Little Italy of Hornell Menu

Little Italy is a family owned and operated business serving Hornell, Arkport and surrounding areas. Little Italy is a small pizzeria and so much more! Serving pizza, subs, wraps, pasta, wings and more. Little Italy has something for everyone. In 2019 Little Italy added a gluten free crust to the menu that tastes simply amazing. Come in and enjoy our small dining space with family and friends, pick up your order, or have us deliver. We love our customers and enjoy our community.

Based on 180 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Little Italy of Hornell 14843

Address:
7498 Seneca Rd N, Hornell, NY 14843

Phone: (607) 324-6740

Website: https://www.littleitalyofhornell.com/

Hours

Tuesday	11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday	11 AM–9 PM
Thursday	11 AM–9 PM
Friday	11 AM–9 PM
Saturday	11 AM–9 PM
Sunday	Closed
Monday	Closed

Pizza
Cheese Pizza Individual (4 slice), Medium (8 slice), Large (8 slice), Extra Large (12 Slice), Party Pizza (32 Slices) Go to littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Toppings Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Salami, Onion, Mushroom, Green Pepper, Black Olives, X-Cheese, Broccoli, Tomato, Pineapple, Extra Sauce, Chicken, Bacon Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
White Garlic Individual(4 slices), Medium (8 Slices), Large (8 slices), Extra Large (12 Slices), Party Pizza (32 Slices) Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Meat Craze Individual (4 slices), Medium ( 8 slices), Large (8 slices), Extra Large (12 Slices), Party Pizza (32 Slices) Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing
Chicken Wing Pizza Hot sauce and blue cheese base, topped with fresh chicken and mozzarella cheese. Individual (4 slice), Medium (8 Slices) Large (8 slices), Extra Large (12 Slices), Party Pizza (32 Slices) Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Calzones & Stromboli’s
Cheese Choose from small (serves 1) or Large (serves 1-2) Calzone includes mozzarella, ricotta and provolone cheese. Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing. Stromboli incudes Mozzarella cheese and pizza sauce.
Deluxe Meat Your choice of Calzone or Stromboli Meat: Pepperoni, Salami, Ham Substitutions may cost more. You may add up to 3 more toppings for additional cost. Toppings are listed under “Toppings” Small ( serves 1) Large (serves 1-2) Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Chicken Wing Calzone This includes Chicken, hot sauce , blue cheese and mozzarella. We do not use ricotta, provolone or pizza sauce in this. small ( serves 1) large (serves 1-2) Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Garlic Chicken Your choice of Calzone or Stromboli. Mounded Mozzarella cheese with chicken, butter garlic and either ricotta and provolone OR pizza sauce. Wrapped in our homemade dough, brushed with butter garlic and sprinkled with parmesan cheese. Baked to perfection. Small (serves 1) Large (serves 1-2)
Wings
Regular Wings Bone In Orders come in 5,10 and 40(you may split the 40 into 2 flavors 20/20) Choose your style: Hot, medium, mild, extra hot, WAY HOT!!!, Sweet and Tangy, Little Italy Style, Tangy Cajun, Butter Garlic Parm, Hot (medium or mild) garlic, BBQ, Honey BBQ, Honey Mustard Served with blue cheese or ranch Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing
Boneless Wings No Bone- breaded. Orders come in 5,10 and 40(you may split the 40 into 2 flavors 20/20) Choose your style: Hot, medium, mild, extra hot, WAY HOT!!!, Sweet and Tangy, Little Italy Style, Tangy Cajun, Butter Garlic Parm, Hot (medium or mild) garlic, BBQ, Honey BBQ, Honey Mustard Served with blue cheese or ranch Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing
Toasted Subs (Unless you specify otherwise, it will be toasted)
Ham Half (approx 8″) Whole (approx. 16″) Thin sliced black forest ham, provolone, lettuce tomato onion, mayonnaise and dressing layered on a fresh, baked on premise roll. Add banana peppers, hot pepper relish, black olives and more to make it your own kind of flavor explosion! Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
BLT Half (approx 8″) Whole (approx. 16″) Bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise layered on a fresh, baked on premise roll. For an extra charge add banana peppers, hot pepper relish, black olives and more to make it your own kind of flavor explosion! Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Italian Half (approx 8″) Whole (approx. 16″) Thin sliced black forest ham, smoked salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise and dressing layered on a fresh, baked on premise roll. For an added charge add banana peppers, hot pepper relish, black olives and more to make it your own kind of flavor explosion! Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Salami Half (approx 8″) Whole (approx. 16″) Smoked salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise and dressing layered on a fresh, baked on premise roll. For an added charge add banana peppers, hot pepper relish, black olives and more to make it your own kind of flavor explosion! Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Turkey Half (approx 8″) Whole (approx. 16″) Thin sliced turkey, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise and dressing layered on a fresh, baked on premise roll. For an added charge add banana peppers, hot pepper relish, black olives and more to make it your own kind of flavor explosion! Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Pizza Half (approx 8″) Whole (approx. 16″) Pizza Sauce, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni on a fresh, baked on premise roll. For an added charge add banana peppers, hot pepper relish, black olives and more to make it your own kind of flavor explosion! Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Steak Half (approx 8″) Whole (approx. 16″) Shaved steak, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise and dressing layered on a fresh, baked on premise roll. For an added charge add banana peppers, hot pepper relish, black olives and more to make it your own kind of flavor explosion! Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Cheeseburger Half (approx 8″) Whole (approx. 16″) Burger Patty, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise and dressing layered on a fresh, baked on premise roll. For an added charge add banana peppers, hot pepper relish, black olives and more to make it your own kind of flavor explosion! Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Meatball Half (approx 8″) Whole (approx. 16″) Hot meatballs with marinara and mozzarella cheese on a fresh, baked on premise roll. For an added charge add banana peppers, hot pepper relish, black olives and more to make it your own kind of flavor explosion! Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Chicken Half (approx 8″) Whole (approx. 16″) Chicken fingers, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise and dressing layered on a fresh, baked on premise roll. For an added charge add banana peppers, hot pepper relish, black olives and more to make it your own kind of flavor explosion! Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Chicken Parm Half (approx 8″) Whole (approx. 16″) Chicken tenders with marinara and mozzarella cheese on a fresh, baked on premise roll. For an added charge add banana peppers, hot pepper relish, black olives and more to make it your own kind of flavor explosion! Visit littleitalyofhornell.com for up to date pricing.
Toasted Wraps
Ham Or Turkey With Provolone Thin sliced ham or turkey, with mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, dressing and provolone cheese on a white tortilla.
Steak & Cheddar Shaved steak, with mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, dressing and cheddar cheese on a white tortilla.
Grilled Or Crispy Chicken Chicken tenders cut into pieces or seasoned chicken breast , with mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, dressing and provolone cheese on a white tortilla.
Spicy Southwest Chicken Chicken breast, chipotle pesto, hot sauce, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, banana pepper on a white tortilla.
Salad
Anti-Pasta Ham Or Turkey Your choice of ham or turkey. Both is an upcharge. A bed of lettuce with tomato, pepperoni, salami, provolone, mozzarella cheese, onion, banana peppers and black olives. Served with toasted garlic bread. Choice of Italian, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Honey Mustard, or Fat Free Raspberry Vinegrette.
Grilled Or Crispy Chicken Bed of lettuce topped with your choice of cut up chicken fingers, or seasoned chicken breast, tomato, onion, banana peppers and choice of dressing. Dressing choices: Italian, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Honey Mustard, Fat free raspberry vinaigrette.
Sub Salad( Ham, Turkey Or Salami) Shredded lettuce, Choice of meat, provolone cheese, tomato and onion chopped up, mixed with mayonnaise and Italian dressing. Not served with side dressing.
Tossed Salad Bed of lettuce topped with tomato, onion, banana peppers and choice of dressing. Served with toasted garlic bread. Dressing choices: Italian, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Honey Mustard, Fat free raspberry vinaigrette.
Appetizers
Garlic Knots Served as a single, order of 5 or 10. Extra saucy, marinara, pizza sauce or butter garlic is extra.
Chicken Fingers Order of 4 Chicken Fingers, Breaded. Dipped or sauce on side is extra.
Waffle Fries A pre-seasoned waffle cut potato fry. Served with ketchup.
French Fries Salted potato fry.
Fried Mushrooms W/ Ranch Battered mushrooms deep fried served with ranch or blue cheese.
Mozzarella Sticks W/ Marinara Sauce Battered mozzarella cheese stick, deep fried. Served with marinara sauce.
Onion Rings Thin battered onion ring, fried.
Chicken Wing Logs Served With Blue Cheese Battered wonton filled with chicken wing filling. Deep fried and served with choice of blue cheese or ranch.
Quesadilla (Cheese Or Chicken) 8 wedges, served with mozzarella cheese and seasoning in the middle with your choice to add chicken for additional cost. Served with sour cream and salsa.
Specials
Everyday Special Large Cheese Pizza , 10 Regular Wings or 10 Boneless & 2 Liter Item available everyday. Add up to 6 toppings to your pizza. Specialty pizzas not included.
Tuesday $9 Large Pizza 4-9pm Large Cheese Pizza Available 4-9pm
Wednesday Special Order a Medium or Larger Pizza at full price get 5 garlic knots for $2.49(+ tax)
Friday Special Medium Cheese Pizza and 10 Regular or Boneless Wings.
Saturday Special Ask for the Saturday special. $1 off any size pizza medium or larger.
Combos
Chicken Finger Combo Chicken Fingers, French Fries, 16 -20oz Drink
Sandwich Combo 8″ Sub/Wrap, French Fries, 16 – 20 oz Drink
2 Slice Combo 2 Slices cheese, 16 – 20 oz Drink Pepperoni also available regularly at an additional cost. Lunch time we serve specialty slices that rotate throughout the week, while they last or 3pm. Whichever comes first.
Garlic Knot Sandwich Combo Choose from a Garlic Knot Burger(Bacon cheddar, or American Dill, or Mushroom onion swiss) or a Garlic Knot Chickwich(Chicken Parm or Chicken Bacon Ranch or Buffalo chicken). A larger garlic knot bun with your choice of the above and smothered in butter garlic. We do not add lettuce tomato or any other topping or condiment. Served with french fries.
Sandwiches
Fish Fry With French fries or waffle fries, cole slaw and tarter sauce.
Pizza Crust Sandwich Steak, chicken, or cheeseburger
Bacon Cheddar Garlic Knot Burger
Mushroom Onion Swiss Garlic Knot Burger
American Dill Garlic Knot Burger
Desserts
Fried Dough Our dough fried and topped with confectioners sugar and light cinnamon.
Raspberry Cheesecake Bites 2 Raspberry Cheesecake filled wantons, covered with confectioners sugar.
8″ Chocolate Chunk Cookie
Beverages
20oz Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Vanilla Coke, Coke Zero, Sprite, Gingerale, Root Beer, Dr Pepper, Diet Dr Pepper, Unsweet Tea, Sweet Tea, Raspberry Tea, Peach Tea, and more
2 Liter Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr Pepper, or Root Beer
Tummy Yummy

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

P Reilly

There’s very few reasons to go to Hornell on purpose. If you’re like me, you sometimes end up there due to circumstances beyond your control. There aren’t many options for food/dining in the area, so I was fortunate to discover this place, as it’s pretty solid. Decent variety, some of the food appears to be prepared fresh, and I like the idea of using garlic knots instead of regular buns on parm sandwiches. Nothing really to complain about, beyond the fact it’s in Hornell.

… more

Rachelle Marie

Great pizza! Wings were good too, asked for extra crispy and they were! On time for pick up. Friendly staff. Second trip the pizza was doughy and not the same. They ask for tip when you pick up which I don’t agree with. I picked it up, I’ll tip a driver.

… more

Lance Trudell

Amazing pizza, amazing service. If you’ve never tried their garlic bread knots, try them and be prepared. More garlic in a single knot than an entire order of garlic bread from anywhere else. I opened the box and it smacked me in the face like like a rude comment to a total stranger 🙂 . All jokes aside, amazing garlic flavor!!! I was not disappointed and I don’t think you will be either.

… more

Will Pirtle

I got delivery it was great no complaints no Dave portnoy doesn’t like Parmesan but I do give you 5 golden shovels .it was hot when it came to the house chicken boneless wings were excellent chicken parmesan was delicious wings buffalo mild I will let my wife decide.perfect 10 way to go little Italy of Hornell under pressure and busy.

… more

Holly Jacobs

My favorite place to order lunch from. Delivery is almost always faster than what they estimate for me and their food is delicious!

… more

Paul Watkins

First time being there, and I must say what a surprise it was and a true delight!

… more

Andrew Field

My family lives in Jamestown NY and I live in Waterloo NY and we found this to be a great place to meet halfway and enjoy a lunch together! The wings and pizza were excellent! Inside the resturant appeared to be all remodeled and very appealing inside. Definitely a family atmosphere!

… more

Sterling Williams

I spent $80 on food and it tasted terrible. Little Italy cooks need to change the fryer. Grease more often. And don’t fry dough In chicken grease or the fried dough will taste like chicken

… more

Del

I ordered a party pizza the other night from Little Italy, and I must say, not only was it delicious, but it was only $22 (+tax) and lasted us for 4 days of meals and snacks!! There is no other pizza joint in Hornell where you don’t get charged a surcharge for using a credit card, pay $22 for a party pizza which was delicious AND be greeted by a wonderful staff! I highly encourage locals to go to Little Italy if you want great food, great service and great prices!! It’s been awhile since we have ordered from Little Italy, but from now on, this is our go-to!!

… more

swamp pirate

The service was friendly and wonderful, the choice of paint color of the interior and the accompanying artwork along with the fireplace, and great food, make the dining experience cozy and comforting. Although I did find the use of to go condiments a little on the cheesy side, I highly recommend Little Italy for dining.

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Little Italy of Hornell Menu – Hornell, NY

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Related:

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions