Based on 130 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
130 E Washington St, New Castle, PA 16101
Phone: (724) 657-2210
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–10 PM |
| Thursday | 3–10 PM |
| Friday | 3–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 3–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
stacey duffee
I would give zero stars if I could. I ordered a pizza, which did not taste right at all. My son who loves Pizza, didn’t even eat 2 bites. The dogs ate our remainder but that doesn’t count. I called and very nicely complained and a manager was to call me. 5 hours later still no call. I’m out $30 with the tip and neither of us ate. Just sad honestly. Life is too expensive for them to just disregard customers. NEVER AGAIN
… more
Brittany B
It was good over all. The workers were very friendly. We got ranch wings and they were AMAZING. The pizza was good. The only thing I wasn’t a fan of was the sauce on the pizza because it was really sweet but that’s just my opinion you should Def try it for yourself.
… more
Ryan Colaluca
Absolutely excellent!!! No matter what you order you won’t be disappointed. The Arizona ranch wings are absolutely phenomenal, all their wings are great but that’s our preference flavor: the pizza is delicious, and the flatbreads are out of this world. If you haven’t tried it yet you need to do so ASAP.
… more
Alicia Lebron
Just a suggestion I would let your customers know when placing order that the large is a Sicilian. Your sandwiches look amazing so I’ll definitely be back to try that. I’m a pizza fanatic so I was a lil bummed it wasn’t round as Sicilian isn’t my favorite. My medium 8 cut was round though. I surprisingly like the Sicilian most. Your garlicy sauce is on point. I would just like my crust a lil more done next time I’ll ask for well done. The pizza definitely tastes better than it looked it was lacking cheese but the sauce made up for it. #1 I’d definitely change the type of cheese you use. I gave 3 stars because of the cheese and not being aware it was Sicilian as stated above. Although I’m glad I had the Sicilian. I’ll definitely be trying other things. Just wanted to give a suggestion
… more
Jaime Ross
Absolutely Excellent food and staff. One of my favorite places. Bread bowl salads are phenomenal! Great job!
… more
Caitlin Wimer
This is in my opinion the only authentic Italian home style pizza in New Castle. For years I’ve been searching for something close to what my grandma made and I finally found it in their homestyle pizza tonight. Great prices, quick service. Will definitely be back.
… more
Angel Lyles
Phenomenal wings! Pierogi pizza is fire! Amazing friendly staff! Owner is hands on and focuses on customer/staff service. All around great place, now go eat!
… more
Vinyl Rat
They’re back room is unkept, filthy and has a mouse problem. Exactly the spot they store the flour for the dough which is where I’ve swept up mouse droppings. Also the other food products including the potato’s for the fries which aren’t cleaned/washed before cutting.
… more
sherri edling
Food was delivered hot. 1st time eating here…Food was delicious! The wings were indeed Jumbo and seasoned well. We also had the pierogie pizza [,1st time].. highly recommend! Thank you LJ’S for a delicious lunch. Will definitely reorder!
… more
Ray Mazzanti
One of the top pizza places in New Castle! The quality is always great and the online ordering is easy and user friendly. Italian flatbread, Arizona ranch wings, and the classic cheese pizza are my favorites!
… more
… View more