Jimmy John’s Menu – Mayfield Heights, OH

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : Mayfield Heights, OH

Counter-serve chain specializing in sub & club sandwiches, plus signature potato chips. Based on 133 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Jimmy John's 44124

Address:
1314 SOM Ctr Rd, Mayfield Heights, OH 44124

Phone: (440) 446-9500

Website:

Hours

Wednesday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Thursday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Friday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Saturday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Sunday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Monday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Tuesday 10:30 AM–9 PM

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Kenya Williams
Manager Scott is very rude! Clearly messed up my sandwich and his response was “you clearly see its only 2 workers so”. Just because you are short staffed doesnt give you an excuse to be RUDE!! No customer service skills or reading skills for that matter.

… more

Leslie
Employees were very nice and were very fast. But they charged me for a pickle and then didn’t give me one, and also ignored most of my topping requests. Really disappointing.

… more

Patrick Fleming II
I called and was told quote we don’t deliver that far we only deliver to Golden Gate Plaza. So I got in my car and drove down there and everybody that was there had their hats on Sideways and no I don’t care what your boxers look like. I ordered a beach club and was told we have no tomato No guacamole and literally a sliver of onions left you still want the sandwich I wouldn’t want that what I was told. He pulled out the little pouch of guacamole that was partially frozen and said no we don’t have any guacamole and I said no it’s okay by the time I get home it will be on thawed. He proceeded to make my sandwich it was only 9:30 they close at 10 very disappointed. You can obviously see in the photos they intended on closing at 9 as the entire store was broken down already also in the picture you can see a garbage bag sitting right outside the door again you close 10 not 9:30 you should take the trash out to the back not leave it out front for your customers to kick to the side just to get in the door. Freaky fast not this time more like freaking disappointed.

… more

Ciara Norris
I ordered two little John’s and got one significantly bigger than the other ….

… more

Charles Cicirella
Delivery is super fast and they actually got out of their car and handed me the sandwich at the door of my apartment building. I like that. I don’t understand these delivery drivers who wait in their car. Now what I don’t understand is how hard is it to put peppers and mustard on the whole sandwich and not just a pepper here and there and a glob of mustard somewhere in the middle. That I do not like.

… more

Louis Johnson IV
Excellent grilled lamb burger and Adobo fries. My wife enjoyed a vegan dish.

… more

Eileen Crilley
Ordered 15 box lunches, different sandwich choices, but the ones that were to have avocado had no avocado. All of the people we serve lunch to open their sandwiches and checked, and there was not any on any sandwich that was supposed to be. called the manager who returned my call, but very much said he made the sandwiches himself and I told him there were no avocado spread on the sandwiches and he did not even offer any words of being sorry just insisted he put it on. I did a lunch for the doctors at Hillcrest Hospital. It was very disappointing and embarrassing. It doesn’t matter that he said he put it on, every single one of them looked and there was none, as I stood there embarrassed! my order was $206. I will never place an order there again, and the manager should have at least Compensated even though he thought he was right he most certainly was not. I did a professional luncheon and it was the most embarrassing thing ever. This place is not a place I would ever order for catering. I was in there the day before and ordered the Veggie that also was supposed to have avocado spread and when I opened my sandwich, it had none but I didn’t say anything about that! Again, think about it, $206.00 & not getting what you want on the sandwiches that’s supposed to be there! Totally uncalled for!

… more

Dee Thomas
Had to reconstruct the veggie sub and the sandwich artist who made it did an excellent job

… more

Mike Johnson
This review is for the Mayfield heights location. They ruined my vito today by slathering jalapenos on it. As someone who’s stomach cannot tolerate hot stuff, it ended up being a waste. I didn’t realize until I was about a half hour away. No idea WHY that would of been added as my only request was add mayo, no onion. Never again.

… more

Desiree Shaw
Went into the store and I ordered my sandwich and my husband then order two additional sandwiches. He stated that he wanted two more of the same sandwiches, without the extra toppings a second time. Once our order was prepared we relize and expressed that we ordered a risk of three sandwiches. When we advise Scott that we order a additional sandwich he looked at us with surprised and stated no you order two, we said no three sandwiches in total. He then as the left who took are order and she said nothing. SCOTT then went to the register and looked and stated she only charged you for two. We then stated that we needed three and he in a sarcastic tone said well she made a mistake and yiu need to pay for the third sandwich. No apology fir the mistake. I asked fir the first receipt to verify and he stated it was with the sandwiches, it was not. He then realized his mistake and handed me my receipt. After express hie opinion and my husband expressed his. SCOTT then thanked us and asked that WE NEVER RETURN THERE. Never should you tell a customer to not come back, because the staff messed up taking an order and the customer express their feelings. I know it’s hard to get help but settling for employees who are rude with a smile is just not okay!!!!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions