We are Killer Pies. A nod to classic pizza joints with a new school take. Amazing NY style, thin-crust slices with a house-made soft drink program that can only be born and bred in downtown Asbury Park, NJ. Indoor dining, outdoor seating, pick up and delivery now available.
Based on 166 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
649 Mattison Ave, Asbury Park, NJ 07712
Phone: (732) 455-3100
Website: https://www.killerpies.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12 PM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 12 PM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 12–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Heather Boswick
New pizza joint in town. Love their whole vibe. Really embraced the Asbury Park feel. The inside is beautiful. Love their branding. My friends got a pie to go and said it was good.
… more
gia !
• pepperoni slice – basic. nothing to write home about, really. there was a garlic chili oil? can’t recall what it was but it was bomb.
… more
Lauren J. Cooke
First learned of Killer Pies on a gluten-free in New Jersey facebook group – and I can say that the gluten-free slices (and can be ordered as a whole pie) are worth the hype! Sicilian-like slices! So good!
… more
Giovanna Mazzilli
On a hot summer day we went to get pizza in asbury as soon as we walked into this place all of our problems were solved. We were hungry, hot, and had to pee. When we got in there we felt the nice ac (but not too cold, it was just right), we found a bathroom, and not only got the best pizza in the country, but we also had the best pinwheels (garlic knots, one with pepperoni and one with just garlic) known to man kind. Not only was the food and environment good but so was the staff. They walked the food right out to us and were very talkative and welcoming. To put the cherry on top, the price was very good! It was a reasonable price for all we bought, especially considering the price of most things these days. I definitely recommend this place
… more
Stargazer
I want to start this by saying the pepperoni and garlic pinwheels are amazing! Not to mention the pizza feels like authentic NY pizza and is almost as delicious as the pinwheels were, also the sauce tastes out of this world. Overall the service was great, the food was given to us hot and quickly and tasted awesome. I can’t wait to go back again!
… more
Ryoji Yamada
Ate at KP today for the first time and it is stellar! Perfect sauce, I think perfect mozzarella cheese and really great crust. The signature “killer” slice which is just a plain is fantastic! My only note is that crust doesn’t have some of the tang/flavor that some other NY slices have. Totally nitpick as it’s a great slice. The white garlic is dope I’m no small part due to the excellent cheese combo! Also had a sesame crusted special slice with chicken and some other delicious toppings on a margherita base, so so good. Can’t wait to come back!!
… more
Bridget
One of the best pizza places in the area, every person behind that counter is super friendly and kind. They care about the little things like making sure you have ice and a cup for your can of soda, making sure your slices or whole pie is good. The vibe and decor of the place are the icing on the cake for this pizza shop. It’s our go to when we want consistently good pizza. The pepperoni pizza is my classic fav there
… more
Jesse Litchman
My wife and I spent the weekend in Asbury Park and after a show at the Stone Pony, we were looking for some good pizza. We found it with Killer Pies. The pizza hit the spot, and it was unique and fresh, exactly what we were looking for. The next day, about two hours from Asbury Park, I realized I lost my debit card. I called Killer Pies, and quickly got an answer that I had left it there. Many heartfelt thanks to the people at Killer Pies for finding my debit card and mailing it to me in Connecticut!! Excellent people, excellent food, five stars all the way, and we’ll definitely be back in the summer!
… more
Dong Yun
Everyone loved the quality of the Cesar salad. Daughter could not get enough of the upside down Sicilian.
… more
Jaclyn Trippe
Legitimately the BEST gluten free crust I’ve ever had. And the dairy free cheese was amazing! The owner was so kind and helpful and made everything so easy! Will 100% be coming back often!
… more
… View more