Colorful, island-style restaurant & bar with a seafood-focused menu, tropical cocktails & a patio. Based on 663 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2303 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa, WI 53226
Phone: (414) 837-2121
Website: https://www.jimmysiguanabar.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 5–11 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alex Edmont
Very nice atmosphere, theme and music. Friendly staff. Good selections of beer and food. The burger was juicy with added bacon.
Paul Fenrich
We stopped by for a bite today after taking the boys to the zoo. The atmosphere is super cool! The taco plate was good, and the nachos were great. The shrimp poboy was decent, but I was missing something. The bar tender was nice. He had to take orders, man the bar, and bring food out.
Alexis Ann
This place was really nice! We ordered a shrimp plate and a calamari dish, and both were really good. The employees were really nice, and the seating area and bar seemed to be kept very clean. I hope to come back some day!
halowars2 8921
It’s a very clean bar, the guy that seems to run the whole place seems to have it down pat, kind of boring though there is no interaction with bartender since he is off running around, other then that our food was good, the sauce for shrimp was different but goods, shrimp was yummy, not a full plate was sharing , fires were yummy too, connected to a hotel
Elizabeth Brock
Came into good and friendly service. The server was very attentive and checked on us (Kristen) the manager Lori stopped by with a smile. Well run. The appetizer came out quickly and we had the proper amount of time to eat those and then the food came out . The presentation was excellent. They offer gluten free options as well. Nicely decorated. Nice atmosphere. Lively music.
Jim Clauer
No AC and no explanation. And honestly the most inattentive slow bartenders I’ve ever seen. Two bartenders should have easily been able to handle the number of guests in there. I’ve bartended in high volume venues and these guys were just weak and had no desire to be any better. Definitely won’t be returning.
Elizabeth Wolf
If you are coming here just to collect the plastic lizard action figure. Just stop. They lied. They don’t have them anymore. So kiss all your little plastic lizard adventure goodbye. Not only did we not get a lizard but the food was also mediocre. Chicken, dry. Shrimp dry. Fishie tacos dry.
Jane Lagolden
I arranged to have a party for 75 people with the assistant manager 2 months prior to the event. Also talked with him a week prior and said everything was fine and the manager would call me back with final arrangements. Left messages and didn’t call until 4 days before the party and said they couldn’t accommodate us. Who does that????
Simone Hayes
The service was great. The food was fine, it came fast and hot. I had something off the menu with chicken and peanut sauce and a dip of some sort. Not somewhere I would frequent but it got the job done for a quick drink and bite to eat.
Lisa Bauer
I ordered this meal at 4:56 for a 7:00 delivery. When the driver got here he stated “I got there just when they were putting it together “. I’m thinking great, it’s going to be hot. Wrong!! It was cold. I try to support local businesses but I live 2 miles from Jimmy’s Island Grill and spent 40.40 for a cheeseburger and fish fry and expected it to be hot. Very disappointed
… View more