Based on 175 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
Address:
1530 Railroad Ave UNIT C, Rifle, CO 81650
Phone: (970) 625-1435
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Audra Price
Fantastic food! Some of the best steaks we have ever had. Their baked beans are amazing! Cassie B was absolutely wonderful. It is a bit pricey but it’s worth it!
… more
Maria Liverett
Absolutely tasty the meat was cooked perfectly nice little presentation I enjoyed myself and the food and the service.
… more
Sadie Hood
My family had a wonderful experience here. Great service, AMAZING food, very clean and cute little restaurant, price was a bit on the expensive side but worth it for the excellent food we received. My husband and I both got the Jay’s ribeye steak. I got the cowgirl (12oz) $29, he got the cowboy(16oz) $33. The dinner entrees come with two sides. It was all so good and plenty of food to fill us up with left overs. Would recommend this place to anyone and definitely plan on going back soon!
… more
Jody Kitchen
The food was excellent but it did not make up for the drama going on in the kitchen. We waited for over 90 minutes to get our food. The waitress was apologetic and nice but whatever problems an establishment is having, your customers should never know about it. One of the cooks walked off. But what I saw was two other managers standing around doing nothing while the one waitress took care of the entire restaurant. I don’t know what was going on in the kitchen, I don’t care to know. 90 minutes is unacceptable, regardless of your backroom drama.
… more
Tyler Wetherelt
I have been here twice and have not been disappointed. Jay uses top of the line beef to make his steaks and burgers and prepares them perfectly. Jay seems to have a real passion for the restaurant industry and each order is personal to him. The restaurant itself gives off a relaxing vibe with excellent waitresses that were courteous and prompt with their service. I would recommend this restaurant to anybody that wants generous portions and perfectly cooked food.
… more
Kris Higgins
Went for breakfast. Husband had the special..Chicken Fried Steak skillet. It was delicious. Very tender and the flavor was great! I had the steak and eggs. Steak was cooked perfect. And the potatoes served with it are wonderful!!
… more
Luke Braby
Hands down the best restaurant around that hometown service that we all enjoy plus food that is out of this world. I took my wife to Jay’s for Valentine’s tonight and we were not disappointed hand-cut steaks the lighter fare is also excellent. I can’t say enough about Jay’s Steakhouse. If you haven’t been there I recommend you check them out
… more
Netegories 99
The burgers were delicious and so were the homemade fries. This place is tucked away behind the Wells Fargo Bank. Doesn’t look like much from the outside. Very clean! Very nice atmosphere. Small and quaint.
… more
B V
The cook (who I believe to be the owner) could tell I was frustrated and took my appetizer order, waitress was way off que. Was able to get a food order finally and when arrived I was less than impressed. They have great potential yet how things are I highly doubt I’ll ever be back.
… more
Jessie Smith
SO GOOD!! We have only lived in rifle two years so far and for the first year here we heard nothing but good things about Jay’s. My only regret is not trying this place sooner! Jay’s is one of our favorite restaurants in the area and our usual dinner date spot. The food and staff are always above and beyond.
… more
… View more