Key West Tacos Menu – Cape May, NJ

Type : Mexican restaurant

Location : Cape May, NJ

Quirky beach shack style Mexican with outdoor tables, plating burritos, quesadillas & tacos. Based on 580 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Key West Tacos 08204

Address:
479 W Perry St, Cape May, NJ 08204

Phone: (609) 898-8226

Website: http://keywesttacos.com/

Hours

Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday Closed
Friday Closed
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed
Monday Closed

Menu

Key West Taco Signatures – All single tacos come with corn chips. All platters include 2 tacos, rice and corn chips
Tony’s Sweet Thai Shrimp
Shrimp, sweet thai chile sauce, arugula and pineapple-mango pico		 $9.50
Joey B’s Korean BBQ Brisket
Smoked beef brisket with korean bbq sauce and pineapple-mango pico		 $9.50
Mary’s Roasted Brussel Sprouts
Roast brussel sprouts with crumbled bacon and balsamic glaze		 $8.50
Pepe’s Shrimp And Chorizo
Shrimp and chorizo sausage with pineapple-mango pico		 $9.50
Craig’s Poke Tuna Taco
Sushi grade rare tuna, marinated with soy sauce, sesame oil, toasted sesame seeds, jalapenos, scallions and avocado, topped with seaweed salad		 $12.00
Key West Taco Classics Menu
The Classic
A heaping ground beef taco with pico de gallo and classic taco seasoning		 $7.50
Key West Chicken
Marinated chicken with fresh pico de gallo and a squeeze of lime		 $8.00
Islander Short Rib
Slow roasted short rib served with pineapple-mango pico		 $9.00
Bubba’s Shrimp
Garlic, butter and old reliable seafood spice		 $8.50
J.B.’S Famous Fish
Our catch of the day, blackened and served with a smoked chipotle tartar sauce		 $8.50
Reggie’s Pulled Pork
Slow cooked pork seasoned with the original 16 spice Caribbean blend and our smoky barbecue sauce		 $8.00
Vegetarian
Black beans, roasted peppers, onions, grilled corn, rice and jalapenos		 $7.50
Crab Crab Crab
Fresh lump crab seasoned with our own seafood spice, topped with guacamole		 $9.50
Ahi Tuna
Seared with Caribbean spice, topped with Key West slaw and pineapple-mango pico		 $9.50
Sloppy Joe
Hemmingway’s favorite lunch time snack, perfect for the child in all of us		 $7.50
Key Largo Bowls
Land Lover’s Favorite Bowl
All bowls are filled with corn chips, cheddar jack cheese, dirty rice, refried beans, roasted corn, black beans, island slaw and fresh pico de gallo and your land lover favorite		 $14.00
Seafood Favorites Bowl
All bowls are filled with corn chips, cheddar jack cheese, dirty rice, refried beans, roasted corn, black beans, island slaw and fresh pico de gallo and your seafood favorite		 $15.00
Ahi Tuna Bowl
All bowls are filled with corn chips, cheddar jack cheese, dirty rice, refried beans, roasted corn, black beans, island slaw and fresh pico de gallo and ahi tuna		 $16.00
Nachos, Quesadillas, Burritos and Salads
Lots Of Nachos
A heaping pile of nachos topped with cheddar jack, black beans, grilled corn, jalapenos, sour cream, and guacamole		 $13.00
Lots Of Nachos – Add Any Key West Favorite Topper
A heaping pile of nachos topped with cheddar jack, black beans, grilled corn, jalapenos, sour cream, guacamole and your favorite Key West topper		 $17.00
Lots Of Nachos – Ahi Tuna
A heaping pile of nachos topped with cheddar jack, black beans, grilled corn, jalapenos, sour cream, guacamole and topped with ahi tuna		 $19.00
Islamorada Quesadilla – All Land Loving Favorites
Each quesadilla starts with a gigantic flour tortilla, grilled with melted cheddar jack cheese and filled with one of your Key West land lover favorites and served with sour cream and salsa		 $13.00
Islamorada Quesadilla – All Seafood Favorites
Each quesadilla starts with a gigantic flour tortilla, grilled with melted cheddar jack cheese and filled with one of your Key West seafood favorites and served with sour cream and salsa		 $14.00
Islamorada Quesadilla – Ahi Tuna
Each quesadilla starts with a gigantic flour tortilla, grilled with melted cheddar jack cheese and filled with Key West ahi tuna and served with sour cream and salsa		 $15.00
Claire’s Classic Caesar Salad
Fresh chopped romaine, served with shaved parmesan, cherry tomatoes, seasoned croutons, fresh sliced lemons and Claire’s house made Caesar dressing		 $11.00
Claire’s Classic Caesar Salad – Add Any Key West Favorite Topper
Fresh chopped romaine, served with shaved parmesan, cherry tomatoes, seasoned croutons, fresh sliced lemons, Claire’s house made Caesar dressing and your Key West favorite topper		 $15.00
Claire’s Classic Caesar Salad – Ahi Tuna
Fresh chopped romaine, served with shaved parmesan, cherry tomatoes, seasoned croutons, fresh sliced lemons, Claire’s house made Caesar dressing and ahi tuna		 $17.00
Tavenier Burritos – All Land Lover Favorites
All of the El-Loco Burritos are filled with cheddar jack, dirty rice, refried beans and island slaw. The crazy part is choosing your Key West favorite to call your own		 $14.00
Tavenier Burritos – All Seafood Favorites
All of the El-Loco Burritos are filled with cheddar jack, dirty rice, refried beans and island slaw. The crazy part is choosing your Key West favorite seafood to fill it with		 $15.00
Tavenier Burrito – Ahi Tuna
All of the El-Loco Burritos are filled with cheddar jack, dirty rice, refried beans and island slaw. The crazy part is filling it with ahi tuna		 $16.00
Long Key Sides
Refried Beans $3.75
Roasted Black Beans & Corn $4.50
Chips And Salsa $4.50
Chips And Guacamole $8.95
Sour Cream $1.00
Salsa $1.00
Rice And Beans $3.75
Island Slaw $3.75
Guacamole $2.95
Island Treats
Key Lime Pie
Fresh baked key lime pie		 $6.50
Key Lime Ice Cream
Small batch hand made Key West Taco key lime ice cream. Limited availability.		 $6.50
Smoothies
Berry Berry Berry $7.95
Parrothead Peach $7.95
Pirate Punch $7.95
The Green Flash $8.95
Havana Banana $7.95
Caribbean Pineapple $7.95

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Heidi Everhart
These were the best, most fresh + delicious tacos I’ve had since Acapulco/Mexico City.

… more

Dominique Ventola
Fast, friendly service, cool vibes & great food! So happy we found this place while vacationing in Cape May! Portions are big! Well worth the price. We had chicken tacos and they were so flavorful. We would highly recommend this place!

… more

Skeeter Lee
Best tacos in Cape May and they are delicious. A single is larger than tacos at most places. Prices are very good for what you get. Staff is friendly and helpful. Very casual atmosphere with most of the picnic tables outside under an awning. I am a frequent customer who has never had a poor experience.

… more

Small Town Guy
Consistency great food. Always great service. What you expect in a tourist town. My wife and I always order way too much food every time we are here. You definitely won’t be disappointed if you give this place a try.

… more

Braden Reese
Great Tacos! A little bit expensive but for the portion sizes it’s actually pretty reasonable. Their fish and classic tacos have not disappointed yet.

… more

Pablo Carrera
We ate a couple of tacos and they were very mediocre (and overpriced, paying 18$ for two). The place did not have a bathroom and the waitress told me to go to the corner CVS to use one, it’s pretty incredible you can’t even wash your hands in a place you typically eat with them. The teenager waitress was very rude to us the two times we asked her questions. Not a great dinner experience.

… more

Pragati Gupta
Key west Tacos has vegetarian options. The taste is good. They server the food in the beautiful garden. We ordered burritos and tacos. The quantity is more then what I expected .

… more

Will Dawson
I was not a fan, the food was EXTREMELY overpriced, $13.00 for ground beef, cold rice, and grocery store chips, literally every ingredient was store bought and lacked flavor, authenticity, or anything remotely good tasting. The seating was extremely small (literally 5 outdoor tables) which wouldn’t be a problem if the food was worth it, like an actual authentic taco spot. Cash only also sucks and honestly everything sucked, i’m sure i could make better tacos on my own if i tried because we’d be using the same ingredients.

… more

Michael Zwolinski
What a hidden gem!

… more

Ethan
These are some of the best damn tacos I’ve ever had. Big portions and fairly priced for the quality. Staff is friendly and service is quick. Amazing hot sauce.

… more

… View more

Related:

  1. La Doña Restaurante Mexicano Menu – Cape May, NJ
  2. Big Wave Burritos Menu – Cape May, NJ
  3. Exit Zero Filling Station Menu – Cape May, NJ
  4. Ebbitt Room Menu – Cape May, NJ

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch