Based on 317 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
3311 N Green River Rd, Evansville, IN 47715
Phone: (812) 602-5255
Website: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Lombardis-New-York-Pizza/407569872695895
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Elizabeth Yoder
Perfect crust! So much better than the chains. Locally owned and operated. I get 2 every time I’m in town and reheat in the oven. Tell them Beth sent you and ask for the secret menu item pickle, ranch, and ricotta 🙂
… more
Jennilyn Brown
The service and atmosphere brings the 4 star food down to 3 stars. My daughter said the Nashville Hot was a good pizza after she picked all the pickles off. Sorry, no pic.
… more
Josh B
We just got back from a trip from New York, and I realized on that trip that New York style pizza was the best. I was very happy to find out that we had our own local New York style pizza here in town. My wife used to eat here when they were located in Henderson, and things have not change the pizza was amazing. The garlic knots were great, and who can be mad at cheesecake? We were able to get the pizza half baked so when we got home we could finish it off and add the ricotta to it which made a big difference given that we live 20 miles away. If you want a decent pizza in a style of New York, this is your place! We will definitely be going back again and again.
… more
Joseph Medicis
Got the Lewallen (pepperoni and Buffalo chicken) pizza today and it was amazing as it always is. Great food and great staff. Never disappoints and I highly recommend
… more
MA C
We ordered a Stromboli, Calzone, lg. pepperoni pizza, garlic knots all for $48. The food tasted good except for the knots which were dense & the pizza crust was soggy & the Stromboli was made more like a calzone. The calzone was good.
… more
Logan Boyd
This was by far one of my favorite dining experiences I have had in Evansville. The dine in area is a little small, but the food is absolutely amazing. Everything is made with fresh ingredients, hand rolled and made dough for all their products, and the Alfredo sauce might be some of the best Alfredo I have ever had. It has an extremely great flavor too it.
… more
Jonathan Lile
I don’t understand how this place has such a high rating! It was my first time getting a pizza here, the young gentleman who took my order seemed not interested in his job, nor did he give me my receipt. The pizza is more like a pizza from a truck stop, it’s terrible! It was burnt. It was burnt so bad the sauce was burnt from it taking all the flavor. I ate two pieces and threw the rest out. Wasted 33 bucks! Terrible. I don’t know how these guys are in business if they always sling burnt pizza. The young guys parents must own the place. Would recommend the pizza from the local quickie market that’s been sitting under the heat lamp for half a day before this place. Terrible.
… more
Laura Andrade
Excellent rice balls, Nashville hot chicken pizza as well as other speciality pizzas… This is our favorite Evansville pizza place. They have best New York style pizza in the tri state area.. Also, their strombolis are to die for!!! Yum yum yum!!!!!!!!!!!
… more
Several Acres
Great tasting pizza, but not quite NY.
… more
Kellyann Walker
Great pizza. Had slices ready to go like every great NY pizzeria should! Also tried the rice ball which was delish! Friendly staff. Oh and don’t miss out on the fresh canoli!
… more
… View more