Lickity Split Restaurant Menu

A True Mom & Pop Shop

We are proud to welcome you into our family friendly restaurant with the vibe of an old-time ice cream parlor and sandwich shoppe! We’re known for our homemade soups, grilled sandwiches, wraps, and of course our ice cream menu!

Mitch and Gina Dissinger, owners of Lickity Split, are passionate about many things, two of which are food and New Holland. So when the opportunity presented itself to open a restaurant in a historic building in downtown New Holland, they jumped at the chance.
After five months of hard work renovating their section of the old Kauffman’s Hardware building, Lickity Split opened it’s doors to the public in June of 2010.

Popular items: Thanksgiving Day Sandwich, Dill Pickle Soup

Relaxed, old-fashioned ice cream parlor & sandwich shop in a historical hardware store. Based on 623 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Lickity Split Restaurant 17557

Address:
209 E Main St, New Holland, PA 17557

Phone: (717) 354-4986

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Wednesday	11 AM–7 PM
Thursday	11 AM–7 PM
Friday	11 AM–7 PM
Saturday	11 AM–7 PM
Sunday	Closed
Monday	11 AM–7 PM
Tuesday	11 AM–7 PM

APPETIZERS
Pretzel Nuggets Fifteen soft pretzel nuggets served with hot cheddar sauce and cranberry honey mustard for dipping
Nachos Tortilla chips with melted cheese, sour cream and salsa on the side
Cheese Quesadilla Crispy tortilla wrap filled with shredded cheese served with tortilla chips and the option of sour cream and salsa on the side. Add chicken
PA Dutch Platter A platter of leaf lettuce with chicken salad, cheese slices, red beet egg, sweet bologna and crackers
Chips And Salsa bowl of tortilla chips and side of salsa
Chicken Quesadilla grilled chicken and melted cheddar cheese served with tortilla chips, sour cream, and salsa on the side
Roast Beef Quesadilla roast beef and melted cheddar cheese served with chips and horseradish mayo or bbq sauce on the side
S O U P S
Homemade Soups: Chicken Corn Noodle, Creamy Dill Pickle, Or Soup Of The Day Cup or Bowl
WRAPS
Rubinson’s Chicken Salad Wrap Creamy chicken salad with dried cranberries, almonds, lettuce, and tomat
Brimmer Turkey Wrap Fresh roasted turkey, crispy bacon, ranch, american cheese, lettuce and tomato
Chicken Caesar Wrap Grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, croutons, and fresh parmesan cheese covered with our creamy caesar dressing
Grilled Main Street Wrap Grilled ham, swiss cheese, sliced apples, and spicy brown mustard
Wild Buffalo Wrap Grilled chicken, provolone cheese, buffalo sauce, lettuce and tomato with your choice of bleu cheese or ranch
Veggie Wrap Cucumbers, onions, lettuce, tomatoes, and provolone with choice of dressing
Smoky BBQ Chicken Wrap Grilled chicken breast topped with tangy bbq sauce, cheddar cheese, and cole slaw
Black Bean Wrap tex-mex rice, black beans, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions and salsa
Old Bay Chicken Wrap grilled chicken breast, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and Old Bay mayonnaise
Build Your Own Sandwich
Bread White, wheat, rye, kaiser roll, ciabatta, plain wrap, spinach herb wrap, tomato basil wrap (gluten-free bread or gluten-free wraps available for an extra charge)
Meat Roasted turkey, ham, chicken salad, sweet bologna, roast beef, grilled chicken
Cheese American, swiss, provolone, cheddar, pepper jack
Main Menu – Grilled Sandwiches
Garden Spot Melt Our homemade creamy chicken salad with bacon and cheddar cheese served on grilled ciabatta
Kauffman’s Cuban Grilled ham, hard salami, swiss cheese, dill pickles, spicy brown mustard, grilled on crunchy ciabatta
Trimmer’s Tribute Roasted turkey, crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, mayo, apple butter and apple slices on grilled ciabatta
Sales Barn Beef Dip Sliced roast beef and melted provolone cheese, on a toasted sub roll served with a side of beef au jus
Weaver’s Chicken Grilled chicken breast, melted cheddar cheese, bacon lettuce, tomato, and ranch or bbq dressing on a kaiser roll
Baler Beef Melt Grilled sliced roast beef, cheddar cheese and bbq sauce on a kaiser roll
New Holland Griller Thick cut slice of sweet bologna, provolone, cheddar, and yellow mustard grilled on wheat bread
Town Clock News (Also Known As A Reuben) Roast beef or roasted turkey, swiss, sauerkraut, 1,000 island, grilled on deli rye
The Clarion (Also Known As A Rachel) Roast beef or roasted turkey, swiss, cole slaw, 1,000 island, grilled on deli rye
Stuffed Pretzel Melt Made locally from an amish bakery, choose from ham and cheese or cheese steak in baked pretzel dough. Sauces available.
200 Block Provolone, cheddar, and american cheese grilled on wheat bread. Add bacon or tomato
Veggie Melt Provolone, cheddar, tomato, lettuce, and cucumber on grilled deli rye with choice of dressing
Classic Grilled Cheese american cheese on grilled white bread
Signature Sandwiches
Thanksgiving Day Roasted turkey, warm stuffing, cranberry sauce and mayo on a kaiser roll
Railroad Avenue Sub Provolone cheese, italian ham, hard salami, lettuce, tomato, parmesan, oregano and olive oil on a sub roll
Lickity Lou Club A triple-decker with ham, roasted turkey, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, bacon and mayo on your choice of toast
BLT Crisp bacon, lettuce, and tomato with mayo on your choice of toast
Salads
Lickity Split Salad Arcadian greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, shredded cheese and potato sticks
Orchard Mixed greens, mandarin oranges, apples, dried cranberries, almonds, and cucumbers served with poppyseed dressing
Caesar Romaine lettuce, croutons, fresh parmesan and caesar dressing
Spring House Mixed greens with dried cranberries, almonds, tomatoes and onions
Chef Arcadian greens, turkey, ham, swiss, red beet egg, tomatoes and croutons
Dressings Ranch, Italian, Caesar, Bleu Cheese, Poppy Seed, Honey Mustard, Oil & Vinegar, Fat-Free Raspberry Vinaigrette, 1,000 Island
Add Meat To Salads Grilled chicken, Chicken Salad, Fresh roasted turkey, Buffalo Chicken
Combos
Soup & Half Sandwich Choose any sandwich in the menu (does not include Club, Stuffed Pretzel Melts, or Black Bean Wrap)
Small Salad & Half Sandwich Choose any salad and any sandwich (does not include the chef salad)
Soup & Small Salad
Kid’s Meals (incudes side and drink)
Cup Of Soup & 1/2 Grilled Cheese
Grilled Cheese
Hot Dog
Peanut Butter & Jelly
Peanut Butter & Marshmallow
Build Your Own Sandwich
Main Menu – Beverages
Soda Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Root Beer, Birch Beer, Sprite
Lemonade
Unsweetened Tea And Sweet Tea
Sweet Tea (Free Refills)
Italian Soda Seltzer soda mixed with your choice of added drink flavoring (free refills)
Strawberry Patch Lemonade Our special mix of sweet strawberries and lemonade in a satisfying blend (free refills)
Milk And Chocolate Milk
Bottled Water
Milk Shake Hand-spun milk shake made the old fashioned way with any flavor of ice cream
Ice Cream Float Vanilla ice cream floating in a glass of root beer, coke or orange soda
Coffee
Hot Tea
Dessert Sips
Milkshake Made the old fashioned way with any flavor of ice cream!
Campfire Shake A Vanilla malt shake topped with roasted marshmallows.
Radio Shack Shake Chocolate ice cream mixed with caramel and Oreos.
Ice Cream Float Creamy Vanilla ice cream floating in a glass of Root Beer, Coke, or Birch Beer.
Dessert Menu – “Sweet News from the Town Scoop”
Featuring Leiby’s Premium Ice Cream Our delicious ice cream is like getting free facial ice cream surgery guaranteed for an instant face lift (oooh), eyebrow lift (ahhh), cheek implant (excited smile), and frown lifter (lasts and lasts), no anesthesia required!
Dessert – Cones & Dishes
Petite Scoop The right size for kids or those with full bellies.
Single Scoop One generous scoop.
Double Scoop Two generous scoops.
Toppings Hot Fudge, Chocolate syrup, Caramel Syrup, Strawberry topping, Marshmallow topping, Oreo pieces, Rainbow Sprinkles, Chocolate Sprinkles, Crushed Peanuts, Wet Walnuts, Crushed Pretzels, Malt, Banana, Gummy Worms
Dessert Menu – The “Sundae” News
Hot Fudge Banana Boat Three scoops of vanilla ice cream between a banana, drenched in hot fudge, and topped with whipped cream, crushed peanuts and a cherry.
Lickity Split Banana Split A scoop of chocolate ice cream topped with chocolate syrup, a scoop of vanilla topped with pineapple, and a scoop of black raspberry topped with strawberry, all nestled between a banana and topped with whipped cream, sprinkles, crushed peanuts and a cherry.
Hot Waffles & Ice Cream Sandwich Two hot toasted homemade waffles filled with up to 3 ice cream flavors of your choice and lightly coated with powdered sugar.
Hot Waffle Sundae Choose 3 scoops of ice cream and 2 toppings to be piled on top of hot toasted homemade waffles, topped with whipped cream and a cherry.
Ice Cream Flight Four mini dishes of ice cream in a sampler flight
Cookie Bottom Sundae A homemade chocolate chip cookie served under a layer of vanilla ice cream and hot fudge, topped with whipped cream, chocolate chips and a cherry.
Classic Brownie Sundae Chocolate ice cream and vanilla ice cream covered with our homemade brownie pieces, smothered with hot fudge and topped with whipped cream, sprinkles and a cherry.
The Dissinger Family Favorite Gather the family together for seven scoops of ice cream and seven delicious toppings with fresh bananas, whipped cream, decadent chocolate chips and cherries.
Dessert Menu – Signature Sundaes
Musty Dusty Road Vanilla ice cream topped with chocolate syrup, malt, whipped cream and a cherry.
Wet And Muddy Road Vanilla ice cream topped with caramel, malt, whipped cream and cherry.
CMP Vanilla ice cream topped with chocolate syrup, marshmallow topping, crushed peanuts, whipped cream and a cherry.
Jiminy Cricket Good ‘ole mint chocolate chip ice cream topped with hot fudge, crushed Oreos, whipped cream and a cherry.
Kauffman’s Jailhouse Rock Black raspberry ice cream topped with M&M’s and red bars of licorice, whipped cream and a cherry.
Garden Patch Black raspberry ice cream topped with strawberry, pineapple, and raspberry topping, chocolate thorns (sprinkles), whipped cream and a cherry.
Plowed Field Cookies & cream ice cream plowed with crushed Oreos, chocolate syrup, earth wor-I mean, gummy worms, whipped cream and a cherry.
Sweet Road Apple (or death by chocolate) Chocolate ice cream topped with hot fudge, crushed Oreos, chocolate sprinkles, crushed peanuts, whipped cream and a cherry.
Candy Shoppe Milky Way and Nittany Paws ice cream topped with M&M’s, chocolate syrup, rainbow sprinkles, whipped cream and a cherry.
Salted Caramel Brownie Vanilla ice cream topped with brownie pieces, crushed pretzels, caramel, whipped cream and a cherry with a sprinkle of salt crystals.
Daily Spotlight Meals – Main
Monday: Manic Burger Monday
Tuesday: Farmshow Favorite Pulled Beef! Our famous 20 hour slow roasted tender pulled beef, lightly seasoned and served with American cheese on a toasted Kaiser roll
Wednesday: “Waffle Waffle Wednesday” Turkey and graved over homemade waffles, served with mashed potatoes, a side of cole slaw and cranberry sauce
Thursday: Cook’s Choice
Friday: Enjoy One Of Our Amazing Weekly Quesadillas
Saturday: Cook’s Choice

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

David S.

Today was our first time visiting Luckity Split Restaurant, and we were so glad that we did. From the moment that we walked in, until we left, the staff was welcoming, kind, and made you feel like they appreciated your business! The decor and atmosphere of the restaurant is charming and makes you want to sit back and relax. The kids menu was a hit! They offer many choices for kids from a hotdog, Mac and cheese, peanut butter and jelly, peanut butter and fluff to a build your own sandwich. I enjoyed the Turkey and Waffles!!! Oh wow was it good! Two waffles smothered in tender Turkey and savory gravy served with mashed potatoes and gravy, coleslaw, cranberry sauce and apple sauce. The Dill Pickle Soup was also amazing! So good!! To end our meal we enjoyed the petite serving of ice cream. I recommend tasting the Teaberry ice cream……a very interesting and good flavor. Enjoy! We can not wait to come back to try more of their delicious menu!

… more

Marilyn Martin

Lickity Split hosted my sister’s bridal shower at Lickity Split Down Under. The staff was very easy to work with and the food was absolutely delicious! The atmosphere was warm and inviting. They even provided background music. If you are looking for a venue in the New Holland area for 20-25 people….look into this venue. You won’t be disappointed!

… more

Sarah Toback

Decor was so cute! We were quickly seated and our order for drinks taken. Our appetizers came out quickly, and I highly recommend the PA Dutch platter!

… more

Melissa Fraser

This little restaurant was great! The food was delicious! I had a cheeseburger and I loved it. The ice cream was really good as well. The waitress was amazing! I definitely will be going back to try another item on their menu.

… more

Shannon Sensenig

I recently had the pleasure of indulging in the delectable treats from Lickity Split Ice Cream Truck, and I must say, it was an experience that brought me joy as we pushed through a week of finals at Lancaster Bible College.

… more

ashh

They have the nicest staff here and the most wonderful food, icecream and lunch sandwiches!! I definitely recommend stopping in for some icecream, a quick bite to eat or just to gobble down a classic banana split!!!

… more

Dawn Weaver

Very impressed with the friendly service by our waitress, and she even let all of us taste a sample of the dill pickle soup! Our food came out quickly and everything was delicious. They have lots of fun ice cream sundae choices. Thank you for serving our food in beautiful dishes, and for the Bible verses on the bottom of the menus.

… more

Tom Chan

A small cafe restaurant with entrance from the back to minimize the traffic noise from the main street. It has the small town atmosphere and serves some great burgers and ice cream. The wait staff was very friendly and helpful. We tried the pickle cream soup and it sure has some kick to it. Prices was reasonable and service was quick.

… more

Diana Lettkeman

What a wonderful place ❤️. We stopped in for lunch and had an absolutely delicious meal . The service was great. I highly recommend a visit to this place if you are ever in the area.

… more

Dave Trout

Wow, just Wow. Kitchy place in New Holland PA with stuff I’ve never seen before. Dill pickle soup (Amazing) and I a sweet balogna and cheese grilled sandwich (yum). Fantastic service on top of it all.

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Lickity Split Restaurant Menu – New Holland, PA

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Related:

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions