could use a good mop job floors are little slick under foot

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions