Based on 185 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3312 S Elm Pl, Broken Arrow, OK 74011
Phone: (918) 252-0333
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–6 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Amy Skeen
Pizza was good. Bottom could have been crispier but had good flavor. Cheesecake was good & had to have a cannolo. I got their “classic”. It was good, I could taste a very light hint of cinnamon but, it would have been better with a little chopped pistachios or candied orange peel or candied cherry. Just a little suggestion, something to think about. The crew working was very friendly & I assume it was the manager, maybe the owner, came around checking to make sure everyone’s food was good. Everything was clean even around the soda station (self serve) which was nice to see. My only other suggestion would be to get better paper plates to serve with the pizza. I have no problem at all using paper but I’m a cutter not a biter when the pizza is hot & I cut through the thin paper plate several times. My husband also got a salad & it was nice size. My son got a ham & mozzarella sub sandwich & he said it was really tasty. I would say 4.8 out of 5 stars. I would definitely recommend to friends and family & we will definitely go back.
… more
Christel Moser
We had originally gone to the pizza place right around the corner and got ignored so we decided to come try this one out. So glad we did! Service was phenomenal, food was fantastic and we will definitely be going again very soon.
… more
kalan scallan
Very tasty authentic New York style pizza, with robust tomato sauce taste. Unfortunately their pricing has gone up, which makes this option not very desirable. I very much enjoy the three pizza places surrounding this location, all at a reduced price. The pepperoni roll was quite a grease bomb, but very tasty! I would recommend people try this place out, as they may love it more than myself.
… more
Rayah Gilliland
Absolutely delicious pizza! very pleased with it! Great flavor and crust. The place is beautiful, updated, and clean. They even stayed open 15 minutes late for me to grab my pizza. And I even got a chance to meet the owner. Very kind people and peaceful atmosphere. Would definitely recommend.
… more
Samantha K
Being from the NY/NJ area it hard to find really good Pizza around Tulsa. But Jimmy’s hits the spot. The food is like getting a slice from home. The owner and staff are super friendly. The owner went to each table durring my last visit. He didn’t just ask them about there experience but he talked with each person like they where family and he wanted to get to know you.
… more
Bunni Love
Jimmy’s is a wonderful family man, and an amazing Boss! I’m sad that I was not able to finish my journey as a worker with Jimmy and his amazing family and crew due to my own personal reasons! Jimmy’s is the best place to eat he is a family man who likes to make people’s tummy’s happy But don’t take my word for it go get a taste of your own and you’ll definitely be back for more!!!
… more
Michael G
This slice needs its own zip code!!! It’s huge!!
… more
Anthony Diaz
Jimmy’s gets it done. Being from Brooklyn, I can tell you it’s hard to find a good slice without taking a trip back East, but Jimmy and his fam know their business. If you want authentic, tasty NY-style goodness, you won’t find better. Loved them at their 71st location, and love them even more that they’re so close here in BA. Keep making people happy with that great NY taste, Jimmy’s!
… more
DENISE PELT
I stopped in, ordered a pizza to take home. The best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Your pizza did not disappoint! I’ll be back to try some other menu items. Very friendly staff and clean restaurant. Thank you!
… more
Robert Meeder
Went for the first time last night. Had the Supreme and it was AMAZING! The sauce and crust are out of this world! Went back again for the lasagna and it’s just as good as homemade maybe a little better! The staff and owner is super nice and welcoming. We will definitely be back!
… more
… View more