Based on 62 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
200 S Main St, Sheridan, IN 46069
Phone: (317) 758-6660
Hours
| Sunday | 5–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 5–9 PM |
| Thursday | 5–9 PM |
| Friday | 5–10 PM |
| Saturday | 5–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Ashley
I worked there over 10 yrs ago and the experience was terrible. Almost a decade later, I order a pizza from them.. it was over 2 hours late, and when I called they told me that my order hadn’t even been made yet. Jan is very friendly at first, but when you start working for her she becomes very disrespectful and rude. Her daughter worked there on weekends to help out sometimes and she would say horrible things such as “Jan hire’s retards.” I nearly walked out after hearing that comment and looking back from the perspective of someone who is nearly a decade older than I was during that time, I should have right then. The husband has a brain so fried, you know exactly what he was doing in the 60’s. He’s a complete burnout, and Jan is constantly yelling at him because he is incompetent. It’s just a complete mess of an establishment. Your food will not be made with love there. And it is true, when I worked there… no one used gloves in the kitchen.
… more
Summer Hewitt
Eek.. i don’t know. I know some people rave about this. But I haven’t even had a bite, but idk if I want to.. very dirty, no gloves are being used. Saw them eat food, then continue to make food for customers.
… more
Pam Harris
We ordered a chef salad, fajita chicken salad and bread sticks. Breadsticks was good. The chef salad was not good, had mostly all lettuce, no spinach, red onions, cheese and then maybe we got two pieces of ham. Then the fajita chicken salad – no spinach, red onions, hardly no cheese, no chicken just mostly lettuce. Also I need to update the prices online. I called back to the Sheridan place and the girl who was working, wanted to argue with me. That she made the salads and they are right. Will not be going back there. Not happy at all. Customer service terrible.
… more
Becca Love
My husband and I love the pizza here! The bad reviews complaining about salad… this is a pizza place not a salad restaurant. The pizza is great, breadsticks are okay. I wish prices were a bit cheaper but we are happy to support local!
… more
Mr Ian Cook
Note that this is Jan’s pizza, not Jan’s salad bar! Pizza was really good, salad was really poor. Not all listed ingredients were in the salad which was mostly lettuce. Our online order was ready on time, lots of cheese on pizza.
… more
Windy J
The few bites we were able to eat were very good. The problem is that after a few bites, my friend pulled a six inch hair out of his mouth that he had just eaten off of the pizza. Disgusting. We were super disappointed, especially because this is something that can easily be prevented with a hair net. They did refund our money with no issue, which is why it isn’t a 1 star review, but we still didn’t get to enjoy our pizza.
… more
Timothy Harris
Got a chef salad and a chicken fagti salad and a order of bread sticks with cheese.it cost$25.35 it said on line the salads were supposed to be $6.79 each and bread sticks $4.49.Not sure what taxes are but when I add that up I come up just a little over $18.The salad had very little meat and cheese mostly lettuce close to being the worse salad I ever had.I could of went to the Dollar store and made my own for less and made it 90 % better.Dont mind paying for something but I also expect to get something decent.Defintely will not go back.This was the Jan’s in Sheridan.
… more
Travis Alexander
Three times now I have tried to get delivery no driver and even before that the other times the pizza was garbage I usually don’t like to talk bad about small businesses but this one is not worth the price anymore for sure
… more
M M
The over priced pizza was decent, the small frozen and fried wings were pretty bad if you are comparing them to good wings. The part I didn’t like the most is when you are charging premium prices for non premium pizza you figure it’s because the employees are being taken care of so it’s like okay I’m good with that, but when they add a tip charge to your already overpriced carry-out order then you go to pick it up and there is a tip jar also… It makes it very difficult to justify those prices. Specially in a town with low rent. Tells me I’m padding the wallet of a very greedy owner. On the principal that im not okay with extortion, I won’t be eating here again. Hey owner I would love to hear your response to this. How much are you paying your employees hourly before you force a tip then ask for another one? How much are you profiting from high prices and low wages?
… more
Liberty for All C
Save yourself the frustration from ordering this pizza. Under cooked, over topped with cheese, and the bland flavor of the pizza left me speechless hunger and still looking for dinner.
… more
… View more