Based on 76 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
114 E Lincoln Ave, McDonald, PA 15057
Phone: (724) 926-8100
Hours
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Brittany Boeltz
The food was absolutely amazing! Portions are huge and we had lots of left overs. Staff are friendly and building is clean. My sons 16th was catered by Michele at Jays Pizza and my guests raved about the food. I had people call me after asking wheee the food was from because they want to book future parties. The price is totally responsible and I promise you the quality/taste is out of this world. Your guest will go home happy and full! Thank you Jays pizza for going the extra mile and writing a birthday message to my son! We will be back! Can’t wait to try to the pizza!
… more
Peter Allyn
We called to order fish sandwiches every Friday for a month only for the owner to tell us that they werent serving them until “maybe October” and were upset with us for calling “too early” even though it was just before 11am! Tried getting sandwiches when they “available” and they were always sold out. They told us to preorder the fish sandwiches ahead of time, and then got angry that we called them too early in the day we will make our own fish sandwiches.
… more
Sam Evans
It was like eating a soggy brick. The crust was incredibly overcooked and rock hard. It was drowned in grease to the point most of the cheese had slid off by the time it made it home. The grease had actually spilled out of the pizza box and onto my passenger seat. Tremendous disappointment.
… more
Tonya Wisor
Just ordered lunch from here today, it was delicious! I got a slice of pepperoni deep dish pizza and a 1/2 club sub, both delicious. The sub had so much meat on it that i could only eat less than half of it!
… more
William Merriman
If you’ve never tried Jays deep dish pizza it is a treat!! Michelle takes great pride in this pizza and it is wonderful!! If you’re looking for something different try it!! It’s a hearty pizza that requires two hands to eat and you can add all your favorite toppings. Don’t be surprised if Michelle gives specific instructions on how to get this masterpiece home safely, lol!! Everyone’s idea of a good pizza varies but if you try it, I hope you enjoy it as much as we do!! You also have the option to use slice, order your delicious pizza using the slice App and pick it up at the time you choose, you can also pay with a credit card with the app as well.
… more
Richard Lazzini
This place is like stepping into the past I’ve been getting pizza here since I was 10 years old and even know there is a new owner it still tastes like it always been for ever so good I would highly recommend eating here you won’t regret it
… more
Stephen Cooper
Somehow three pizzas run you 75 bucks here. The pizza was half baked and was basically raw. Will not order from here ever again. Shame
… more
Melissa Mowry
Today was the first time trying Jays Pizza after following them for quite some time on fb and I’m kicking myself for not ordering sooner. My bf and I got their Super Bowl package deal which included- 12 cut 1 topping pizza, whole Italian hoagie, and either 12 wings or a large pepperoni roll (we chose the wings). I was hesitant ordering wings with sauce bc I like to make my own but we decided to order the wings in mild sauce and they were PERFECTION. The pizza was perfectly, delicious, and cheesy squared cuts just how I like it. Their hoagie was HUGE and they do not disappoint on the meat, and the lettuce and tomato was fresh. It’s always nice to bite into a hoagie to crisp lettuce instead of soggy mush lettuce. We will definitely be ordering from them again soon. And a HUGE shoutout to a WOMAN OWNED BUSINESS who’s doing it RIGHT!!!
… more
Barbie Lazzini
Haven’t had Jay’s pizza in at least 17yrs and I’m super stoked that after all this time and inflation rising that their pizza is STILL phenomenal and one of a kind! Jay’s is definitely worth the trip and I definitely recommend you try it if you’ve never had Jay’s pizza ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… more
Chu-Yi Tan
Giving one star solely on the fact that the owner lady was horrible at customer service and was not at all helpful she cant even write my order down right. After she passed the phone to the manager, i found out she didn’t even write my order down. The gentleman who helped me after that was extremely helpful and kind. Worse customer service from who was supposed to be the owner on the place.
… more
… View more