Why Kay Jack: It’s our attention to detail that sets Kay Jack Pizza apart. “Quality ingredients” and “fresh products” are not just marketing terms for us – they’re actually how we do business. Nothing on our menu is that basic, frozen, reheated food served off the back of a delivery truck like you would get at a typical pizza chain. Instead, we have built each recipe on our menu with attention to quality and flavor because that’s how your local pizzeria should do it, right?
If you want to know more about our doughs, sauces, and key ingredients, check out our quality section on our website or follow us on Facebook!
Based on 40 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
Inside Duffy’s Tavern, 60 W Main St, Madison, OH 44057
Phone: (440) 428-9937
Website: http://www.kayjack.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday |
4–8 PM |
| Thursday |
4–8 PM |
| Friday |
4–8 PM |
| Saturday |
4–8 PM |
| Sunday |
Closed |
| Monday |
4–8 PM |
| Tuesday |
4–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Raymond Haynes
Delicious pizza served inside Duffy’s Tavern. The garlic cheese bread is also awesome. Frendly staff. Try the white garlic butter with sausage and bacon pizza .
… more
Chris P
I had an awesome Pizza from this place. THE TOPPINGS we plentiful and the delicious. Not to greasy and oily. The owners were friendly as well. I would go back again if I happen to be in the Area. Go Blue!
… more
Kitt Lashley
Hands down my favorite pizza around. This is artisan pizza and you can taste it. The dough is fluffy and goes perfect with their sauce and it reheats great the next day. The classic pepperoni is our favorite. My kids love the cheese bread and the fried dough and Carmel dipping sauce is delicious and you will wish you had more .
… more
Ed Mackovjak
By far the best pizza around! Always perfectly cooked, the right amount of ingredients, and friendly service! If you haven’t had this, you’re missing out! 100% recommend!
… more
Ray Delmoko
If I could give Kay Jack’s more than 5 stars, I would. Easily the best pizza in Lake County. 🙂
… more
Anthony King
I was really excited to try a new pizza place in Lake County and was impressed by how good the pizza was on the first day. You can tell by the first bite that the owner uses top notch ingredients. The cheese is stringy, the crust is crunchy, and the taste of the homemade sauce brings it all together. If you are ever in Madison on a Saturday night I highly recommend you stop in at Kay Jack Pizza.
… more
Melissa Holbrook
This pizza will change your life. This pizza will instantly increase the dopamine in your brain just smelling it. This pizza tastes like happiness. The cheese is a total throwback to the time before pizza cheeses became waxy & disappointing; it stretches, it’s stringy & its chewy like it’s 1990 all over again. The toppings & ingredients are SUPER fresh and this isn’t a greasy pie. The photo attached is missing pieces because I couldn’t wait for the sauce to not be lava before I started eating it. This is an independently owned small, family business. The owner is really awesome. They’re just starting out so run out there and show ‘em some love!!
… more
JR
Very good pizza honestly some of the best I have had. Love the style the crust it’s a great all round pizza I would highly recommend over any other pizza in the area they don’t even come close.
… more
Michelle G
LOVE Kay Jack’s Pizza!!! The pepperoni, pulled pork, and buffalo chicken are my favorites! Always great customer service, crust is light and fluffy, and pizzas are not greasy at all. Recently had (8) 1/2 sheet pizzas for my bday party and there were only 5 slices leftover – plus Bill was very accommodating and made it completely convenient for me. Now I get Kay Jack’s like once a week lol. Check them out!
… more
patchouli monster
Fantastic pizza. We moved out here 2 years ago and have been searching for good pizza to no avail. Well boys, we found it. You can tell they use good quality ingredients. Just wish it had a little more sauce 🙂
… more
… View more
