Based on 363 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
220 W North Water St, New London, WI 54961
Phone: (920) 982-2333
Website: https://www.jollyrogerspizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Roxanne Dahlgren
Been there twice. Tried the fish first, that was a disappointment, could buy box fish and have a better experience. This time got a burger, bun was burnt, “with bacon” is bacon bits, ordered lettuce and tomato, never got it and their so called onion rings are shredded onion fried and burnt, service sucks also.
… more
marria marg
Recent new patron of Jolly Roger’s. This was our second time dining in for pizza. I think the pizza is great tasting! We have tried all 3 crust types with thin being the favorite. My only criticism is that both times the pizza’s could have been cooked a little longer. Both toppings & crust needed more time. Next time we will request this
… more
Gloria Hoffman
We have really come to love Jolly Rogers’ pizza, and it is now our “go-to” place. We have never been disappointed, until today. Not sure if they had someone new making the pizzas tonight, or if this was an aberration, but a little constructive criticism is warranted. While the pizza generally tasted fine, the toppings were uncharacteristically skimpy. I would guess, maybe, 1 ounce of mushrooms on the entire large pizza. (I had to take the pizza back to the counter and ask the server if they even put mushrooms on it. She pointed to two or three tiny slivers and suggested next time I order with “extra mushrooms”- huh?)Black olives, not much better. And, about half the bacon we usually see on it. Even the sauce (which we requested “on the heavy side”) was lacking. Usually, we give their pizza a “10”; today, it’s a “4”, maybe “5” tops.
… more
Bryghton
Love the pizza. Best in town. Great service. Clean place. Love it there!
… more
Name Exe Missing
It’s a very nice place to eat the food isn’t to long of a wait and if it is there is always a game of pool or darts to make yourself pleased on the wait very nice addition with the spaghetti straws and it’s always fun to see the pizza challenge.
… more
Robert Running
I had a great experience at Jolly Roger’s, the people are nice, waitress was great! I am definitely going back!
… more
Elizabeth Cross
My family loves the pizza here! We normally have it delivered. It is always delivered fast and quality is great! I also love that I can get a gluten free crust. Unfortunately no gluten free burger bun which would be nice, hopefully someday
… more
Clint Sailors
If you like sauce and no cheese this is your pizza! Heard all sorts of good things but it literally is sauce and a few veggies. Great sauce, add cheese..
… more
Steve Krause
We really enjoy their frozen pizzas and decided to try their fresh made. We loved it! The pizza was fantastic. Light and crunchy thin crust, but not tough. The sandwiches were tasty and dessert was good. Very affordable and a nice atmosphere.
… more
Orion Antonakis
I really wanted to like this place. Let’s start with the good….
… more
… View more