Based on 90 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
Address:
169 Port Rd, Kennebunk, ME 04043
Phone: (207) 967-0033
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sharon Gadbois
Update: I went again, recently, because I was craving a good pizza and decided to go here. I just loved the pizza and the perfection of the gluten free crust, except when I got home with the pizza, it was luke warm and the crust was soggy. The service when I picked up the pizza wasn’t as friendly. Tried saying hello to the owner and was disregarded. Changing the review to 3*.
Harold Greer
This was a little surprise for me and the wife. It was rainy night in town and just trying to find anything or anywhere to park to get downtown. But we noticed this little pizza joint and decided it’s miserable out let’s just get some pizza. I got the 10” meat lovers and the wife got the plain cheese that was available by the slice. It was really really good. The sauce was spot on, not too spicy but had great taste. They were generous with the toppings on my pizza. Great staff, the actual restaurant inside is not much to look at, some interesting decor. The Mannequin stared too much at my wife……
Bailey Hanson
I new the owner since I was probably 7 years old, which is 11 years now! Time goes by fast. These guys never gave me a bad pizza, it was always really delicious. The people that work there are really kind and respectful, and gives your pizza at a reasonable time, even when busy. Good cheese, just enough pepperoni, and really good crust. I hope they reopen soon, because Atlantic at this point is dominating pizza Roma, even when not making pizza.
Joseph Sgammato
Terrible pizza. I submitted the order online to be ready at 5:30, but I got an email saying it was done at 5:11, so it sat around for 20 minutes waiting to be picked up. When I got it home, the cheese was black from cooking too long. The mozzarella sticks were inedible. My kids refused to eat them. I thought, “Come on. How bad could they be?” I took a bite and literally spit it out. Never again.
Maria Robb
Amazing pizza! So delicious, and perfectly seasoned. Kind staff, owner is often present. Delicious food, good prices, and a wonderful experience! Would highly recommend it, from ordering a full pizza to just buying a slice, it’s always fun.
susan oneil
A nice surprise for this resort town where dining out can be very expensive and not always great. I didn’t have a crowd to cook for tonight so decided I wanted to bring a simple sandwich to the beach for my quiet dinner alone. A very pleasant man waited on me at Atlantic Pizza about 5 pm. I ordered an Italian sub with few extras so he stuffed in the most delicious fresh thin tomato slices imaginable. It made my quiet and appreciated dinner at the beach just perfect. So nice to enjoy pleasant, friendly service during this busy season. Thanks.
Jennifer Shell
While visiting Kennebunkport with my boyfriend, we decided after a few days of seafood that we needed a break and some pizza would be perfect. After finding this place on google, we decided to give it a try and I’m glad we did! The pizza was AMAZING. We ordered a large pepperoni and onion pizza and an order of buffalo wings. We asked for the wings extra crispy and they ended up being extremely soggy, but still had good flavor. The pizza was amazing and exactly what we were looking for! Perfect place to take a break from all the seafood this town offers!
Steven Meltzer
Atlantic Pizza, Kennebunkport, Maine: Probably deserving of it’s mixed reviews. My wife liked it better than I, but I thought it was very good, but not great. Still, very, very fairly priced with fast friendly service. My frat brother who has a home in the area said it was terrible, but a couple we spoke with in the pizzeria eat there often and thought it was spectacular. So, somewhere in between, leaning toward the better.
Lisa Lingo
My husband and I visited Atlantic Pizza their first season and have never missed an opportunity to go back. The staff is super friendly, the dough is made fresh daily and they only use the freshest ingredients at very reasonable prices. I can honestly say that Atlantic Pizza was a factor in our decision to move to Maine from Ohio.
Paul Bourgault
Yummy pizza – slow service. Delivered wrong pizzas first time 100 minutes after placing order.
… View more