Jim’s Pizza Box Menu – Milan, OH

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Milan, OH

Jim’s Pizza Box is an Italian restaurant and pizza shop that has been serving Milan, Ohio for over sixty years. We are locally owned and operated. We credit our delicious cuisine to the time-tested recipes of our matriarch, Momma Josephine. Her Italian-American recipes are still served in our kitchens today. Most notably her pizza and pasta sauces, homemade soups, and comfort food specials. Whether you’re in the mood for pizza with a flaky, crisp crust and a soft bread dough interior or subs, baked on fresh bread with meats that makes your mouth water Jim’s Pizza Box is the place for you. Swing by or call in your order and enjoy a true taste of Italy today.

Based on 617 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Jim's Pizza Box 44846

Address:
10 N Main St, Milan, OH 44846

Phone: (419) 499-4166

Website: https://www.jimspizzabox.com/Milan-OH

Social Profile:

Hours

Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Friday 11 AM–11 PM
Saturday 11 AM–11 PM
Sunday 11 AM–9 PM
Monday Closed
Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM

Menu

Appetizers
Italian Stuffed Hot Banana Peppers
Hungarian hots with our house blend sausage and meatball mixture. Served with Mama Josephine’s sauce and Italian bread
$11.99
Mama Meatballs
Four of our house meatballs in Mama Josephine’s sauce, baked to perfection with our signature cheese blend. Served with fresh baked Italian blend
$12.99
Sauerkraut Balls
Our family’s recipe. Lightly breaded, made with sauerkraut, mixed with sausage, fried golden brown and served with our house dipping sauce
$12.99
Guido’s Sausage & Peppers
Italian sausage, served with fire roasted red peppers and Mama Josephine’s meat sauce. Topped with our signature cheese blend
$12.99
Garlic Bread With Cheese
House made garlic butter with our signature cheese blend, baked atop fresh Italian bread. Served with house made pizza sauce
$5.99
Olive Oil & Balsamic Herb Bread Dip
Olive oil, Italian herb blend, Romano cheese, and balsamic vinegar. Served with fresh baked Italian bread
$6.99
Quesadilla
Sun-dried tomato tortilla with choice of chicken, seasoned taco meat, pulled bbq pork and beef with mixed cheeses. Served with salsa and sour cream
$12.99
Nachos
Baked with mixed cheese and jalapenos. Choice of chicken, seasoned taco meat or pulled beef & pork. Topped with lettuce, fresh tomato, guacamole and sour cream
$13.99
Bacon Cheese Fries
Baked with mixed cheese and bacon. Served with our homemade ranch dressing
$9.99
BBQ Pork And Beef Fries
Baked with mixed cheese and out BBQ pork and beef
$8.99
Chili Cheese Fries
Baked with mixed cheese and out homemade chili
$8.99
Cheese Fries
Baked with mixed cheese. Served with our homemade ranch dressing
$6.99
Wings
Traditional Wings
Boneless Wings
Sauces
BBQ • Honey Mustard • Plain • Buffalo • Sweet Red Chili • Hot • Tangy Carolina Gold • Hot Garlic Parm • Rajili Spicy Ginger • Stinging Honey Garlic • Teriyaki
Subs & Sandwiches
Meatball Sub
House meatballs with Mama Josephine’s sauce and signature cheese blend
$9.99
Smitty Sub
Ham, bologna, salami, pepperoni, American and signature cheese blend. Finished with mayo, lettuce, tomato and Italian dressing
$9.99
Hot Sub
Ham, bologna, salami, pepperoni, American, signature cheese blend, house made pizza sauce
$9.99
Sausage Sub
Mild Italian sausage, sauteed onions and green peppers, signature cheese blend
$10.99
Veggie Sub
Sauteed cucumbers, onion, green peppers, mushrooms, American and signature cheese blend. Finished with lettuce, tomato and homemade ranch dressing
$9.99
Jimmy’s Grinder
Ham, bologna, salami, pepperoni, baked with American cheese. Finished wit lettuce, roasted red peppers, pickled jalapenos & our shredded cheese blend. Seasoned with oregano, re,d pepper flakes & Italian dressing. Served on a long bun
$9.99
Eggplant Parmesan Sub
Breaded eggplant, Mama Josephine’s sauce, signature cheese blend
$9.99
BLT Sub
Bacon and mixed cheese. Finished with lettuce, tomato, and mayo
$10.49
Parmesan Sandwich
Breaded chicken or veal steak, Mama Josephine’s sauce, signature cheese blend
$10.99
Breaded Chicken Or Veal Sandwich
Breaded chicken or veal steak, Josephine’s sauce, signature cheese blend
$10.99
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
American cheese baked between Texas toast slices
$8.99
BBQ Pork & Beef Sandwich
House made pork and beef braised and cooked with hours in our house made sauce. Served with bbq sauce
$9.99
Steakburger
1/4 lb hamburger with American cheese, finished with lettuce, tomato and mayo
$10.99
Wraps
Gyro
Gyro lamb meat and pizza cheese baked to perfections with lettuce, cucumber, onion, tomato and tzatziki sauce
$10.99
Chicken Caesar
Romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, shredded parmesan cheese, Caesar dressing
$10.99
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Grilled chicken, bacon, mixed cheese, lettuce, tomato and homemade ranch dressing
$11.99
Buffalo Chicken
Grilled chicken, bacon, mixed cheese, lettuce and buffalo sauce
$10.99
Veggie
Sauteed cucumbers, onion, green peppers, mushrooms, American and signature cheese blend. Finished with lettuce, tomato and homemade ranch dressing
$9.99
BLT
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, colby and signature cheese blend
$11.99
Kids
Grilled Cheese
Served with fries
$7.99
Spaghetti Or Rigatoni & Sauce
Served with applesauce
$8.99
Boneless Wings
Four boneless wings served with fries
$8.99
Create Your Own Pizza
Regular Crust
Deep Dish
Gluten Free
Toppings
Meat: Pepperoni • Sausage • Old World Sausage • Ham • Hamburger • Bacon • Meatballs • Chicken • Anchovies Veggies: Jalapenos • Spinach • Sauerkraut • Mushrooms • Green Peppers • Roasted Red Peppers • Onion • Green Olives • Black Olives • Pineapp…
Extra Cheese
Create Your Own Calzone
Cheese Calzone
Toppings
Meat: Pepperoni • Sausage • Old World Sausage • Ham • Hamburger • Bacon • Meatballs • Chicken • Anchovies Veggies: Jalapenos • Spinach • Sauerkraut • Mushrooms • Green Peppers • Roasted Red Peppers • Onion • Green Olives • Black Olives • Pineapp…
Extra Cheese
Specialty Pizzas & Calzones
Deluxe
Pepperoni, mushroom, onion, green pepper, ham, sausage
BLT
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, mixed colby & signature cheese blend
Chicken Club
Seasoned grilled chicken, bacon, colby & signature cheese blend, lettuce, tomato, mayo
Hawaiian
Ham, pineapple, bacon, signature cheese blend
Cheeseburger
Hamburger, American & signature cheese blend, lettuce, tomato, ketchup, mustard, mayo
Spinach & Stewed Tomato
Oil base, marinated spinach, stewed tomato, signature cheese blend
Veggie Alfredo
Broccoli, cauliflower, alfredo sauce, mixed colby & signature cheese blend
Taco
Seasoned meat, mixed colby and signature cheese blend, lettuce, tomato & side of taco sauce
Taco Supreme
Seasoned meat, mixed colby & signature cheese blend, lettuce, tomato, taco sauce, ranch dressing, topped with crushed Doritos
Buffalo Wing
Buffalo sauce, seasoned grilled chicken, bacon, colby & signature cheese blend
Meat Lovers
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon
Chicken Alfredo
Alfredo sauce base, seasoned grilled chicken, colby & signature cheese blend
BBQ Chicken
BBQ sauce, seasoned grilled chicken, colby & signature cheese blend
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Ranch base, seasoned grilled chicken, bacon & signature cheese blend
Old World Sausage & Peppers
Oil base, Old World sausage, roasted red peppers & signature cheese blend
Popper Calzone
Jalapeno peppers, cream cheese, mixed colby & signature cheese blend
Gyro Calzone
Gyro lamb, pizza cheese, lettuce, cucumber, onion, tomato, tzatziki sauce
BBQ Pork And Beef Calzone
House made BBQ pork and beef covered with our signature cheese blend mixed with colby
Salads
Tossed Salad
a blend of iceberg and romaine lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber and garbanzo beans with choice of dressing
$6.99
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, croutons, shredded parmesan cheese, Caesar dressing
$6.99
Taco Salad
A blend of iceberg and romaine lettuce, seasoned meat, colby cheese, tomato, black olives and Doritos. Served with taco sauce and homemade ranch dressing on the side
$13.99
Antipasto Salad
A blend of iceberg and romaine lettuce, ham, salami, American and Swiss cheese, black and green olives, pepperoncini peppers, cucumber, tomato, red onion and garbanzo beans. Choice of dressing
$13.99
Asian Chicken Salad
A blend of iceberg and romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, crispy wontons, sunflower seeds, sliced almonds. Served with Asian sesame seed dressing
$13.99
Chicken Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, chicken, croutons, shredded parmesan cheese, Caesar dressing
$11.99
Dressings:
Homemade Ranch • Italian • French • Bleu Cheese • 1000 Island • Honey Mustard • Caesar • Homemade Celery Seed • Fat Free Raspberry Vinaigrette • Asian Sesame Seed
Pasta Dishes
Spaghetti With Meatball
Spaghetti noodles and a house meatball served with Mama Jos traditional spaghetti sauce
Spaghetti With Sausage
Spaghetti noodles and an Italian sausage served with Mama Jos traditional spaghetti sauce
Baked Spaghetti
Spaghetti noodles, a house meatball, Josephine’s traditional spaghetti sauce. Covered in our signature blend of cheese and baked to perfection
$14.99
Baked Rigatoni
Penne noodles served with Josephine’s meat sauce, covered in our signature blend of cheese and baked to perfection
$13.99
Saccatino
Pasta pouches stuffed with spicy sausage blend, served with Mama Josephine’s traditional spaghetti sauce
Rigatoni
Penne noodles served with Mama Jospehine’s meat sauce
Baked Parmesan
Spaghetti noodles served with Josephine’s traditional spaghetti sauce and baked with our signature cheese blend
Baked Ravioli
Meat, cheese or combo served with Mama Josephine’s traditional spaghetti sauce
Sides
Coleslaw $2.99
Applesauce $2.99
Cottage Cheese $2.99
Fries $2.99
Side Salad Or Caesar Salad $5.99
Soups
Jims Cinci Chili
Diced onion, colby cheese, chili, over Doritos
$6.99
Soup Of The Day $5.99
Lunch Menu
Soup
Salad
With choice of dressing
Pasta
Sandwich

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

B SNOW
Awesome little pizza place in a small town. Great service and a beautiful dining area made for a wonderful experience. Their pizza is a little but thicker than I prefer but it was delicious nonetheless. Will be back when visiting CP!

… more

Bruce Seiler
Newly remodeled. We got here right after the nightly rush, so it was quiet. We ordered salad pizza, a calzone, and spaghetti. They didn’t get the salad out before the pizza which a little upsetting, but the salad was tasty. My daughter got a gluten-free pizza, which she enjoyed. My other daughter did loke the meatball but was not thrilled with the spaghetti. The sauce didn’t have much flavor. We got a large pizza with some meat and mild peppers. I love how the pizza is cut in little pieces and not slices. The pizza was delicious

… more

kevin hoettel
5 out of 10 of My chicken wings had broken bones. Had to pick out the bone shards to even try to eat. The sauce was great. Got the cheeseburger pizza and it was nasty. So much ketchup mayo and mustard I couldn’t even eat it all. Way to much lettuce also. My co worker got chicken parm and he said it was pretty good.

… more

Robert Earl
Wow! Great food! Generous helping!! Our waitress Sam was exceptionally attentive! Definitely going back !! Thanks Jim’s Pizza Box!!

… more

Snarf & Leesi
Atmosphere unknown, as we had our food delivered.We are passing through the state on our way home to Wisconsin. We found this locally owned spot and decided to order. We were NOT disappointed!! Delivery was super fast and everything was hot and delicious!! 10 out of 10 for us. Highly recommend! We will be back next time we come through! Thank you Jim’s pizza box!! Wasn’t an option below, baked spaghetti is amazing.

… more

Jillian Luy
After a bummer of a day, we ordered a large pizza from here for delivery. All three of us wolfed that pizza down! It was absolutely fresh and delicious. That ended the day on a high note. We highly recommend!

… more

Jennifer Pelham
Jim’s Pizza Box is a staple in this area. Jim’s homemade sauce and various Italian and American food items are of top quality. I have NEVER had a bad meal. The service that you receive is way above average. With the installation of the bar and now pasta every day has made Jim’s Pizza Box a restaurant for all ages and those that want more than just Pizza. I cannot say enough great comments about this treasure of a place. ❤️

… more

Tomika Watkins
I visited Sandusky for work and when I’m out of town I love to try a local pizza place. I scoured Google for food near me and came across this place and the reviews were good so I tried them. All I had was a pepperoni deep dish pizza and it was not good. No flavor whatsoever; it just tasted like cheese on thick bread. Sauce was nonexistent and bland. I ended up going to McDonald’s. But the girl on the phone and my delivery driver was great! I’m glad I can expense this meal through work and get my money back!

… more

annie hayes
Absolutely love coming into Jim’s! The food is always hot, fresh and delicious.

… more

Kim DelMonico
I have been here 2 times, when I’ve been in the area. I’m gluten and dairy free, so wasn’t sure what I would find that I could eat, but they have gluten-free pizza crust. Today I did a make-your-own pizza without the cheese and added old world sausage, black olives, and spinach. It was amazing! Everything I got last visit was delicious as well. I would definitely come back again. Highly recommend.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions