Based on 206 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
206 New Castle Rd, Butler, PA 16001
Phone: (724) 283-7333
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Corina R
The New Yorker ( bacon, pepperoni, and green peppers), Italian hoagie w/works ( small ), Steak & Cheese hoagie ( large ) and Fries with cheddar & bacon.
Carolyn Wincer
Order was delivered to the wrong address when we used the slice app. When food finally arrived the pizza and wings was over cooked. No offer was made to make the situation better. Order was placed at 4pm, did not have the food until 630. Will not be returning.
James Lambert
Showed up earlier this evening at closing time, and they were more than happy to still take my order. The Italian hoagie was toasted and fantastic. And the New York style pizza was great (Pepperoni, Mushroom, Green Peppers, and Meatball) . They even sprinkle parmesan cheese on the pizza before closing the box. It’s the little things and attention to detail that makes places like this that much better. If you find yourself in the area, do stop in for a pie. Terrific service, delicious food, and great value. Fat kid tested, fat kid approved…
Hunter Hodak
Prices are really good and the amount of food you get is a lot. However I had the chicken bacon cheddar sub and it was very subpar and a little disappointing. However the pepperoni balls were super good! And the ranch was amazing!
Carl Swartz
I just got carryout. So, I couldn’t say about the atmosphere. I don’t think there is a dining room. However, the pizza was out of this world. Will definitely go back to try other food items.
Billy Belajac
I got the bbq chicken pizza. For a $16 pizza, it was subpar. I’ve had better frozen pizzas
Lori Walker
Told the girl I absolutely did NOT want yellow peppers on my pizza three times and when my pizza was delivered they eliminated my olives and loaded it up with YELLOW peppers. I talked with the guy and he denied it. I offered to send him a picture of my pizza and he said I’ll drive to your house and see it! And then to top it they put cheddar cheese on my Italian pizza!! Yukkkk! I’ll never do business with them again.
Candy Robison-Jones
Grand opening week…they messed up our order both times we went but understand new owner n tryin to honor last place of business menu ..we gonna give it another whirl
Alissa Robinson
The best pizza and customer service in the butler area hands down. Hats off to everyone that works hard to make such tasty pizzas at Pizza Plus! Keep it up!
Ghost_Tom_Joad
This place used to be better. Darn near impossible to actually get through to someone on the phone most times. Today we weren’t given the 2 litre we ordered with our meal. Also the pizza itself was under cooked and cold. The crust was super chewy. I will say there were plenty of toppings, but that doesn’t do anything for me if they aren’t cooked. The hoagie also was super soft and chewy. I only live 10 minutes away and was at the pickup counter exactly when they told me to be. I tried calling twice after I got home to ask for a refund but as I stated earlier, it’s almost impossible to get an answer. Undercooked food plus I couldn’t refunded? Yinz gotta do better.
… View more