All-day American comfort fare in a converted home with limited seating & a no-frills interior. Based on 238 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1 S Riverside Dr, Neptune City, NJ 07753
Phone: (732) 774-9647
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 8 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Dustin Giuffrida
Great staple in the neighborhood! Their pizza is definitely some of the best in the area, as far as “regular” pizza is concerned. Their sandwiches are top notch, especially their cheese steaks. We also often pick up their dough to make our own salami/pepperoni bread (see photos attached), out of all of the places we’ve tried, John’s dough is hands down the absolute best. The only constructive criticism I could provide is that they need to slice their cold cuts thinner on their subs/hoagies.
Josh Langenberger
On the way to being lost, on the corner in the middle of a residential neighborhood, sat this tiny little, mom and pop gem. On the window it said XL pizza, pick up only at $12.95 and they had me. I love pizza and it is my most common review on another platform, so I couldn’t pass up the deal, even after having eaten dinner. Just a plain pie, I always say. If an Italian place can’t master the basics, I won’t eat anything else there. We they did it. A good pie at a great price. Simple. It’s a deli and they sell ice cream, and next time I get lost in the neighborhood, I will stop by again.
James Wilmarth
I only rated one star because I have to to write this . I ordered 2 burgers , 2 chicken fingers , and one wrap . I picked the food up and returned to the boat club. When I got there I realized that I was short one burger . I contacted them and made them aware of the situation. They told me they would make me a new one and deliver it to me. I then receive the phone call 20 minutes later that my burger is ready and that they will not deliver it to me and then if I want it delivered I will have to pay five dollars. I agreed to pay the five dollars cash and 20 minutes later I still don’t have my burger. I called him back and made them aware of it again and they told me that they’re waiting for me to make a payment with my credit card for the five dollars this point I told him forget it keep the burger and I’m going to put this on line to let everybody know that the place is ran by a bunch of little kids that have no respect for people. This is totally unprofessional and I am going to also make a point to contact the restaurant later today and tomorrow because I’d like to make the owner aware of the situation. The extreme disrespect and unprofessionalism. Don’t go to this place unless you want to be treated with this respect oh and by the way chicken fingers I got for my kids were all dried out and disgusting.
… more
Dylan Reilly
If you’re ever looking for a great deli with a wide variety of delicious, freshly prepared meals, look no further than This place. The food here is amazing! They have a great selection of deli sandwiches, salads, sides, and soups that make for a delicious meal. The customer service is second to none — the staff is friendly and accommodating, and always happy to help out with any questions you may have. The atmosphere is inviting, making it the perfect place to get lunch or dinner. Plus, the prices are great! All in all, John’s Cracker Barrel is a fantastic place to go for delicious food, and wonderful customer service. Highly recommended!
Debbie W
I’ve been going to this place since I was a little child. I’m 64 now. We use to bring soda bottles to get penny candy. It has been around long before I was born. Has changed hands a few times but has expanded into quite a great place. Breakfast, lunch and dinner is great. Their subs are big and the best. Deli with wide variety. Staff is excellent. For a country store you can’t beat it.
Sandy Riepel-Smith
We were in the car looking for food, I was looking up what was in that immediate area, saw this place, the food was fresh, and the establishment was clean. The menu is a la carte, prices are reasonable. Simple menu, my burger was good.
J Lucas
Superb little deli. Friendly and responsive staff. Excellent sandwiches. All at reasonable prices. Highly recommended place for lunch.
James Booker
Great staple in the neighborhood! Their pizza is definitely some of the best in the area, as far as “regular” pizza is concerned.
Marica –
A local GEM….and if you love a good Margherita pizza….you have to try “Grandma’s pie” the crust is covered in sesame seeds and is crispy. I also tried the eggplant parmesan sub with ricotta cheese….So far 2/2 and the service is fast and the staff is super friendly and welcoming.
Sean Sprague
Try to stop by every time I visit my home town very good food and people has change just enough to stay up-to-date by not so much that it brings back great memories
… View more